Quaerere Caelis

I rather like this thread, any excuse for more rockets right? We might also see that much hoped for Anglo-Australian lunar base!

I wonder if your basing of nuclear weapons deterrents in Australia will have much in the way of political after affects. Certainly a stronger, earlier anti nuclear weapons movement. Might also change things in other ways, would the Australians be so keen on intervention into Vietnam?

In terms of funding, you might be able to get NZ to chip in a little. It wouldn't be much, but as things are on the smell of an oily rag, well, that might help.
 
So. Britain won't get any colour TV until the 1980s, eh?

A Direct to Home TV satellite requires electronics, power, and transmitting antennae that weren't going to be available for a couple of decades.
 
So. Britain won't get any colour TV until the 1980s, eh?

A Direct to Home TV satellite requires electronics, power, and transmitting antennae that weren't going to be available for a couple of decades.

In the context of multi-hundred-channel digital TV broadcast in the Ka-band then you are right. However, we are talking about a few channels of analogue signals. Most of the radio technology was well established. Although some new tech like phased arrays and solid state amplifiers have come along in recent years, fixed antenna & TWTA design has not changed fundamentally in decades. For this system, the signal encoding would need to change, but not much more than it did in reality when we moved away from 405 line TV. Electronically, there is little difference between DtH/FSS and what early comsats like Telstar actually did.

The big difference (and the reason it couldn’t happen in the real 60’s) is spacecraft power and control. Launchers like Thor-Delta could only put tiny payloads into orbit. Satellites like Early Bird had transmitters that put out a few Watts, into low-gain antennas. For DtH you would need more like 100W and much higher gain, as well as better Rx antennas on people’s homes than the hopeless bits of bent wire that were typical at the time.
This means a satellite with a capable electrical system, cooling system and a stable platform to keep the big dish pointed accurately at the ground. Such a satellite would weigh thousands of pounds. Early Bird weighed about 85lbs. The US Navy had a big stable comsat program in the early 60's, but cancelled it when it became overweight, overbudget and the Atlas-Centaur kept getting delayed.

Although all the details haven’t emerged yet in the story, “improved Blue Star” isn’t going to be a small rocket…

I’ll leave it there for now as there is more to come on this topic.
 
I rather like this thread, any excuse for more rockets right? We might also see that much hoped for Anglo-Australian lunar base!
Many thanks. I'm trying to keep it in the realms of science fiction rather than fantasy, but we can dream can't we?

I wonder if your basing of nuclear weapons deterrents in Australia will have much in the way of political after affects. Certainly a stronger, earlier anti nuclear weapons movement. Might also change things in other ways, would the Australians be so keen on intervention into Vietnam?
Tricky one that, it will certainly have consequences. Not sure the Australians will like being Britain's overseas missile base any more than the Brits liked being America's. In an early version of this story I would have had a flight of RAAF TSR-2s on supersonic bomb runs over Hanoi at nought feet. Unfortunately, both that idea and the TSR-2 are still on the drawing board at the moment.

In terms of funding, you might be able to get NZ to chip in a little. It wouldn't be much, but as things are on the smell of an oily rag, well, that might help.
Obliging people the Kiwis, and located very conveniently downrange.
 
In the context of multi-hundred-channel digital TV broadcast in the Ka-band then you are right. However, we are talking about a few channels of analogue signals. Most of the radio technology was well established. Although some new tech like phased arrays and solid state amplifiers have come along in recent years, fixed antenna & TWTA design has not changed fundamentally in decades. For this system, the signal encoding would need to change, but not much more than it did in reality when we moved away from 405 line TV. Electronically, there is little difference between DtH/FSS and what early comsats like Telstar actually did.

The big difference (and the reason it couldn’t happen in the real 60’s) is spacecraft power and control. Launchers like Thor-Delta could only put tiny payloads into orbit. Satellites like Early Bird had transmitters that put out a few Watts, into low-gain antennas. For DtH you would need more like 100W and much higher gain, as well as better Rx antennas on people’s homes than the hopeless bits of bent wire that were typical at the time.
This means a satellite with a capable electrical system, cooling system and a stable platform to keep the big dish pointed accurately at the ground. Such a satellite would weigh thousands of pounds. Early Bird weighed about 85lbs. The US Navy had a big stable comsat program in the early 60's, but cancelled it when it became overweight, overbudget and the Atlas-Centaur kept getting delayed.

Although all the details haven’t emerged yet in the story, “improved Blue Star” isn’t going to be a small rocket…

I’ll leave it there for now as there is more to come on this topic.

No, I'm talking 16 channel Astra 1a, service started in 1989. ~1.8 tonnes, 1.7kW - and using polarized signals. Initial prices for dishes/receivers was like $500 at the time (even for those small dishes, and even with 1980s electronics).

To do this with 1960s tech, the satellite will be MUCH heavier (if even possible), the receivers will be MUCH more expensive, and thus there will be no market for colour broadcast. So, service would have to wait for 2 decades until the tech improves and the prices go down.
 
The Summer of '62

F-9
Blue Streak test from Woomera. “All up” missile test with production-type RV and guidance system. Planned shutdown at 142s. Apogee 395km, Range 1120mi, Impact 1025' from aim point. Very successful flight.


Jul-62 Overseas
MA-10. NASA manned flight. A repeat of MA-9 with improved capsule systems. This time, all goes much closer to plan and astronaut Gordon Cooper completes 26 orbits on a flight lasting 38h 53m. In doing so, he retakes the endurance record from the Soviets.

NASA launches Bell Laboratories' Telstar satellite. The first effective communications satellite, Telstar is used to relay telephone and TV transmissions over the Atlantic. It is planned to launch a large number of these into low orbits to allow for continuous relay. The satellite operates for just 4 months before suffering radiation damage caused by high-altitude nuclear tests.


Aug-62
Plans for the second phase of Blue Streak hardened shelters in the UK are quietly dropped. Several outlying sites in the Scottish islands which were in the first phase are also "de-prioritised", meaning they will be completed once the priority mainland sites are ready.

BK22
Advanced Black Knight with a ballast offset in the RV, in an attempt to test a “lifting entry”. RV also carries the usual thermocouples and an ablative experiment. First Stage underperformed. No useful data is returned.

A short series of uncooled chamber tests are carried out at Spadeadam during a lull in Blue Streak qualification firings. The tests allow Bristol Siddeley to improve their models of heat transfer and combustion efficiency for Black Anvil’s new Orion engine.

Aug-62 Overseas
The USSR launches two manned missions on successive days. Both cosmonauts complete 3 day missions and "fly their spacecraft within 5 kilometres of each other". This is actually nothing more than good launch timing, as the capsules have no manoeuvring capability and the cosmonauts do not even sight each other’s vehicles.

Aug-62
The MoA and MoD both commission studies into using the Black Anvil rocket as the basis for a satellite launcher. The vehicle will obviously be able to deliver large payloads to low Earth orbit. With an upper stage added it could put large satellites into higher orbits. Greater mass means more power and control could be available for communication or other systems. It is thought that this could offer the potential for more flexible communication with satellites, without the need for the large dish antennas currently needed to communicate with small satellites such as Telstar.

Despite the new and extensive Black Anvil programme, UK aviation and aerospace firms continue to suffer from ever reducing workloads. The RAF’s TSR-2 bomber project is still on the drawing board and development of a supersonic VTOL aircraft is on hold. A simpler subsonic version is still in the experimental stage.
In the civil sector, the only projects on the horizon are the VC-10 and BAC 1-11. Sales of older types are winding down and Anglo-French discussions regarding a supersonic airliner project came to nothing.
Fears of a renewed "Brain Drain" are voiced as the US space programme keeps expanding, while American civil aviation developments such as the Boeing 7227 make working in the US seem ever more attractive, particularly to younger British engineers and designers.

Many “semi-formal” studies (usually by engineers in their spare time, but often using some company resources) look at the possibilities and challenges of building manned spacecraft, space stations or of sending probes out to other planets. None of these have any official status, however there is an increasing awareness within the aerospace community of the capabilities that larger rockets might offer. Although a lot of it is dismissed as “the dreams of scientists with their heads in the clouds”, the exploration of space is being studied more than ever before.


Sep-62
A full size engineering model of the Blue Star launcher is displayed at the Farnborough Airshow. Other space-related exhibits include a Black Arrow rocket and versions of the RZ-2 and Gamma rocket motors. The highlight of the show is a demonstration of vertical take-off and landing by a Hawker P.1127 experimental aircraft.

The French seek to renew discussions regarding an agreement to cooperate with the UK in aeronautical research. The recent failure to reach an agreement over a supersonic airliner project has not impressed the French government, who are keen to develop every aspect of French science and engineering to help ensure that she can stand alone as a world power.
A proposal to jointly develop a series of scientific satellites is put forward, which would be built in France and launched on Blue Star rockets. Both British and French instruments could be carried. It is hoped that this will lead to wider co-operation in satellite design and the transfer of some key technologies such as guidance systems and large engine pumps. By now it is accepted that the UK is unlikely to cooperate directly with France in ballistic missile development, partly for national reasons, but also due to the nature of technology sharing agreements with the USA.
However, to many in France, the existence of these agreements confirms that they are right to seek to develop in their own way and not be drawn too far into the "Anglo-American" sphere of influence.

American suspicion of sharing sensitive nuclear information with the UK is increased by the arrest of John Vassal, who is charged with supplying information to the Soviets. In practice, the US-UK intelligence sharing agreement is as strong as ever, however the scandal fuels the instinctive distrust for the British that exists in some quarters of the US administration.

While on a visit to Rice University, President Kennedy makes an impassioned speech in favour of the expanded nuclear power and space programmes.
With several references to "living and working in space" and "taming the new frontier of space" the speech is widely seen as a clear statement of intent to push forward with building new rockets, large space stations (several designs are published almost simultaneously) and ultimately send US astronauts to the Moon and beyond.
The American public are not so won over by “the promise of new technology” as many might think and a series of further speeches, exhibitions and promotional tours are planned to help convince them that so much government money is needed to support these projects.
 
No, I'm talking 16 channel Astra 1a, service started in 1989. ~1.8 tonnes, 1.7kW - and using polarized signals. Initial prices for dishes/receivers was like $500 at the time (even for those small dishes, and even with 1980s electronics).
To do this with 1960s tech, the satellite will be MUCH heavier (if even possible), the receivers will be MUCH more expensive, and thus there will be no market for colour broadcast. So, service would have to wait for 2 decades until the tech improves and the prices go down.

Have patience, you don't have the full picture yet, the story hasn't got that far. A system as sophisticated as that provided by Astra 1a and its associated consumer units could not have been built in the 60's.
 
Higher and Faster

F-10, the first two-stage Blue Streak vehicle to fly, combines both of the existing British rockets into one. A slightly strengthened version of the Blue Streak missile carries a modified Black Knight rocket as an upper stage. Confusingly, these military test flights are still called "Blue Streak", while an otherwise identical civilian launch would bear the much better known “Blue Star” name.

This purpose of this first test flight is simply to try to prove the concept of the two-stage design and carries only a boilerplate re-entry vehicle as a payload. To everyone’s relief, the launch, staging and second stage burn are completed successfully, and the Gamma engines cut off as planned leaving nearly 2,000lbs of fuel remaining on this relatively short range flight.
Peak speed at shutdown was 6,651m/s (nearly 15,000mph). The dummy RV separates and coasts to an apogee of 169km, heading for a nominal target point in the Arafura Sea, 3195mi from the launch site. No attempt at recovery can be made, although a Royal Navy ship was on station in an unsuccessful attempt to observe the early stages of re-entry and track the body of the rocket.

Sep-62 Overseas
NASA announces that its new Apollo spacecraft will be built by North American Aviation. Models and drawings of the new spacecraft show a large conical re-entry and command module with a rocket engine fitted to a cylindrical service module. This spacecraft will be launched on the agency's new Saturn rockets. Normally, Apollo will carry a crew of two, plus up to three “mission specialists” depending on the requirements of the flight.
To reduce the gap between Mercury and Apollo flights, early Apollo CSMs will be built in two groups. “Block 1” will be a basic version for Earth orbit tests, with a simple guidance and control system and no provision for docking or other complex tasks. Later “Block 2” models will include an advanced on board computer, docking system and extended flight capability to conduct longer research flights or to ferry crews to the planned space station. NAA says it could then develop a Block 3 version which would be capable of taking crews to high Earth orbits or to the Moon.


Oct-62
English Electric produce a conceptual design for a large satellite, which would be equipped with thrusters to control its exact position in space and deployable solar "wings" to generate power. The concept is based on the firm's knowledge of the capabilities of Black Anvil and includes an upper stage to boost the satellite into geostationary orbit. No payload is specified, but the firm points out potential uses such as communications and photography. Only outline summary is made public, details such as mass breakdowns are classified; as is everything to do with Black Anvil. The launch vehicle is simply described as an "improved Blue Star".

The complete success of F-10 prompts the MoA to agree to proceed with the expanded programme of tests discussed earlier in the year. Approval is given for an orbital attempt with the "Ariel" satellite in November, which will be followed by a high speed re-entry test in January. Development of the SUS is behind schedule and it is not expected that the first flight model will be available before August 1963.

BK 101
Black Knight flight from Woomera. First of a new series of joint test flights with the US as part of Project "Gaslight". The 58" Black Knight carries a low drag re-entry vehicle. A fire in the motor bay causes structural failure at 63s. Mission failed, no data is returned.
 
Finger on The Button

After months of monitoring by intelligence agencies, spy planes and tracking ships, President Kennedy is briefed on the Soviet build-up in Cuba. He agrees to the acceleration of numerous “training exercises” and the escalation begins towards the most dangerous nuclear crisis in history.

On the 21st October, Prime Minister Harold Macmillan is officially informed of the construction of Soviet missile sites in Cuba. Through other government contacts and intelligence, the UK has unofficially been aware of the American position for some time. The V-Force has already been brought to a state of heightened alert, again covered as part of a pre-planned exercise. The next day, President Kennedy announces to the world that the US has found evidence of Soviet nuclear missiles on Cuba and declares that the island will be quarantined against the import of all weapons and military supplies.

While the diplomatic efforts of the British government are towards de-escalation and compromise, frantic preparations are being made to put the country on a war footing. This has included an order to make all possible efforts to prepare a live Blue Streak missile for launch from RAF Feltwell. By the 26th, the RAF V-Force is dispersed. Overnight, weapons are armed, crews are briefed and they sit ready on board their aircraft at maximum readiness on the 27th.

After eight days of round the clock work, vehicle R-019, the first nuclear-armed Blue Streak, is erected on its pad ready for launch countdown. At 0529 on the 28th, pre-launch checks are started, kerosene fuel is loaded and the vehicle's guidance system is aligned. At 0615, Macmillan is quietly advised that a British nuclear missile is prepared for launch towards Moscow.

Mercifully, before anyone has to launch anything, Khrushchev backs down.

It is subsequently found that there are faults in R-019’s fuel and control systems, meaning that the missile could not have been launched even if the order had come. In fact, it was more likely to have caught fire on the pad. The live warhead is quickly removed and returned to storage while work continues on the missile.

Ten days later, with the crisis now fading, this first Blue Streak pad and missile is given "interim operational status" after the crew successfully complete a full pre-launch sequence, include fuelling the missile and completing a countdown to T-4 seconds.

The Prime Minister is told in the evening that the Blue Streak programme has delivered Britain’s first operational ballistic missile; it will be several months before any more are ready.
 
Great to see that this TL is up and going now.
Btw it'd be great if you would entertain the idea of a more developed South Korean space programme.
 
Great to see that this TL is up and going now.
Btw it'd be great if you would entertain the idea of a more developed South Korean space programme.

Glad you are enjoying it so far. Unfortunately, I don't think a South Korean space programme will be part of this story - economic factors wouldn't allow them to start one much before 1970 and then it would be payloads only, as the US would be dead set against any rocket development. It's a good idea as part of a follow on though.
I would encourage anyone else who wants to have a go at writing such a story (ideally someone with a greater knowledge of Korean history than me).
 
America Knows Best

The Joint Deterrent Force

At the end of the Cuban crisis, a secret agreement between the USA and USSR called for the accelerated withdrawal of American nuclear missiles from Turkey and Italy. For the Soviets, it would remove missiles from their back yard, while for the US, the opportunity it created meant that this particular cloud might have a silver lining. In the American’s view, these "Jupiter" missiles were obsolete anyway and a strategic plan for their replacement had been under study for some time.

In addition to the secret deal over the Jupiters, the Americans regard the Thor missiles based in the UK as being obsolete and that therefore they should be withdrawn in 1963. This was discussed with the British government prior to the Cuban crisis and they were found to be broadly in agreement. In the British view, the Thors can be replaced by Blue Streak (which in the Americans' opinion is a very marginal weapon, even with the "hardened shelters" the British are building for the missiles).

In an attempt to offer something better, a plan for a “Joint Deterrent Force” is presented to several of America’s key NATO allies. The force will consist of US-supplied Polaris missiles, to be based on ships or submarines operated by British, French or Italian navies. The JDF offer made to the British government is to supply three Polaris armed submarines to be operated by the Royal Navy. In return, the US would want berthing facilities for its own submarines in the UK.

The Joint Deterrent Force offer is the culmination of US plans to "defuse" the problem of controlling nuclear weapons in Europe. Despite America not making it easy for them, Britain has its own modest nuclear arsenal, the French are about to deploy a small number of atomic weapons and the Italians are starting to develop their own system. The French are known to be working hard to expand their small force and have repeatedly shown a tendency to go their own way, outside of US control or even influence.

The JDF seeks to sweep away all of these small, ineffective, foreign-controlled nuclear forces and replace them with “proven, modern” US-controlled weapons systems.

In the view of some US strategists - who hold considerable sway with the current administration - small deterrent forces are dangerous as they may be used to attack, or provoke an attack by the Soviets in which US Forces in Europe would be destroyed or damaged. This would undoubtedly lead to immediate escalation of a situation that is not under US control.
Nations other than the US should therefore not be allowed to operate nuclear forces, or at least if they do, it should be in such a way that the weapons are ultimately under US control. Politically, proposing a NATO-wide deterrent force is the most practical way of achieving this. The "arming key" system proposed for the Joint Deterrent Force would ensure that the weapons could never be used without US authorisation and would also be easy to incorporate into integrated strike plans.

A week later, an offer is made by NASA on behalf of the US Government to launch British scientific and military satellites on American rockets. The full range of US launch vehicles would be made available, including the powerful Atlas-Centaur, which will be capable of sending large payloads into geostationary transfer orbit.
 
The Third Space Power

Ariel​
The desperate activity in the weeks surrounding the Cuban crisis meant that all efforts to pursue the space programme had been put on hold. Engineers and test crews had been called in from across the country and a few were even brought home from Australia to help accelerate the deployment of Blue Streak nuclear missiles.

As the rest of the world heaved a sigh of relief, the work did not slow down. The one Blue Streak that had been made ready was found to be defective, while efforts to train RAF missile crews actually reached their peak in the early part of November.

Steadily reducing international tensions and the lack of pads for further missiles meant that personnel could be released from crisis duty later that month. Plans for the launch of "Ariel", Britain’s first satellite, could be resumed. After the success of the two-stage F-10, there was considerable hope that this first Blue Star launch vehicle would succeed and make us the third nation to launch a satellite.

Preparations for launch begin in earnest on the 26th November. Before being inconsiderately interrupted by the Soviets, technicians had assembled the rocket and the 785lb satellite had been tested in a clean room at the launch site. All that was left was to integrate it with the launcher and carry out the pre-flight and countdown checks.

At 1426 on the 9th December 1962, Britain finally enters the Space Age. Blue Star Satellite Launch Vehicle No.1 (also known as F-11 or BSLV-1) lifts off its pad on the Woomera Joint Test Range and roars into a crystal-clear sky. The Blue Streak missile that makes up the first stage functions perfectly during its 154 second flight. Small separation rockets fire and the second stage (itself a modified 58” Black Knight first stage) coasts upwards for a few seconds before all four of its engines ignite to push both stage and payload on into orbit.

Telemetry from the rocket is interrupted at 289s. Some instruments go crazy, others just read zero and for a heart-stopping moment, everyone in the control room fears the launch has failed.

Within a few seconds, many of the signals are reacquired, but the channels relaying data from the engines and flight timer remain dead. The rocket is now far downrange and nearly a hundred miles up, so controllers can only hope that everything on board continues to function. Just under six minutes after liftoff, tracking signals confirm that the stage is no longer accelerating.

It is nearly an hour before anyone is certain that the satellite is in orbit. It is only confirmed when a NASA tracking station in the Bahamas picks up the signals from Ariel. Later observations show that the satellite has been successfully launched into a 161 x 2232km polar orbit.

Post-flight analysis suggests that an electrical discharge at 288s caused the telemetry problems and must have burnt out some of the control electronics. The stage did not steer itself as planned and the engines continued to fire until all the fuel was burned, rather than cutting off at the pre-set time, leaving the satellite in a far more elliptical orbit than was planned. Separation squibs on the upper stage probably failed to fire, likely leading to the upper stage hitting the satellite after it was released (the satellite is in an unexpected slow spin).

Nevertheless, Ariel’s small experimental solar panel and battery powered magnetic field sensor, ion detector and micro-meteoroid experiments all function until the satellite’s orbit decays 51 days later.

Britain’s space programme has begun.
 
Fallout

Nov-62
The Institute of Mechanical Engineers publishes a paper in co-operation with Hawker Siddeley on the systems needed to land a robotic probe on the Moon. Different methods of propulsion and navigation are discussed, as well as the need for a radar system to detect the surface and control a "soft" touchdown. Although not specific to any particular launcher, the paper talks about a rocket with a 15t Earth orbit payload capability and an upper stage based around an efficient Methane/Oxygen engine.


Dec-62
BK102
Anglo-US “Gaslight” test. Repeat of the failed BK101 flight. Vehicle reaches 369km and the second stage successfully accelerates the RV before re-entry. Heating and acceleration data was recorded and the remains of the RV were recovered for analysis.


The initial reaction of the British establishment to the JDF offer is mixed. It is a valid military option and would give the UK access to a fully developed, modern US weapons system, but would leave British nuclear policy entirely in American hands. The status of the V-Force and tactical nuclear weapons would be in doubt. It has previously been suggested that the RAF should retain airborne nuclear capability until the V-bombers reach the end of their airframe lives, probably in the mid 1970s.
A hurried report by the Treasury shows the cost implications to be broadly positive, as there would be no need to continue the Black Anvil development programme. As the Polaris system would not be available immediately due to the need to build the submarines, the report notes that “unfortunately, some level of Blue Streak deployment would still be required”. Operational costs are likely to be higher, due to the need for ongoing maintenance of the submarine force. There would also be the need to build a major new submarine servicing base, either at Devonport or on the Clyde.

The NASA spacecraft Mariner 2 makes the first flyby of another planet when it passes close to Venus. The probe detects that the planet has very high surface temperatures and no measurable magnetic field.

The PM receives a briefing from British Intelligence regarding US actions and intentions during the Cuban crisis. The key point is that the US was prepared to act unilaterally in launching nuclear strikes on the Soviet Union. This is entirely reasonable, however US opinion is that “collective NATO security” extends to firing American-controlled missiles from the UK as part of any US strike, even though the UK may not technically have declared war. The US policy of “launch on warning” is therefore of greater concern than ever, particularly when considering its implications for the JDF.
It is around this time that Macmillan makes the statement (leaked some years later) that comes to summarise British nuclear foreign policy for decades to come “If this country were to suffer a nuclear attack, then it should be as a consequence of the failure of the British government, and not the American government, to find a way of keeping the peace.”*

The implications of the JDF offer and the recent intelligence assessment are discussed at a secret Cabinet session. The intelligence reports only reinforce support for the existing strategy of seeking to base all future deterrent forces away from the British Isles. If this were implemented in full, it is clear that the difficult question of removing US nuclear forces from Britain would have to be dealt with. However, the simple existance of such a policy could be a significant negotiating strength when the JDF is discussed with the US early next year.

Regarding the merits of the JDF offer, a submarine based solution was regarded as the second best option by the SSPC report in 1959, but was dismissed as the UK did not have the technical means to produce such a system within a reasonable time. Polaris is now a proven system which could be operational within 3-4 years if supplied by the US, or 4-5 years if major components were to be built in the UK with US assistance. Blue Streak still has to be deployed in any case, to cover the “deterrent gap” prior to either the JDF or Black Anvil becoming available.

A negotiating position must be formulated prior to further discussion with the US and initial thoughts centre around a British-owned but US-designed submarine system. Such a force would normally operate within the integrated strike plan but the UK would retain independent control, in exactly the same way as it currently does with the V-Force.
The offer by the American space agency to launch British satellites is suggestive, as accepting it would mean the UK would no longer require its own launch vehicle.
When these offers are taken together, it confirms the view that the US wants Britain out of the nuclear and missile fields altogether and is seeking to achieve this through the cancellation of Black Anvil and the curtailment of Blue Streak/Blue Star.
The cancellation of Black Anvil might, in the short term, be of financial benefit even allowing for termination penalties with the manufacturers. However, it would leave the British aviation and aerospace industry with very little workload, to the extent that the survival of several firms could not be guaranteed.

*[and parodied by arch-civil servant “Sir Humphrey” in the 1984 TV sitcom Yes Prime Minister;
Sir Humphrey (speaking to dim-witted sidekick): “It is not for the Americans to determine when Britain gets blown up … that’s the job of the civil service”]
 
A Strategic Interlude - 1962

In many ways, the British backed themselves into a corner in the early 60s. The commitment to “one strong programme” (Black Anvil) was intended to show the Americans that they were serious about maintaining a credible deterrent and would remain a worthwhile technology partner in the space and defence fields. In practice, the Americans largely ignored British developments. Attitudes varied from those who wanted to see “no active support” for UK missile development to those who actively wanted to see it stopped. Many in the Kennedy administration assumed that shortage of money and time would ultimately force the UK to accept a US-owned deterrent.

The existence of a British space programme was viewed as a threat to the US’s ability to export satellite and launch services to friendly nations. The "Blue Star" launcher might become direct competition for NASA's Scout and Delta rockets when it came to launching foreign satellites.
America was at the peak of its technical and economic self-confidence. It was widely believed that the US had "won the Space Race" and should be in the position to reap all of the benefits of the technologies that Americans had developed and paid for. This included the ability to determine who had access to space – access which should be provided by American rockets.

However it must be said that American attitudes at this time were inconsistent, with different departments and agencies pulling in different directions. The armed forces and intelligence services maintained close co-operation with their British counterparts, to the extent that the CIA and NRO were working with British agencies on a series of signals intelligence satellites, one of which was to be built and launched by Britain.
 
Small separation rockets fire and the second stage (itself a modified 58” Black Knight first stage) coasts upwards for a few seconds before all four of its engines ignite to push both stage and payload on into orbit.
58" Black Knight? Wow, that's an upgrade from OTL. IIRC, even the wider diameter version that was looked at iOTL wasn't THAT big. Of course, OTL's Black Knight was rather undersized as a second stage - it just had the advantage that it existed. Did they up engine it, as well?

Telemetry from the rocket is interrupted at 289s. Some instruments go crazy, others just read zero and for a heart-stopping moment, everyone in the control room fears the launch has failed.

Within a few seconds, many of the signals are reacquired, but the channels relaying data from the engines and flight timer remain dead. The rocket is now far downrange and nearly a hundred miles up, so controllers can only hope that everything on board continues to function. Just under six minutes after liftoff, tracking signals confirm that the stage is no longer accelerating.
How many channels of telemetry did they have?
http://www.svengrahn.pp.se/sounds/spectrgr/FMFMPAM.html
has a graph showing 6 (5 functional?) channels from an Atlas launch. Does this have a lot more telemetry than an Atlas, or was 'many' an exaggeration?


It is nearly an hour before anyone is certain that the satellite is in orbit. It is only confirmed when a NASA tracking station in the Bahamas picks up the signals from Ariel. Later observations show that the satellite has been successfully launched into a 161 x 2232km polar orbit.

2232 km Apogee on something that was supposed to be a circular orbit (on assumes)? That sounds like a lot of extra fuel was burned. In fact, why would have carried that much?
 
58" Black Knight? Wow, that's an upgrade from OTL. IIRC, even the wider diameter version that was looked at iOTL wasn't THAT big. Of course, OTL's Black Knight was rather undersized as a second stage - it just had the advantage that it existed. Did they up engine it, as well?

Yes, BK has gone bigger earlier. It was somewhere way back in the story. New RVs and joint Anglo-American tests needed a bigger test vehicle so they resized it and went to 8 Gamma 201 engines. As an upper stage its still 58", but with only 4 long-nozzle engines.

In reality, several designs up to 58" were suggested and a 54" was built (for Black Arrow). Originals were 36". 58" max was supposedly due to size limits at High Down testing station, although the 2m first stage of Black Arrow was later tested there, so the "limits" existed more in the minds of pesky anti-space bean counters.

How many channels of telemetry did they have?
http://www.svengrahn.pp.se/sounds/spectrgr/FMFMPAM.html
has a graph showing 6 (5 functional?) channels from an Atlas launch. Does this have a lot more telemetry than an Atlas, or was 'many' an exaggeration?
More than one instrument per sub-carrier channel; multiplexing soon became very important. Most Atlases used more than 5 channels (I believe 16 channel, 200ish instruments was typical in the early days). If they'd only been able to make 5 measurements we'd still be testing Atlas today.

2232 km Apogee on something that was supposed to be a circular orbit (on assumes)? That sounds like a lot of extra fuel was burned. In fact, why would have carried that much?

They were aiming for 300km circular (I may not have said that, it probably got editted out somewhere), so about 230kg based on simulation, not allowing for ullage.
a) Simple satellite, built to be well below the capability of the launch vehicle.
b) It burned to propellant depletion, not the planned cutoff. No-one ever plans to do this (obviously other than with solids, where they can be the same thing). Even with "maximum payload", there should be a margin added for under-performance/error/manufacturing variation etc... Fuel margins equivalent to over a hundred m/s would be quite typical, even on a well-tested version of a modern rocket.
c) There will always be unusable propellant in lines, valves, jackets etc., plus the pressurant gas in the tank. If the control system never shuts the prop. valves, all of this will be vented. Even if it can't all be burned, it can still add to the total impulse. Venting can take time, hence the stage (maybe) colliding with the satellite when the separation squibs fail. Alternatively, venting might have destabilised the stage prior to separation. Without the telemetry, they will never know...
 
Possibilities in the New Year

Jan-63 Overseas
MA-11. NASA manned flight. The first of two planned long duration flights using improved Mercury capsules. Astronaut Gus Grissom becomes the last of the original astronaut group to fly, making a 3 day 14 hour flight, completing 57 orbits and effectively equalling the current Soviet record. The plan to complete a 5 day flight could not be accomplished due to the failure of electrical systems on the Mercury capsule.

Jan-63
Further Cabinet discussion of the American JDF offer follows a briefing by Prof. Zuckerman and others on the technical aspects of the plan.
The loss of the independent deterrent is not regarded as acceptable, particularly when it is clear that the Americans are willing to use nuclear forces completely independently of their allies. The cancellation of Black Anvil would cause severe problems for the UK aeronautics industry, to the extent that nationalisation would probably be the only option to avoid the collapse of BAC and several other firms.
More detailed studies from across several ministries, including the MoA and the Treasury, show that the cost of a "free" American supplied deterrent could be comparable to continuing with Black Anvil, once the cost of Blue Streak and of closing down the project and supporting the industry is taken into account. A healthy aerospace industry is key to UK security interests, national prestige and is an important source of both exports and jobs.

The recent cancellation of the US Skybolt missile (once a much-wished-for upgrade for the V-Force) is further illustration of the fickle nature of US planning and defence procurement. It is emphasised that relying on a US system carries the risk that the programme will be cancelled, with the US able to dictate terms regarding any replacement.
The Polaris system is already deployed with the US Navy, so the cancellation risk is minimal in that particular case. Of greater concern is that the Americans might change their minds about the entire JDF concept prior to deployment, a situation which would leave the UK without any options.

Despite these misgivings, a negotiating position is agreed, seeking improvements to the original JDF offer:
- British owned warheads and missiles, with warheads built in the UK to US designs.
- The UK to have independent launch authority.
- Four (not three) submarines to be built in the UK (a US design would be preferred).
- All nuclear forces based in the mainland UK to be under British command, but normally operated within the integrated strike plan. A dual-key arrangement would be acceptable for US nuclear forces in the UK if it can be made to work.

It is felt that technically and strategically this is an inferior solution to that offered by Black Anvil, but it would offer advantages in terms of development risk and in helping to maintain a close Anglo-American relationship. The conditions suggested are thought to push the Americans as far as they are likely to go with any chance of agreement.
Under these conditions, a limited civil and military (but non-nuclear) space programme might be continued to support British industry and retain technical capability in the country. A joint civil programme with France would be of benefit to mitigate the cost. An Anglo-American space programme appears impractical due to the relative size of budgets and the widely varying plans of the Americans.

Sir Giles Jervis is asked by the government to prepare a paper on the potential benefits of space research to industry, specifically the exploitation of resources or techniques that are unavailable on Earth. A commercial lawyer and keen amateur geologist, Sir Giles seems almost entirely unsuited to the role of analysing space technology and his appointment draws no complaints from those who oppose the funding of such research.

US Secretary of Defence Robert McNamara visits London to discuss and gather support for the JDF plan. His discussions with Minister of Defence Peter Thorneycroft and British officials are frank. The terms discussed at Cabinet are put to McNamara, who seems surprised and irritated that Britain is not jumping at the US offer. The British side are ultimately reduced to commenting that this is not the first time that the US has tried to "push us into accepting your plans, then pulling the rug out from under us" [in respect of nuclear co-operation]. McNamara points out that the Polaris system is almost invulnerable to pre-emption, while US analysts consider Blue Streak to be an old-fashioned and rather limited missile, even now, two years before it is fully deployed.
Thorneycroft's reply is recorded as simply "Yes, we know Blue Streak has its limits. The improved system which we have under development is much more capable. It may remove the need to base nuclear weapons in Britain."
Discussions ended shortly thereafter.

By telephone, Macmillan and Kennedy agree to meet next month at Nassau in the Bahamas.
The real implications of Thorneycroft's statement are largely lost in Washington, where the potential for the removal of nuclear forces from the UK is regarded as laughably improbable. The prospect of some form of weak UK “independent” deterrent causes far greater concern. No doubt a few concessions could be made, but it seems clearer than ever that the British must be pushed into accepting the JDF.

Aware that the British are now looking back towards their American allies regarding co-operation in the space field, the French make a more determined attempt to agree terms for a joint research programme before the chance slips away. Offering the British this “consolation prize” might go some way to repairing the damage to relations caused by the rejection of their EEC membership, while also being of direct benefit to the French aerospace industry and help counterbalance US power in Europe.
They propose a staged project, including military and scientific satellites, with a medium term goal of putting a man into space and building a system of communication satellites.
Unlike previous proposals, the French accept that the early flights should be launched on British rockets, with a high proportion of the early work done in the UK, despite significant French financial involvement from the outset.
President de Gaulle and his ministers see the US and Britain making significant progress in aerospace technology. France is also making good progress, but remains some years behind. A programme to ensure that she is a leading power in this area is essential, but it would be costly and slow without the sort of help that Britain has received from the US.
De Gaulle suggests that the British be told that France would also consider a Franco-American space research programme in an effort to “encourage them to co-operate now, or else they become irrelevant”. With great diplomacy, his ministers dissuade him from pursing this risky suggestion. They believe that the British would simply walk away from discussions if they thought France was trying to play them off against the USA.
A deal with the UK is the real objective, as part of wider French efforts to try to balance American power in Europe.
 
“We aimed for the Pacific … and missed”

On the 18th January 1963, RAE engineers launch the twelfth Blue Streak missile from Woomera.

Unlike the highly publicised success of “Ariel” the previous month, no details of this Top Secret flight are reported. A 75% scale model of the proposed Black Anvil re-entry vehicle is mounted on top of the second stage and will be boosted close to orbital velocity. It will fly east, barely above the atmosphere before falling towards a target point near Christmas Island. Ribbon parachutes will slow the RV to allow it to splashdown intact after a flight of around 4,800 miles. It is designed to float until picked up by a nearby recovery ship.

The flight is effectively Britain’s first test of an ICBM, albeit a design that is never intended to enter service.

Launch vehicle performance appears normal and controllers heave a sigh of relief when the Black Knight second stage separates and ignites as planned. Before launch there had been a series of problems with the timing circuits that trigger these events. Radar tracking shows that altitude at second stage shutdown is slightly higher than expected. Other than this, all seems normal and at T+8m 22s, the RV is ejected from the top of the rocket as planned.

A few minutes later, having arced halfway across the Pacific, a tracking station on Christmas Island scans for and acquires the RV, which is fitted with a transponder to help the radar lock on to it. Almost immediately, it is clear that the RV is higher - about 50 miles higher - than expected and is not descending into the atmosphere. There is concern that the Top Secret design is in orbit; this RV is more advanced than anything in service in either Britain or the US. If it is, it could land almost anywhere. The flightpath would ultimately take it over some decidedly unfriendly nations, who would no doubt be happy to pass it along to Moscow.

Although the booster was equipped with a range destruct system, the RV is not; no one imagined that one might be needed. Radar tracking is maintained for a few minutes before the lock is lost in radio clutter as it nears the horizon.

The tracking data is analysed with the greatest urgency and it becomes clear that the RV will not complete an orbit due to its low altitude. It seems likely that it will have already re-entered, somewhere over the Eastern Pacific. After an assurance that the RV will sink after a day at most, no search is attempted; no-one knows exactly where to look and the risk of the Top Secret RV design being recovered by a Soviet ship is considered non-existent.

Post flight investigation suggests that the simple "point and shoot" guidance system on the upper stage pitched down less than had been programmed. In addition, the engines produced a higher thrust at lower efficiency than expected, resulting in a lighter, faster accelerating stage.
The resulting burnout velocity was about 11m/s too high, and more significantly at a slight angle of climb, not the planned dive back into the atmosphere.

More thorough analysis of the radar data is radioed back to the UK, where a computer model of the drag forces suggests that the RV might have flown further than was first thought. Assuming it survived re-entry, the impact point is later estimated to be somewhere in the American Midwest.

Uncertain as to whether to “ask the Americans if we could have our rocket back”, test managers pass the matter up the chain of command, where it enters the mire of international diplomacy. Events in the real world move much faster.

On the edge of a field outside of Colt, Arkansas, farmer Merve Collins finds “some sort of bomb, all burned up”. His brother, on leave from the Navy, takes one look at it and knows enough to contact the nearby Air Force base and ask them to come get whatever has fallen off one their planes.
After a near-farcical sequence of interference by the local Sheriff, not one but two broken down pickup trucks and a night landing on an improvised airstrip, Pentagon officials final get to see the mysterious object and conclude “it isn’t ours”. What it is, however, is the remains of a highly advanced missile re-entry vehicle.

It took a while for anyone to connect the fact that Britain had conducted a missile test on the far side of the world on the day before it was found. It is a shock to realise that this makes it the longest flight yet made by a ballistic missile; impact was 9,742 miles from Woomera. [Although unknown at that time, it still holds the record for the greatest miss in history, at 4,932 miles, a distance greater than the range from the launch site to the intended target].

No one event changes the course of history, but with the benefit of hindsight, F-12 certainly gave it a nudge. Not for the first (or the last) time, analysts engaged in the preparation of a briefing for the US administration connected the dots and came to completely the wrong conclusions.
The supposedly new British missile codenamed “Black Anvil” was nothing more than an upgraded “Blue Streak” with an upper stage. Obviously, this combination will be able to achieve long range, but it still makes for a weak deterrent. It would be a missile no better than America’s first ICBM “Atlas”, early versions of which will be taken out of service within a couple of years. Recent comments by various British officials would seem to support this conclusion. Given Britain’s limited resources, it would make sense for the “improved Blue Star” satellite launcher and the ballistic missile “Black Anvil” to be virtually the same vehicle. With this as their only home-grown option, the British will undoubtedly accept America’s JDF proposal, although perhaps they hope to trade their program in return for a better deal.
[In one way the analysts were right, “improved Blue Star” and “Black Anvil” were the same rocket, just not the one they were thinking of.]

Armed with the knowledge that the British had only a weak hand to play, the US delegation heads for the Bahamas. They were confident that, in the end, their JDF proposal would succeed in bringing all Western nuclear weapons back where they belonged - under US control.

The entire incident would be hushed up. Merve Collins was paid $122 by the Air Force as compensation for the hole in his field, and no-one said anything more about it.
The story finally came out in 2003; how, three months after the Cuban crisis, an experimental British ICBM hit the United States.
 
Wonder how Doctor Who will be affected by this (IOTL, it premiered in November of 1963 (1))...

(1) The day after JFK was shot, BTW (2).
(2) I doubt the British space program butterflies will affect JFK's assassination (JFK is still going to have to go to Dallas to try to heal the divided Texas Democratic Party)...
 
Top