The Alternate Cabinets Thread

The Curtis Cabinet 1937 (Kaiserreich)

President: Charles Curtis
Vice President: Quentin Roosevelt
Secretary of State: Arthur H Vanderburg
Secretary of the Navy: Leroy Grummon
Secretary of the Treasury: George Norris
Postmaster General: Robert H Jackson
Attorney General: William Borah
Secretary of the Interior: Hugh S. Gibson
Secretary of Agriculture: Alf M. Landon
Secretary of Commerce: John J. McCloy
Secretary of Labor: Fiorello LaGurdia

Speaker of the House: John N. Garner
Senate Majority Leader: Charles L. McNary
President Pro Tempore of the Senate: Hiram Johnson
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court: Louis Brandeis
Head of the FBI: J. Edgar Hoover
 
President: William Jennings Bryan (D-NE)
Vice President: Adlai Stevenson (D-IL)
Secretary of State: Joseph C. S. Blackburn (D-KY)
Secretary of the Treasury: Henry M. Teller (SR-CO)
Secretary of War: Claude Matthews (D-IN)
Attorney General: James Hogg (D-TX)
Postmaster General: John R. McLean (D-OH)
Secretary of the Navy: George Gray (D-DE)
Secretary of the Interior: Thomas E. Watson (P-GA)
Secretary of Agriculture: Marion Butler (P-NC)
Secretary of Commerce and Labor: James H. Kyle (P-SD)

Ambassador to the United Kingdom: Richard P. Bland (D-MO)
Ambassador to France: Clifton R. Breckinridge (D-AR)

Chair of the Federal Bureau of Coin: Alexander del Mar (S-NY)
 
Last edited:
Yani Cabinet (Indonesia)
POD: Late on 30th September, Soeharto decides to report to Commander of the Army Ahmad Yani that there will be a kidnapping attempt that night. Yani rallies the Army to him and launches a movement against the group of middle-ranked officers called the 30th September Movement as well as overthrowing Soekarno in a coup. At the 1965 Special Session of the Provisional People's Consultative Assembly (MPRS) Ahmad Yani becomes the 2nd President of the Republic of Indonesia. The following is his cabinet:

President: Gen. Ahmad Yani
Vice President: KH Idham Chalid

Minister of Home Affairs: Lt. Gen. Ibrahim Adjie
Minister of Foreign Affairs: Adam Malik
Minister of Defense and Security: Lt. Gen. Sarbini
Minister of Justice: Prof. Dr. Mochtar Kusumaatmadja
Minister of Information: Maj. Gen. Basuki Rachmat
Minister of Finance: Sri Sultan Hamengkubuwono IX
Minister of Industry: Maj. Gen. M. Jusuf
Minister of Trade: Prof. Dr. Ali Wardhana
Minister of Agriculture: Prof. Dr. Widjojo Nitisastro
Minister of Transportation: Maj. Gen. Darjatmo
Minister of Public Works and Electricity: Ir. Sutami
Minister of Mining: Maj. Gen. Ibnu Sutowo
Minister of Manpower: Maj. Gen. (Pol.) Hoegeng
Minister of Religion: KH Ahmad Sjaichu
Minister of Health: Brig. Gen. Azil Wijayakusuma
Minister of Education and Culture:
Minister of Social Affairs:
Frans Seda

Commander of the Army:
Lt. Gen. Soeharto
Commander of the Navy: Adm. Martadinata
Commander of the Air Force: Commodore. Rusmin Nurjadin
Commander of the Police: Police. Gen. Soejipto Joedodihardjo

State Secretary:
Lt. Gen. Soeprapto
Cabinet Secretary: Lt. Gen. MT Harjono
Attorney General: Maj. Gen. Sutoyo Siswomihardjo
Chief of Intellignce: Lt. Gen. S. Parman
 
No snap election called, and Article 50 triggered in November rather than March.

Theresa May, June 2016
Cabinet Members

Prime Minister - Theresa May MP
First Secretary and Leader of the House of Commons - Damian Green MP
Chancellor of the Exchequer - Phillip Hammond MP
Home Secretary - Amber Rudd MP
Foreign Secretary - Dr Liam Fox MP
Brexit Secretary - David Davis MP
Business and International Trade Secretary - Boris Johnson MP
Defence Secretary - Sir Michael Fallon MP
Lord Chancellor and Justice Secretary - Sajid Javid MP
Education Secretary and Equalities Minister - Justine Greening MP
Health and Social Care Secretary - Dr Greg Clark MP
Housing, Communities and Local Government - Liz Truss MP
Transport Secretary - Chris Grayling MP
Scotland Secretary - David Mundell MP
Wales Secretary - Alun Cairns MP
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Secretary - Oliver Letwin MP
Northern Ireland Secretary - James Brokenshire MP
International Development Secretary - Penny Mordaunt MP
Work and Pensions Secretary - David Gauke MP
Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Secretary - Priti Patel MP
Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster - David Lidington MP
Chief Secretary to the Treasury and City Minister - Andrea Leadsom MP

Attending Cabinet
Minister for the Cabinet Office and Paymaster General - Ben Gummer MP
Minister without Portfolio - Jeremy Hunt MP
Minister without Portfolio - Brandon Lewis MP (also Party Chairman)
Leader of the House of Lords and Lord Privy Seal - Baroness Natalie Evans
Chief Whip and Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury - Gavin Williamson MP
Minister of State for Immigration - Karen Bradley MP
Minister of State for Energy and Climate Change - Matt Hancock MP
Minister of State for Mental Health and Social Care - Anne Milton MP
Attorney-General for England and Wales - Stephen Phillips MP

Junior Ministers and Other Appointments of Note (Non-Cabinet)
Financial Secretary to the Treasury - Margot James MP
Minister of State for European Affairs (FCO/Brexit) - Baroness Joyce Anelay
Minister of State for Courts and Justice – Rt Hon Jeremy Wright QC MP
Minister of State for Universities, Science, Research and Innovation (Bus/Ed) - Sam Gyimah MP
Minister of State for Housing and Planning and Minister for London - Jo Johnson MP
Minister of State for Digital and Culture - Rt Hon Greg Hands MP
Minister of State for Transport - Robert Goodwill MP
Minister of State for Transport - John Hayes MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport - Jesse Norman MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for EU Negotiations - Suella Fernandes MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport - Andrew Jones MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Work and Pensions - Caroline Nokes MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Justice - Phillip Lee MP
Treasurer of the Household and Deputy Government Chief Whip - Mike Penning MP
Deputy Leader of the House of Commons and Minister for the Constitution - Chris Skidmore MP
Deputy Chairman of the Conservative Party - James Cleverly MP

Changes
August 2017:
David Davis and Michael Fallon leave government, replaced by Michael Gove and Jeremy Hunt respectively. Goodwill replaces Hunt as Minister without Portfolio, and Andrew Jones replaces Goodwill as Minister of State for Transport. Nus Ghani enters government, replacing Jones as Under Secretary.

October 2017:
Baroness Joyce Anelay steps down due to ill health, replaced as Minister of State for European Affairs by Dominic Raab MP.

December 2017:
Damian Green leaves government.

January 2018:
Reshuffle to replace Green, James Brokenshire steps down citing ill health. Karen Bradley replaces Green as Leader of the House of Commons, and Mark Harper enters government replacing Brokenshire as Northern Ireland Secretary. Caroline Nokes replaces Bradley as Minister of State for Immigration. Nokes is replaced by Kit Malthouse, who enters government.

John Hayes steps down, replaced by Jo Johnson. Johnson is replaced by Nick Boles, who enters government.

Chris Skidmore becomes CCHQ Vice Chair for Policy Development, Oliver Dowden enters government replacing him as Deputy Leader of the House of Commons and Minister for the Constitution. Nigel Adams becomes CCHQ Vice Chair for North England, Kemi Badenoch AM and Brian Whittle MSP are appointed as CCHQ Vice Chairs for Candidates, Reham Chisti MP and Helen Grant MP are appointed as CCHQ Vice Chairs for Communities.

April 2018:
Amber Rudd MP resigns due to the Windrush Scandal. Sajid Javid replaces her, James Brokenshire re-enters government replacing Javid as Justice Secretary.

June 2018:
Phillip Lee resigns as Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Justice, replaced by Edward Argar MP.

Greg Hands resigns as Minister of State for Digital and Culture, replaced by Margot James. James is replaced as Financial Secretary by Mel Stride MP, a whip (Lord Commissioner to the Treasury). Stride is replaced as a whip by Chris Heaton-Harris MP, an Assistant Whip. Heaton-Harris is replaced by Jo Churchill MP, who enters government.
 
A bit of a shameless plug, but I don't think I've put this down on "paper" in Alternate Cabinets yet. Also it has the advantage of getting into some of the weeds because there's such fun to be had at the intra-departmental level too. The initial Cabinetry for my TL in progress McGoverning, no spoilery changes over time here but the picture as of early 1973. For anyone interested.

McGovern Administration

McGovern Cabinet

President: George S. McGovern
Vice President: Philip A. Hart
Secretary of State: R. Sargent Shriver, Jr.
Secretary of the Treasury: John Kenneth Galbraith
Secretary of Defense: Cyrus Vance
Attorney General: Archibald Cox
Secretary of the Interior: Jesse Unruh
Secretary of Agriculture: Frank Morrison
Secretary of Commerce: Dwayne Andreas
Secretary of Labor: Leonard Woodcock
Secretary of Health and Human Services: Andrew Young
Secretary of Education: J. Terry Sanford
Secretary of Housing and Urban Development: George Romney
Secretary of Transportation: W. Graham Claytor
Secretary of Peace: Donald M. Fraser
Secretary of Veterans' Affairs: Gen. David M. Shoup, USMC (ret.)

"Cabinet-rank" positions
Director of Central Intelligence: Paul "Pete" McCloskey
Chairman of the Federal Reserve: Arthur Burns (replaced midway through 1973 by Andrew F. Brimmer)
Ambassador to the United Nations: Shirley Chisholm
United States Trade Representative: Lawrence "Larry" O'Brien
Director of the Arms Control and Disarmament Agency: John Sherman Cooper

Executive Office of the President
White House Chief of Staff: Gary W. Hart
Deputy White House Chief of Staff: Douglas A. Coulter
Office of Counsel to the President: Frank Mankiewicz
Deputy to the Office of Counselor to the President: Gene Pokorny
White House Counsel: Ramsey L. Clark
National Security Adviser: Paul Warnke
Deputy National Security Adviser: Robert Sherman
Director, Office of Management and Budget: Lester Thurow
Chair, Council of Economic Advisers: Edwin Kuh
Director, Office of Policy Development: Jean Westwood
Director, Office of Public Liaison: Anne Wexler
White House Communications Director: Frank Mankiewicz [1]
White House Press Secretary: Richard "Dick" Dougherty

United States Department of State[2]
Secretary: R. Sargent Shriver, Jr.
Deputy Secretary: George Ball
Undersecretary for Political Affairs: Philip Habib
Undersecretary for International Security Affairs: David L. Aaron
Undersecretary for Management: William "Bill" Macomber
Assistant Secretary for African Affairs: Patricia Roberts Harris
Assistant Secretary for East Asian and Pacific Affairs: Richard "Dick" Holbrooke
Assistant Secretary for European Affairs: George Vest
Assistant Secretary for Inter-American Affairs: William G. Bowdler
Assistant Secretary for International Organization Affairs: Charles W. Mayne
Assistant Secretary for Near Eastern and South Asian Affairs: Alfred "Roy" Atherton
United States Ambassador to the Soviet Union: Robert S. "Bob" Strauss
United States Representative to the People's Republic of China: Arthur W. Hummel, Jr.
United States Ambassador to India: Chester Bowles [3]
United States Ambassador to the United Kingdom: Kingman Brewster, Jr.
United States Ambassador to France: Pierre Salinger
United States Ambassador to West Germany: Walter J. Stoessel, Jr.
United States Ambassador to Mexico: Edward R. Roybal
United States Ambassador to Brazil: Lt. Gen. Vernon Walters (ret.)
United States Ambassador to Israel: Kenneth B. Keating
United States Ambassador to Iran: Talcott W. Seelye
United States Ambassador to Saudi Arabia: James E. Akins
United States Ambassador to South Vietnam: John Gunther Dean
United States Ambassador to Cambodia: Daniel Patrick Moynihan [4]
United States Ambassador to Bangladesh: Archer Blood [5]

United States Department of the Treasury
Secretary: John Kenneth Galbraith
Deputy Secretary: Paul A. Volcker, Jr.

United States Department of Defense
Secretary: Cyrus Vance
Deputy Secretary: Townsend Hoopes II
Undersecretary for Policy: John D. Holum[6]
Undersecretary for Research & Engineering: Harold Brown
Undersecretary for Intelligence: Robert C. "Bob" Komer
Secretary of the Navy: Otis G. Pike
Secretary of the Army: Charles E. "Charlie" Bennett
Secretary of the Air Force: David S. Lewis, Jr.

United States Department of Justice
Attorney General: Archibald Cox
Deputy Attorney General: Clifford L. Alexander, Jr.
Solicitor General: John Doar

[1] Frank's wearing two hats in consequence of his central role with the administration's brains trust
[2] Though he doesn't have a formal title just yet, the senior administration bosses are maneuvering to give Clark Clifford a special ambassadorship that would in effect make him "arms control czar" for the administration, even though the subject-matter post at ACDA belongs to the retired liberal-Republican, anti-Vietnam senator from Kentucky John Sherman Cooper
[3] Returns for a hat trick
[4] Moynihan and John Kenneth Galbraith were close personal friends (JKG was actually close friends with several people whom he disagreed with even more sharply on policy, most famously William F. Buckley, and here despite Moynihan's association with Nixon they find a job for DPM even if it's a hardship post)
[5] Have I mentioned that this is pretty much the most Indophilic US administration in American history, even compared to JFK's?
[6] The McGovern administration beats OTL's Carter administration to the punch and sets up the subject-matter Undersecretaries at DoD
 
Last edited:
President: Henry Howell
Vice President: John Glenn

State: Ed Muskie
Treasury: Ross Perot
Defense: Earl Ravenal
Att. Gen.: Rose Bird/Bill Clinton
Interior: Russell Means
Agriculture: Bob Krueger
Commerce: Philip M. Klutznick
Labor: Thomas R. Donahue
HEW: Patricia R. Harris
HUD: Moon Landreiu
Transport: Larry McDonald
Energy: Alan Cranston

Chief of Staff: Billy Shore
EPA Director: Douglas M. Costle
OMB Director: Jim McIntyre Jr.
Trade Rep.: Reubin Askew

NSA: John McCain
 
“It’s {the Current Year}!”: A cabinet without straight white men.

President: Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)
Vice President: Fmr. Sec. Julian Castro (D-TX)

Secretary of State: Fmr. UN Amb. Samantha Power (D-MA)
Secretary of the Treasury: Fmr. Gov. Deval Patrick (D-MA)
Secretary of Defense: Ret. Maj. Gen. Claudia Kennedy (I-VA)
Attorney General: Fmr. Acting Attorney General Sally Yates (D-GA)

Secretary of the Interior: Gov. Kate Brown (D-OR)
Secretary of Agriculture: Fmr. Feeding America CEO Diana Aviv (I-IL)
Secretary of Commerce: Rep. Ro Khanna (D-CA)
Secretary of Labor: Dr. Edward Montgomery (D-MI)
Secretary of HHS: Dr. Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI)
Secretary of HUD: Mayor London Breed (D-CA)
Secretary of Transportation: Rep. Cheri Bustos (D-IL)
Secretary of Energy: Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK)
Secretary of Education: UC System President Janet Napolitano (D-CA)
Secretary of Veterans’ Affairs: Mayor Pete Buttigieg (D-IN)
Secretary of Homeland Security: Rep. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ)
 
Bush (2001-05)
* President: George W. Bush
* Vice-President: Dick Cheney
* State Sec: Donald Rumsfeld
* Treasury Sec: Paul O'Neill
* Defense Sec: Colin Powell
* Attorney Gen: John Ashcroft
* Homeland Sec: Tom Ridge
* Nat Security: Condoleezza Rice
Policies:
* Wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, N Korea
* Patriot Act, tax cut, school reform, partial-birth ban

Kerry (2005-09)
* President: John Kerry
* Vice-President: Hillary Clinton
* State Sec: Richard Holbrooke
* Treasury Sec: Donald Kohn
* Defense Sec: Sam Nunn
* Attorney Gen: John Edwards
* Homeland Sec: Gary Hart
* Nat Security: Leon Panetta
Policies:
* Wars in Palestine, Lebanon, Syria

Hunter (2009-13)
* President: Duncan Hunter
* Vice-President: Rudy Giuliani
* State Sec: John R. Bolton
* Treasury Sec: Brian Bilbray
* Defense Sec: Paul Wolfowitz
* Attorney Gen: Sam Brownback
* Homeland Sec: Rick Perry
* Nat Security: Norman Podhoretz
Policies:
* War in Venezuela, Cuba coup
* Growth, infrastructure plan, migrant ban

Hunter (2013-17)
* President: Duncan Hunter
* Vice-President: Rudy Giuliani
* State Sec: Paul Wolfowitz
* Treasury Sec: Brian Bilbray
* Defense Sec: Randy Scheunemann
* Attorney Gen: Rick Santorum
* Homeland Sec: Tom Tancredo
* Nat Security: David Petraeus
Policies:
* War on ISIS
* Realignment, Anglosphere confederation
* Mexico border wall
* 22nd Amendment revoked

Hunter (2017-21)
* President: Duncan Hunter
* Vice-President: Rick Santorum
* State Sec: Randy Scheunemann
* Treasury Sec: Gary Cohn
* Defense Sec: James Mattis
* Attorney Gen: Marco Rubio
* Homeland Sec: David Clarke
* Nat Security: Mike Pompeo
Policies:
* Wars in Baltics, Taiwan (WWIII)
* State of Emergency
* Militarisation, state planning
 
Kennedy cabinet – Jan 49

taken from my thread "Lancashire Life: An Account of the Great Patriotic War"

President of the United States - Joseph Kennedy (died of his injuries March 1949)
Vice President - William Douglas (Killed March 1949)
Secretary of State - Dean Acheson (killed March 1949)
Treasury Secretary - Henry Morgenthau (succeeds to President March 1949, killed June 1949)
War Secretary - Kenneth Royall (killed March 1949)
Attorney General - Frank Walker (resigned January 1949) replaced by Biddle.
Attorney General - Francis Biddle (became a member of the 5 man council July 1949)
Postmaster General - unknown
Navy Secretary - James Forestall (killed March 1949)
Interior Secretary - Oscar Chapman (sacked July 1949)
Defense Secretary - Louis Johnson (killed June 1949)
Air Force Secretary - Stuart Symington (sacked July 1949)
Commerce Secretary - Charles Sawyer (sacked July 1949)
Labor Secretary - Frances Perkins (resigned January 1949, replaced by unknown)

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff - General Patton
Chief of Staff (Army) - General Eisenhower

Chief of Staff (Air) - General Twining (sacked July 1949, replaced by unknown)
Chief of Staff (Navy) - unknown


see link below if you wish to read more ;)
 
Heseltine Cabinet, 1990

Prime Minister: Michael Heseltine
Chancellor of the Exchequer: John Major
Secretary of State for Trade, Industry, and the Regions: Chris Patten
Foreign Secretary: Douglas Hurd
Home Secretary: Sir Geoffrey Howe
Defence Secretary: Tom King
Education Secretary: Kenneth Clarke
Health Secretary: William Waldegrave
Secretary of State for Social Security: Tony Newton
Secretary of State for Employment: David Hunt
Secretary of State for the Environment: Peter Walker
Secretary of State for Transport: Norman Lamont
Secretary of State for Energy: John Wakeham
Secretary of State for Northern Ireland: Peter Brooke
Secretary of State for Scotland: Malcolm Rifkind
Secretary of State for Wales: Wyn Roberts
Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries, and Food: John Gummer
Chief Secretary to the Treasury: Peter Tapsell
Chairman of the Conservative Party: Tim Sainsbury
Chief Whip: Sir Patrick Mayhew
 
UK Cabinet - Legends Edition

Prime Minister: Winston Churchill (Conservative - National)
Chancellor of the Exchequer: William Gladstone (Liberal)
Foreign Secretary: Lord Palmerston (Liberal)
Home Secretary: Sir Robert Peel (Conservative)
Defence Secretary: Denis Healey (Labour)
Education Secretary: David Blunkett (Labour)
Health Secretary: Ken Clarke (Conservative)
Justice Secretary: Roy Jenkins (Labour)
Work and Pensions Secretary: Barbara Castle (Labour)
Business Secretary: David Lloyd George (Liberal)
Communities and Local Government Secretary: Michael Heseltine (Conservative)
Transport Secretary: Peter Walker (Conservative)
Environment Secretary: John Gummer (Conservative)
Culture Secretary: Jennie Lee (Labour)
International Development Secretary: Lynda Chalker (Conservative)
Scotland Secretary: Willie Ross (Labour)
Wales Secretary: Jim Griffiths (Labour)
Northern Ireland Secretary: Mo Mowlam (Labour)
Minister for Housing: Harold Macmillan (Conservative)
Chief Secretary to the Treasury: Joel Barnett (Labour)
 
UK Cabinet - Legends Edition

Prime Minister: Winston Churchill (Conservative - National)
Chancellor of the Exchequer: William Gladstone (Liberal)
Foreign Secretary: Lord Palmerston (Liberal)
Home Secretary: Sir Robert Peel (Conservative)
Defence Secretary: Denis Healey (Labour)
Education Secretary: David Blunkett (Labour)
Health Secretary: Ken Clarke (Conservative)
Justice Secretary: Roy Jenkins (Labour)
Work and Pensions Secretary: Barbara Castle (Labour)
Business Secretary: David Lloyd George (Liberal)
Communities and Local Government Secretary: Michael Heseltine (Conservative)
Transport Secretary: Peter Walker (Conservative)
Environment Secretary: John Gummer (Conservative)
Culture Secretary: Jennie Lee (Labour)
International Development Secretary: Lynda Chalker (Conservative)
Scotland Secretary: Willie Ross (Labour)
Wales Secretary: Jim Griffiths (Labour)
Northern Ireland Secretary: Mo Mowlam (Labour)
Minister for Housing: Harold Macmillan (Conservative)
Chief Secretary to the Treasury: Joel Barnett (Labour)
hmm I think Norman Fowler has a claim to be the most underrated minister in the Health Portfolio and should be considered for the line up rather than Clarke. And should not there be some other posts Leader of the House, Leader of the Lords, Ag and Fish, Energy (if we are going with environment and not Defra or climate change)
 
hmm I think Norman Fowler has a claim to be the most underrated minister in the Health Portfolio and should be considered for the line up rather than Clarke. And should not there be some other posts Leader of the House, Leader of the Lords, Ag and Fish, Energy (if we are going with environment and not Defra or climate change)

I like Fowler too - though like Clarke more for pushing through the NHS internal market and taking on the doctors' unions.

I've got Gummer down for Environment which could also encompass Agriculture and Fisheries. Energy I just assumed would come under Business.

I haven't used Rab Butler so can put him down for Leader of the House.
 
I like Fowler too - though like Clarke more for pushing through the NHS internal market and taking on the doctors' unions.

I've got Gummer down for Environment which could also encompass Agriculture and Fisheries. Energy I just assumed would come under Business.

I haven't used Rab Butler so can put him down for Leader of the House.
What about the Lords?
 
UK Cabinet - Legends Edition

Prime Minister: Winston Churchill (Conservative - National)

Defence Secretary: Denis Healey (Labour)
Education Secretary: David Blunkett (Labour)
Health Secretary: Ken Clarke (Conservative)
Justice Secretary: Roy Jenkins (Labour)
Work and Pensions Secretary: Barbara Castle (Labour)
Business Secretary: David Lloyd George (Liberal)
Transport Secretary: Peter Walker (Conservative)
Northern Ireland Secretary: Mo Mowlam (Labour)
Churchill captured a national moment in 1940 but wasn't a particularly good PM -Lloyd George, Chamberlain, Attlee and Thatcher were all much more effective and better talent spotters
Healey was a reasonably good Defence Minister for Labour but he was essentially a cost-cutter and had no great creative ideas about defence. He would rate well below Richard Haldane (Liberal) or Clement Attlee (Labour) if you wanted Legends
Education -Haldane or R A Butler (Conservative) -or even Michael Gove (Conservative). Whatever you think of their respective politics they were all genuinely committed to making sure that the little buggers actually learned something and Blunkett wasn't very good at Health
Health- Walter Elliott (Conservative) or Walter Runciman (Liberal) would have stronger track records
Justice- Aretas Akers-Douglas (Conservative), Henry Herbert Asquith (Liberal) ditto -the former tried to do the right thing not just what was politically expedient and the second was a master and driving through legislation, progressive but also keenly analytical of legislation's likely effects
Work and Pensions - Asquith, Lloyd George or A V Alexander (Labour)
Business - Reginald McKenna (Liberal) had a better brain for that sort of thing than Lioyd George and Oliver Lyttleton or Peter Thorneycroft (both Conservatives) would have been very good
Transport- Leslie Hore-Belisha (National Liberal) or Leo Amery and Euan Wallace (Conservative) might have claims. Amery was actually General Manager of a railway before he went into politics and Euan Wallace organised getting British troops to France during the Phoney War and helped organise the Dunkirk evacuation
Northern Ireland - you cannot be serious. Although a very popular politician at home Mo Mowlam was blatantly partisan in NI and nearly brought the talks crashing down and Blair had to sack her. Depending on what you want done - Roy Mason (Labour) and Tom King (Conservative) were effective but unpopular and Sir Patrick Mayhew (Conservative) was better at being conciliatory and taking the heat out of things. As was Peter Mandelson (Labour) Richard Needham (Conservative) never got the top seat but did a brilliant job of developing the economy and really deserved it.
 
Horror Show (not set at any particular time):

President: James Buchanan
Vice President: Aaron Burr
Secretary of State: Douglas MacArthur
Secretary of the Treasury: Andrew Mellon
Secretary of Defence: Curtis LeMay
Attorney General: Roy Cohn
Secretary of the Interior: Andrew Jackson
Secretary of Agriculture: John Rusling Block
Secretary of Commerce: Albert B. Fall
Secretary of Labor: Thomas A. Scott
Secretary of Housing and Urban Development: Phil Gramm
Speaker of the House: John Boehner
Senate Majority Leader: Benjamin Tillman
President Pro Tempore of the Senate: Jesse Helms
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court: Roger B. Taney

A mixture of the hopelessly incompetent and the outright dangerous.
 
Horror Show (not set at any particular time):

President: James Buchanan
Vice President: Aaron Burr
Secretary of State: Douglas MacArthur
Secretary of the Treasury: Andrew Mellon
Secretary of Defence: Curtis LeMay
Attorney General: Roy Cohn
Secretary of the Interior: Andrew Jackson
Secretary of Agriculture: John Rusling Block
Secretary of Commerce: Albert B. Fall
Secretary of Labor: Thomas A. Scott
Secretary of Housing and Urban Development: Phil Gramm
Speaker of the House: John Boehner
Senate Majority Leader: Benjamin Tillman
President Pro Tempore of the Senate: Jesse Helms
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court: Roger B. Taney

A mixture of the hopelessly incompetent and the outright dangerous.
Thurmond for Ambassador to the UN?
 
Top