So let’s see if I get the various points some folks are insisting on.
1). Without US material and Financial and eventually Military Support The Entaunt is somehow going to win a way that they just Barely won with this support
2) in fact not having the US support will HELP them and they will do butter
3) not have the crutch of US support will cause thier Generals to realize the stupidity of thier ways and to invent better more practical tactics.
4) With the US starting off as a CO from day one not a SIngle country will even consider staying neutral. Because OBVIOUSLY Russia, France and England against Germany, AH, and the US is any easy fight. So country’s will be lining up to join the obvious victors.
5). Japan a country that had reasonable relations with the US at the time and that joined the war to basically grab some colonies from a distract Germany and otherwise did basically nothing in the real timeline is going to jump in with both feet against the US because... reasons.
6) in fact Hapan is not only going to jump in but is going to Kick the US’s but.
7)Canada, a country with EXTRODINARY ties economically to the US is going to not hesitate to declare war on the US. Because “God bless the KING!”
8) Canada has never had anyone ever suggest that maybe they should be independent. Unlike, Ireland, Scotland, India and pretty much every single English possession in history presumably because “God safe the King”
9). Quebec in 1914 was fiercely loyal to Canada and England and would NEVER have any subgroup try to take advantage of the war to gain independence from England/Canada. Apparently that independent streak only existed in the 1800s and then was reborn after WW2. So WW1 was a magical time when all folks in Quebec and the rest of Canada were fiercely loyal.
10). Canada is going to be able to easily resist the US. Because historically countries outnumbered over 12 to 1 in people, the size of its military, military spending, navel power, industries and finance have ALWAS been able to one the day because thier hearts are pure.
11). England is going to divert all its colonies military to support Canada (not that Canada needs it, see point 10)
12) Diverting said troops will not hurt England’s war against Germany, because... reasons.
13) in fact England will send its BEF to the US instead of Germany (this one I actually think may happen)
14). Sending the BEF to Canada will somehow not lose France the way. Just because Germany came close to winning against France AND England in the first offense and then again in the march to the sea. But apparently without England’s help France will do just fine.
15). England can easily get its troops to Canada because the US Navy is a joke. And can do nothing to stop this.
16). In fact if the US Navy tries to stop it England will just brush it aside with practically no lose.
17). England can use its entire navy against the US (not that it needs it) because Germany and it’s Navy won’t try anything... because reasons
18). England had so much extra shipping that it can easily still ship everything it did in WW1 and still have ships to send the BEF to Canada and support it.
19). Not that Canada needs this support because it can take the US all by itself. (I need to make that perfectly clear so I am repeating it so our Canadian members don’t get offended)
20). Apparently the US and it’s military, material and financial support were of no perticular use to anyone and in fact France and England would have been better off without them...
I could go on but I think you get my point by now.
So in short Canada outnumbered by over 12 to 1 will win the War against the US because they eat more maple syrup then the US does. And as a result of this thier will be no one in all of Canada that things going to war with the US is a bad idea.
Now once the ASB go home the reality is that England has alwas worried about England and damn the colonies, So odds are England will send 0 support to Canada as England is worried about Germany and it dominating Europe, This is why England entered the war and didn’t stay neutral. It is not like England has a long time love of France,
This means that Canada is on its own against a country it CAN NOT BEAT. It is outnumbered and out produced and out financed by way way to much. It has no natural defenses and 90% of everything but land is within 100 miles of the US. And much of that is all but on the boarder as the two countries are very close economical to each other.
Not everyone in Canada in 1914 was a diehard defender of the Empire. And some sections of Canada did not even want to be Canadians much less English.
Only a fool would not expect that after the US wins against Canada the will all but End Canada. The will (odds on) take the western section in part to Connect Alaska, in part for its national resources. It will probably take everything touching the Great Lakes and it will “rationalize” the boarder here and there. It will probably also devide up the remains to give anyone interested thier own country. So anyone can see that Canada wins or it goes away (for all practical purposes). And the odds against Canada winning are so long as to be ASB level.
So it is Logical for Canada to look at this and say “No thanks”. We are staying out, And I have to think that most Canadians are more loyal to Canada then to England/the Empire. The question is are Canadians smart enough back then to realize that the Empire is only loyal to England and England is NOT loyal to anyone but England ? Buy this I mean that England will defend and or help anyone in the Empire right up to the point of it being in England’s better interest to do something else, the Empire has alwas been England first.
Of course this raises the possibility that England may give Canada its independence just to avoid a war in America at the same time it is fighting Germany,
1). Without US material and Financial and eventually Military Support The Entaunt is somehow going to win a way that they just Barely won with this support
2) in fact not having the US support will HELP them and they will do butter
3) not have the crutch of US support will cause thier Generals to realize the stupidity of thier ways and to invent better more practical tactics.
4) With the US starting off as a CO from day one not a SIngle country will even consider staying neutral. Because OBVIOUSLY Russia, France and England against Germany, AH, and the US is any easy fight. So country’s will be lining up to join the obvious victors.
5). Japan a country that had reasonable relations with the US at the time and that joined the war to basically grab some colonies from a distract Germany and otherwise did basically nothing in the real timeline is going to jump in with both feet against the US because... reasons.
6) in fact Hapan is not only going to jump in but is going to Kick the US’s but.
7)Canada, a country with EXTRODINARY ties economically to the US is going to not hesitate to declare war on the US. Because “God bless the KING!”
8) Canada has never had anyone ever suggest that maybe they should be independent. Unlike, Ireland, Scotland, India and pretty much every single English possession in history presumably because “God safe the King”
9). Quebec in 1914 was fiercely loyal to Canada and England and would NEVER have any subgroup try to take advantage of the war to gain independence from England/Canada. Apparently that independent streak only existed in the 1800s and then was reborn after WW2. So WW1 was a magical time when all folks in Quebec and the rest of Canada were fiercely loyal.
10). Canada is going to be able to easily resist the US. Because historically countries outnumbered over 12 to 1 in people, the size of its military, military spending, navel power, industries and finance have ALWAS been able to one the day because thier hearts are pure.
11). England is going to divert all its colonies military to support Canada (not that Canada needs it, see point 10)
12) Diverting said troops will not hurt England’s war against Germany, because... reasons.
13) in fact England will send its BEF to the US instead of Germany (this one I actually think may happen)
14). Sending the BEF to Canada will somehow not lose France the way. Just because Germany came close to winning against France AND England in the first offense and then again in the march to the sea. But apparently without England’s help France will do just fine.
15). England can easily get its troops to Canada because the US Navy is a joke. And can do nothing to stop this.
16). In fact if the US Navy tries to stop it England will just brush it aside with practically no lose.
17). England can use its entire navy against the US (not that it needs it) because Germany and it’s Navy won’t try anything... because reasons
18). England had so much extra shipping that it can easily still ship everything it did in WW1 and still have ships to send the BEF to Canada and support it.
19). Not that Canada needs this support because it can take the US all by itself. (I need to make that perfectly clear so I am repeating it so our Canadian members don’t get offended)
20). Apparently the US and it’s military, material and financial support were of no perticular use to anyone and in fact France and England would have been better off without them...
I could go on but I think you get my point by now.
So in short Canada outnumbered by over 12 to 1 will win the War against the US because they eat more maple syrup then the US does. And as a result of this thier will be no one in all of Canada that things going to war with the US is a bad idea.
Now once the ASB go home the reality is that England has alwas worried about England and damn the colonies, So odds are England will send 0 support to Canada as England is worried about Germany and it dominating Europe, This is why England entered the war and didn’t stay neutral. It is not like England has a long time love of France,
This means that Canada is on its own against a country it CAN NOT BEAT. It is outnumbered and out produced and out financed by way way to much. It has no natural defenses and 90% of everything but land is within 100 miles of the US. And much of that is all but on the boarder as the two countries are very close economical to each other.
Not everyone in Canada in 1914 was a diehard defender of the Empire. And some sections of Canada did not even want to be Canadians much less English.
Only a fool would not expect that after the US wins against Canada the will all but End Canada. The will (odds on) take the western section in part to Connect Alaska, in part for its national resources. It will probably take everything touching the Great Lakes and it will “rationalize” the boarder here and there. It will probably also devide up the remains to give anyone interested thier own country. So anyone can see that Canada wins or it goes away (for all practical purposes). And the odds against Canada winning are so long as to be ASB level.
So it is Logical for Canada to look at this and say “No thanks”. We are staying out, And I have to think that most Canadians are more loyal to Canada then to England/the Empire. The question is are Canadians smart enough back then to realize that the Empire is only loyal to England and England is NOT loyal to anyone but England ? Buy this I mean that England will defend and or help anyone in the Empire right up to the point of it being in England’s better interest to do something else, the Empire has alwas been England first.
Of course this raises the possibility that England may give Canada its independence just to avoid a war in America at the same time it is fighting Germany,