The High and the Mighty (President John Wayne)

maverick

Banned
True Grit



WAYNE MAINTAINS A 25 POINTS ADVANTAGE OVER WALLACE

President John Wayne leads Democratic Nominee George Wallace by a commanding 25 points according to a Gallup Poll conducted in the last three days, a lead that is somewhat reproduced in the relation of forces between Wallace and Independent Democratic Candidate Eugene McCarthy.

McCarthy, who took the anti-war and liberal delegates in a walkout at the Democratic National Convention in June, has also demonstrated a great ability to garner the Black vote, thanks to his running mate, New York Congresswoman Shirley Chisholm. Whereas Wallace’s strength relies upon middle class whites and blue collar workers, McCarthy’s tries to consolidate his base through the nation’s youth, college students and African American voters.

[Taken from…The Washington Post, September of 1972]

****************************************************

We couldn’t believe our luck after the Democratic Convention; Wallace and McCarthy had effectively destroyed any chances their party might have had in 1972, of course considering what they were running against that year. They ran in mutually exclusive areas, neatly and quiet appropriately divided by the Maxon-Dixon Line, with a few exceptions of course. Wallace spent considerable time in Michigan and Ohio, not to mention the Western States, which were of course considered as a good battleground for the Wallace Campaign. Of course, little could compensate the fact that they were dead north of Maryland and that New York and New England wouldn’t go to Wallace unless hell froze over first.

The Democrats should have been more thankful to Him in any case. Their party would have had no chances in any case, not even if they had run Kennedy, not after Nixon died and the JFK Syndrome settled in at the polls.

[Taken from…The Making of A President, testimony of Republican Strategist John Sears]
********************************************************

George Wallace was a fascinating man in any way you look at him. Having entered Alabama politics as a progressive and even a liberal, at least what you can call a Liberal by 1950s Alabama politics, his career took an interesting turn in the 1958 Democratic Primaries for the Governorship, at the time the only real election, the general election being only a formality given the chances of the Republicans in the 1950s South.

The Conservative Attorney General John Patterson ran with the support of the Ku Klux Klan, an organization Wallace had spoken against, while Wallace was endorsed by the NAACP. After the election, aide Seymore Trammell recalled Wallace saying, "Seymore, you know why I lost that governor's race?... I was outniggered by John Patterson. And I'll tell you here and now, I will never be outniggered again

From then on, Wallace would cynically use Race to further his career, from his successful election to The Governorship in 1962, his stand against Federal Desegregation of Alabaman Schools and Universities, his controversial and incredibly racist reelection campaign for a second term in 1970 and his Presidential Campaign of 1968, at which point he had begun to abandon his incredibly open support for segregation given the need to appeal to a national audience. ‘Law and Order’ and ‘States’ rights’ had become his new banners. The last remnants of his old Pro-Segregation stances remained in his opposition to Desegregation busing and his reputation, that still remained from his stand against President Kennedy and Desegregation in 1963.

Yet the 1972 presented the unusual situation of having Wallace run against a man that was arguably the most popular man in America, a combination of his pre-political status, Presidential Status and post-Nixon Sympathy, who was also his political equal on stances of Law and Order, States’ Rights and even more shockingly, Race relations.

Even as Wayne’s open racism would be paid more attention only after the election, during which Vietnam and other issues took primacy, and especially during the 1976 election, it was interesting to note that in many occasions Wayne had espoused more than controversial views on race and race relations, going as far as to say on one occasion in 1973 that... I don't feel guilty about the fact that five or ten generations ago these people were slaves. Now I'm not condoning slavery. It's just a fact of life, like the kid who gets infantile paralysis and can't play football like the rest of us, amongst many other statements. Thankfully, running against George Wallace nullified the race issue from the debate.

Come October, The Wallace Campaign began their mayor offensive against President Wayne nevertheless, using the greatest weapon at their disposal: John Wayne’s Service record during World War Two…



[Taken from…Chaos: The Presidential Election of 1972]



***********************************************


The official response, which would be the official version about the affair in most Biographies of President Wayne, came from both the White House and the Republican Campaign the day following the first ads and speeches that attacked President Wayne’s lack of military service during the war. George Wallace, a known hawk in foreign policy affairs, was also a World War Two veteran, as was his running mate Sam Yorty, having served in the Air Force and Navy respectively. The attacks, that began with a Wallace speech at Columbus, Ohio on September 30th and were expanded into several attacks and ads through early October.
The offensive hadn’t taken the Wayne Campaign by surprise, but the President was quiet visibly shocked as his patriotism was questioned and his character put under attack. America's entry into World War II had resulted in a deluge of support for the war effort from all sectors of society, and Hollywood was no exception. Many established stars rushed to sign up for military service. Most notably, James Stewart, who had already enlisted in the US Army Air Corps, surmounted great obstacles in order to do so.

Officially, John Wayne was excepted from Service Wayne was exempted from service due to his age (34 at the time of Pearl Harbor) and family status, classified as 3-A (family deferment), yet the more public response oriented the affair in the general direction of Hollywood and Republic Studios, specifically the head of Republic, Herbert Yates, who was adamant in his resistance to let Wayne go to the war, given the loss of so many stars and the death of Gene Autry overseas.


Correspondence between Wayne and Herbert Yates indicates that Yates threatened Wayne with a lawsuit if he walked away from his contract, though the likelihood of a studio suing its biggest star for going to war was minute. Whether or not the threat was real, Wayne did not test it. Selective Service Records indicate he did not attempt to prevent his reclassification as 1-A (draft eligible), but apparently Republic Pictures intervened directly, requesting his further deferment. In May, 1944, Wayne was reclassified as 1-A (draft eligible), but the studio obtained another 2-A deferment (for "support of national health, safety, or interest"). He remained 2-A until the war's end. Thus, John Wayne did not illegally "dodge" the draft, but he never took direct positive action toward enlistment, as many would counter to the Official arguement.


The Controversy nevertheless remained for much of the campaign, as even Independent Candidate Gene McCarthy joined in Wallace in criticizing Wayne for his hypocritical policies and stands, accusing him of being a chicken hawk and a draft dodger.


The Controversy had influenced the direction of Wayne's life after the war. By many accounts, Wayne's failure to serve in the military during World War II was the most painful experience of his life. There were some other stars who, for various reasons, did not enlist. But Wayne, by virtue of becoming a celluloid war hero in several patriotic war films, as well as an outspoken supporter of conservative political causes and the Vietnam War, became the focus of particular disdain from both himself and certain portions of the public, particularly in later years. While some hold Wayne in contempt for the paradox between his early actions and his later attitudes, his widow suggests that Wayne's rampant patriotism in later decades sprang not from hypocrisy but from guilt. Pilar Wayne wrote, "He would become a 'superpatriot' for the rest of his life trying to atone for staying home."


The Final response and the virtual end of the Controversy that year would come from the President Himself, in an address to the Nation on October 17th of 1972…


[Taken from…The Making of A Presidency]
 
Last edited:
Awesome update Mav, I really think the usage of Wayne's non-service as a campaign issue was a very interesting one, and Im not sure why McCarthy/Chisholm has attacked both Wayne and Wallace hard for their blatant racism. Im actually interested in seeing if we could actually get some type of Electoral College in the next few years especially if McCarthy's third party campaign wins a few votes. Maybe the Bayh-Celler Amdendment would actually get passed ITTL.
 
maverick

Sounds interesting although hopefully unlikely. Mind you details like Wayne's racism I wasn't aware of until reading this so might not have had as big an impact at the time, especially against Wallace. Could well be highly destructive of American society in the years afterwards however, not to mention his views on Vietnam. Could see seriously and possibly violent division in the US and also possibly impacts on the relationship with the rest of Europe.

Anyway have subscribed to see what happens.

Steve
 
Sheesh! I'm learning about the politics of the country in which I live from an Argentinian!

Wow!

Good work Maverick! I'm regularly astounded by your timelines, but to pick an American topic in an American dominated forum and 1) find something no one's looked at before, and 2) do it so well. My hat's off to you!
 

maverick

Banned
True Grit II




My Fellow Americans, I come before you tonight not as the President of the United States or a political candidate for higher office, but as an American Citizen whose name and integrity has been attacked and love for this great country questioned.

“Nearly Thirty Years ago, this great nation embarked on its greatest military Endeavour since the days of the American Revolution and the War of Independence, standing in the name of Freedom and Democracy against the menace of Tyranny and Global annihilation. The Facts were these…”

[Taken from…The Making of A Presidency…John Wayne’s speech of October 17th of 1972]

************************************************************
‘For Nearly 30 years, this country and myself have know who John Wayne was, and have seen that name become a household name in America, and for nearly 30 years we believed that we knew what kind of man John Wayne was. What we saw tonight, at the President’s address has proven us wrong. The cultivated image of a rough, unemotional and uncaring cowboy that shoots first and ask question later has been shattered today to become what the American people always thought of the man, as an icon of American cinema and history…


[Walter Cronkite on CBS Evening News, October 17th of 1972]

**********************************************************
“There are, and this is the official opinion thus far, as far as historians have agreed, three pivotal moments, all aligned with dramatic and moving speeches, in the political life of John Wayne. The first came at the Republican National Convention of 1964 with the ‘A Time of Choosing’ Speech, and the last came on November of 1979, with his valediction speech, but it was perhaps his 1972 “A History of Regret” speech the one that has made the greatest impact on the perception this nation and its people had on its 38th President, one of the greatest and most iconic American figures of the 20th century.

“Perhaps the most interesting part is that the most memorable parts of the speech were not in fact part of the original script as written by Pat Buchanan and William Safire, but in fact an abandonment of said scripted speech and a truthful and passionate appeal to the American People, an attempt to actually reach out to them. There is a marked difference between the first part of the speech, which to a degree was just another Nixonian speech, somewhat recycled in style and substance by Buchanan and Safire, in which the typical arguments that had been repeated in the last weeks were reinforced by the President Himself, putting the blame on his condition as a family man over 34 and the involvement of Republic Studios in the whole ordeal.

“It was eight minutes into the speech that the President stopped reading and sighed for a second, the longest second in his political career, as he contemplated the true magnitude and importance of his words, and realized that this wasn’t what the people wanted to hear, not from John Wayne, not from their president; completely abandoned the plan, he addressed the American people at that moment not as the President of the United States, but as a regretful American Citizen, truly ashamed and repentant from his failure to serve his nation during the war as hundreds of thousands of young men had at the time.

“For the millions of Americans that saw the President’s address, that had grown with John Wayne movies and with the image of a roughed hardened old cowboy, the image of a hero was shattered to leave room for a more humane, down to earth man everyone could understand and relate to. His last words, begging for forgiveness to God and all those young soldiers that had died overseas, and his promise to do his outmost best to serve the United States in their name, as his teary eyes and his sincere expression of regret created the perfect frame for the new picture the American people know had of John Wayne…”

[Taken from…John Wayne, the Man Behind the Myth]

************************************************************
PRESIDENT WAYNE HOLDS 30 POINT LEAD OVER WALLACE


JUST DAYS BEFORE THE ELECTIONS, PRESIDENT JOHN WAYNE maintains a 30% lead over Democratic candidate George Wallace, who in turn holds a 20% difference over Independent Gene McCarthy. In the days following President Wayne’s speech, nicknamed the ‘regret speech’ by the press and political commentators, the President’s approval and popularity have skyrocketed once more, expanding his lead at the polls over Wallace, who has seen his margins decrease dramatically in perceived close states, such as Virginia, North Carolina, Kentucky, Florida and Maryland.

[Taken from…THE WASHINGTON POST, OCTOBER 25TH OF 1972]
 
one more issue

Mavrick this is wonderful! In keeping with Duke's atttitutes about race.
Will we see aide to Rhodesia and South Africa?
 
Will POTUS Wayne earn a sea of blue in '72?
How do you define "sea"? If Wallace still gets the Deep South (like the states that went for Goldwater in 1964) and McCarthy gets a few liberal states to the north (Minnesota, Massachusetts...), does that count as a "sea of blue"?
 

maverick

Banned
The Undefeated


April 26, 1971


CONFIDENTIAL


MEMORANDUM FOR

JAMES W. McCORD
FROM: JOHN N. MITCHELL


All Operations have been cancelled until further notice.


Mr. Haldeman has announced that we are to receive no more funding until further notice as well, pending a final decision on behalf of the President.


Furthermore, The Plumbers Unit has to be disbanded immediately and its operatives relocated elsewhere should an official investigation or inquiry arise.


cc.: Mr. Malek


[Committee to Reelect the President, internal MEMORANDUM, April of 1971]


************************************************************

Throughout September and October of 1972, Eugene McCarthy made no less than 80 trips to American cities throughout the northeast of the country, addressing the people on the two core issues of his campaign: Race and the War in Vietnam.

Following the unfortunate debacle at the Democratic National Convention, McCarthy became the standard bearer for both issues as the National candidate, George Wallace, began a crusade for ‘Law and Order’ and ‘Peace with Honor’, alienating a good half of the party that was now up for grabs. Sadly for McCarthy, Wallace took an important half of the party when the Labor Unions, Blue Collar workers and several other important groups joined him. The Catholic vote was somewhat divided and important figures such as Ted Kennedy did not support either candidate. (The Kennedys had notoriously bad relations with both Wallace and McCarthy)

Washington D.C., New York, Boston, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Philadelphia, Detroit and many others were the centers of the McCarthy campaign, specifically visiting black neighborhoods, college campuses and underprivileged neighborhoods, often in the company of running mate Shirley Chisholm or figures of the civil rights or anti-war movements. Groups such as ‘Vietnam Veterans Against the War’, the NAACP and more controversially, what had once been known as the ‘Students for a Democratic Society.’

It is also interesting to note that amongst the people that participated in the McCarthy campaign, there was future Governor and failed 1992 Presidential Candidate John F. Kerry, who was elected to Congress that year as part of the McCarthy campaign, and reverend Jesse Jackson of Operation PUSH.

[Taken from…Chaos: The Presidential Election of 1972]
***********************************************************

There is a marked difference in the Wallace campaign pre and post October 17th of 1972, when President John Wayne responded personally to the Wallace and McCarthy attacks during the ‘Military Service Controversy.’

September and October had seen a steady growth for the Wallace camp throughout the west and what could be considered the swing states, such as Virginia, North Dakota, Michigan, Ohio, Maryland and Kentucky. Late September had even seen a daring Wallace offensive north of the Mason-Dixon line as he addressed the loyal crowd of blue-collar workers and middle classed white people at Pittsburg and other Pennsylvanian cities. The logic was simple, as many would point out years later: “Pennsylvania is Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, with Alabama in the middle.”

Yet in the best case scenarios, it was always a 15 to 20 point difference, and following October 17th, the Wallace campaign was officially doomed; the polls show drastic loses in most states, and Wallace was forced to go back and campaign in states that had been thought to be safe, such as Maryland, North Carolina and Florida.

Most worrisome was the Democratic Stronghold of Texas, which had voted Democratic in almost every single Presidential elections for the past century, except for the Eisenhower Years; The difference had been 46% to 41% in September and it was closing, but by late October, Wayne had managed to increase his 5 point advantage to a 15 point lead…the Wallace campaign pretty much imploded in the days leading to Election Day…

********************************************************

“…this just in…The Great States of New York and Pennsylvania have voted, along with most of the eastern seaboard, and we are ready to call a victory for President John Wayne”

[CBS Evening News, November of 1972]



To be Continued...
 
Fantastic couple of update mav, the anticipation for the final electoral map is killing me, I really hope McCarthy/Chisholm will get some votes(DC most definatley as well as Massachusetts, Minnesota, Rhode Island and Hawaii could be toss ups). I definatley believe it will be a landslide electoraly for President Wayne(Over 60%) but electorally Wayne should get over 450...Keep it comming:D
 

maverick

Banned
You mean this?

3941347484_ea55c4245e_o.png




I don't know how realistic this is...but take into consideration that McGovern took 37% of the vote IOTL, that McCarthy is an independent with only half the party and none of the funding and that Wallace had 10 million voters in 1968 and expanding that into 30% of the vote would have been nearly miraculous given the fact that this is George Wallace we're talking about here...



Also, thank god wiki kept its old maps! No way in hell am I Going with the idea that the right wing party is red and the left wing one is blue...
 
Last edited:
I don't know how realistic this is...but take into consideration that McGovern took 37% of the vote IOTL, that McCarthy is an independent with only half the party and none of the funding and that Wallace had 10 million voters in 1968 and expanding that into 30% of the vote would have been nearly miraculous given the fact that this is George Wallace we're talking about here...



Also, thank god wiki kept its old maps! No way in hell am I Going with the idea that the right wing party is red and the left wing one is blue...
What, McCarthy doesn't even win his home state?

And by the way, you have to fix the pie charts in the corner... or get rid of them, whichever works for you.
 

maverick

Banned
Odd, I thought I had eliminated them...fixed now


Errr...I mean, what pie charts? there are clearly no pie charts there and there have never been! :p:eek:
 
John Wayne carrying DC is pretty close to ASB. Or Massachusetts. I'd expect an election more like 1912, with each of the three parties carrying some states.
 

maverick

Banned
Interesting point, although I do have to say that IOTL Massachusetts went for McGovern by some 200,000 votes

MASSACHUSETTS 1,332,540 54.2 14 1,112,078 45.2 -

which doesn't seem much...

In a three way race, Wallace takes some of the John Wayne votes, perphaps, but his is massachusetts.

And that's without mentioning voting turnout...which was already low IOTL...ITTL we have a third party candidate who took on a black female running mate, a former actor turned president and George Wallace, who has support of the Unions and several party bosses, not to mention the democratic establishment and the fact he's the official candidate, whereas McCarthy runs a fringe campaign, A "Freak Power" ticket, like the Gonzo Run in Aspen in 1970.


Is it more realistic to think that it would go to a third party candidate? Because I'm unsure...maybe I don't give independants enough credit...
 
Last edited:
Top