Prologue 1: The Compromise of 1850
JJohnson
Banned
Dixie Forever
Prologue: The Compromise of 1850
The Compromise of 1850 was an ominous sign of things to come for the young republic known as the United States of America.
During the war with Mexico, the United States’ representative with Mexico negotiated the settlement, whereby Mexico would lose over half its territory (62.7%), and would recognize the independence of Yucatan. The total amount gained by the United States was 1,279,871 mi2 (3,345,019 km2). Some wanted the United States to annex all of Mexico; others wanted nothing to do with it. Some wanted more land to take their servants/slaves, while others wanted to restrict the practice to the southeast to leave land for white settlement in the west. Many varying forces wanted the land, either for their belief in Manifest Destiny, the expansion of African slavery, new lands, new exploration, or a number of other reasons.
The issue came when California petitioned to join the Union as a state, claiming a territory extending entirely to the end of the Baja peninsula. Before the state came into the Union, southerners in southern half had brought their slaves with them, set up farms, and claimed a government based in San Diego. Northerners had ventured into the state for gold and land, and wanted the entire state to be a ‘free state.’
As part of the compromise, Texas ceded land north of 36°30’ and west of the 100° W, but both the Texans and southern Californians demanded the cession of southern California as another ‘slave state,’ as part of the deal. Northern Californians objected, wanting the entirety of California, for the land, for the gold, and to keep out the slaves.
In the end, Congress’s authority over the territories of the United States won out, and the proposed state of California was split evenly across the 37th parallel, in line with Indian Territory and Arizona Territory. Both southern and northern California would be admitted as states, the southern a slave state, and northern a free state. The compromise also organized the territory of Rio Grande, Chihuahua, and Sonora, south of Texas and Arizona Territory. Since river access and sea access was important for commerce, Arizona Territory’s southern border was adjusted to 31° N so that it would have sea access.
Textbook map of the Compromise of 1850, showing Northern and Southern California separated at the 37th parallel
The freshman Whig congressman from Illinois, Abraham Lincoln, criticized both President Polk and the war, saying it was immoral, pro-slavery, and a threat to the nation’s republican values. His views were not uncommon from where he came.
Whig Congressman, Abraham Lincoln
Meanwhile, south of Texas in the Territory of Rio Grande, the black, white, red flag with three stars flew up the flagpole in triumphant shouts of joy at the parties people were having, being free of Mexico. They were sure of the security and freedom they would now have being in the United States. It was the next best thing to being an independent nation, since the United States was built on state sovereignty, the Anglos said. States were sovereign in everything but those specific powers delegated to the federal government, which had no power to interfere in their own internal affairs. If it did, then the compact between them would be dissolved, just like any contract. There would be no Santa Anna in the United States, waging war on the states.
Flag of the US Territory of Rio Grande, the same as the former Republic of Rio Grande
Southern California cheered when they got the news and their separate statehood was affirmed by the Congress three thousand miles away. The new Southern California flag was flown at the temporary state house in San Diego, and the people of the new state immediately began working towards bringing in more investment and people from their old homes back east. Georgia, Louisiana, North and South Carolina, Kentucky and Tennessee, and even Texas – all the southern states parted with some of their men and women to populate their new fellow southern state. Along with them, body servants and slaves came to try to make the desert state bloom.
Flag of Southern California
Some people in New England, on their legislatures and in their newspapers, however threatened secession. Four times before, in 1802-1803, in 1811-12, in 1814, and in 1844-45, people in the north threatened secession and this would make the fifth. First, Colonel Timothy Pickering of Massachusetts, friend of George Washington, of Massachusetts, and member of his cabinet; second from Josiah Quincy, another distinguished citizen of Massachusetts; third from the Hartford Convention of 1814; fourth from the Legislature of Massachusetts. Josiah Quincy, in the debate on the admission of Louisiana to the Union, on January 14, 1811, declares his “deliberate opinion that, if the bill passes, the bonds of this Union are virtually dissolved,…as it will be the right of all [the States], so it will be the duty of some, to prepare definitely for a separation, - amicably if they can, violently if they must.” In 1839, John Quincy Adams declared that “the people of each State have a right to secede from the Confederated Union.”
In 1844, and again in 1845, the Legislature of Massachusetts reiterated its right to secede, and threatened to exercise that right if Texas were admitted to the Union:
“The Commonwealth of Massachusetts, faithful to the compact between the people of the United States, according to the plain meaning and intent in which it was understood by them, is sincerely anxious for its preservation, but it is determined, as it doubts not the other States are, to submit to undelegated powers in no body of men on earth.”
Not even the Oregon Treaty ameliorated the abolitionists and other New Englanders; President Polk wanted Texas, but agreed to a treaty with the United Kingdom, based on the existence of US settlers north of the 49th parallel, the existing border between the US and British North America. This new treaty gave the US all land west of the Continental Divide in the Rockies, and south of the 52° N parallel.
Every time the United States acquired more territory it seemed as if New England threatened to secede. But it wouldn't be the North which would carry out the threat.
-------This timeline is inspired by the Union Forever timeline from Mac Gregor, and Dominion of Southern America from Glen. I hope to make this as detailed and fun as his timeline is.
The Compromise of 1850 was an ominous sign of things to come for the young republic known as the United States of America.
During the war with Mexico, the United States’ representative with Mexico negotiated the settlement, whereby Mexico would lose over half its territory (62.7%), and would recognize the independence of Yucatan. The total amount gained by the United States was 1,279,871 mi2 (3,345,019 km2). Some wanted the United States to annex all of Mexico; others wanted nothing to do with it. Some wanted more land to take their servants/slaves, while others wanted to restrict the practice to the southeast to leave land for white settlement in the west. Many varying forces wanted the land, either for their belief in Manifest Destiny, the expansion of African slavery, new lands, new exploration, or a number of other reasons.
The issue came when California petitioned to join the Union as a state, claiming a territory extending entirely to the end of the Baja peninsula. Before the state came into the Union, southerners in southern half had brought their slaves with them, set up farms, and claimed a government based in San Diego. Northerners had ventured into the state for gold and land, and wanted the entire state to be a ‘free state.’
As part of the compromise, Texas ceded land north of 36°30’ and west of the 100° W, but both the Texans and southern Californians demanded the cession of southern California as another ‘slave state,’ as part of the deal. Northern Californians objected, wanting the entirety of California, for the land, for the gold, and to keep out the slaves.
In the end, Congress’s authority over the territories of the United States won out, and the proposed state of California was split evenly across the 37th parallel, in line with Indian Territory and Arizona Territory. Both southern and northern California would be admitted as states, the southern a slave state, and northern a free state. The compromise also organized the territory of Rio Grande, Chihuahua, and Sonora, south of Texas and Arizona Territory. Since river access and sea access was important for commerce, Arizona Territory’s southern border was adjusted to 31° N so that it would have sea access.
Textbook map of the Compromise of 1850, showing Northern and Southern California separated at the 37th parallel
The freshman Whig congressman from Illinois, Abraham Lincoln, criticized both President Polk and the war, saying it was immoral, pro-slavery, and a threat to the nation’s republican values. His views were not uncommon from where he came.
Whig Congressman, Abraham Lincoln
Meanwhile, south of Texas in the Territory of Rio Grande, the black, white, red flag with three stars flew up the flagpole in triumphant shouts of joy at the parties people were having, being free of Mexico. They were sure of the security and freedom they would now have being in the United States. It was the next best thing to being an independent nation, since the United States was built on state sovereignty, the Anglos said. States were sovereign in everything but those specific powers delegated to the federal government, which had no power to interfere in their own internal affairs. If it did, then the compact between them would be dissolved, just like any contract. There would be no Santa Anna in the United States, waging war on the states.
Flag of the US Territory of Rio Grande, the same as the former Republic of Rio Grande
Southern California cheered when they got the news and their separate statehood was affirmed by the Congress three thousand miles away. The new Southern California flag was flown at the temporary state house in San Diego, and the people of the new state immediately began working towards bringing in more investment and people from their old homes back east. Georgia, Louisiana, North and South Carolina, Kentucky and Tennessee, and even Texas – all the southern states parted with some of their men and women to populate their new fellow southern state. Along with them, body servants and slaves came to try to make the desert state bloom.
Flag of Southern California
Some people in New England, on their legislatures and in their newspapers, however threatened secession. Four times before, in 1802-1803, in 1811-12, in 1814, and in 1844-45, people in the north threatened secession and this would make the fifth. First, Colonel Timothy Pickering of Massachusetts, friend of George Washington, of Massachusetts, and member of his cabinet; second from Josiah Quincy, another distinguished citizen of Massachusetts; third from the Hartford Convention of 1814; fourth from the Legislature of Massachusetts. Josiah Quincy, in the debate on the admission of Louisiana to the Union, on January 14, 1811, declares his “deliberate opinion that, if the bill passes, the bonds of this Union are virtually dissolved,…as it will be the right of all [the States], so it will be the duty of some, to prepare definitely for a separation, - amicably if they can, violently if they must.” In 1839, John Quincy Adams declared that “the people of each State have a right to secede from the Confederated Union.”
In 1844, and again in 1845, the Legislature of Massachusetts reiterated its right to secede, and threatened to exercise that right if Texas were admitted to the Union:
“The Commonwealth of Massachusetts, faithful to the compact between the people of the United States, according to the plain meaning and intent in which it was understood by them, is sincerely anxious for its preservation, but it is determined, as it doubts not the other States are, to submit to undelegated powers in no body of men on earth.”
Not even the Oregon Treaty ameliorated the abolitionists and other New Englanders; President Polk wanted Texas, but agreed to a treaty with the United Kingdom, based on the existence of US settlers north of the 49th parallel, the existing border between the US and British North America. This new treaty gave the US all land west of the Continental Divide in the Rockies, and south of the 52° N parallel.
Every time the United States acquired more territory it seemed as if New England threatened to secede. But it wouldn't be the North which would carry out the threat.
-------
Last edited: