I'm afraid that all I can see in this thread is preferential treatment to these other suggestions, both of the last two by the same user, solely because they are newer. I see no voting process whatsoever; if the next scenario isn't chosen in order or arbitrarily then there's some kind of inner conclave at work. This is concerning imo.
Best case scenario is that ya'll have just been winging it informally
Oh for the love of Pete, there's no MotF cabal--the next topic is simply the one suggested
since the last contest that receives the most support (i.e. people liking posts/saying "I like this topic"). If nobody suggests any, then it's the runner-up topic from the last contest. How else, besides limiting it to recent topics, would we even know what the topics were we were selecting from?
it's my job to give suggestions if I want them to be considered by the userbase. Here are a few (arbitrarily) chosen suggestions from the list:
Yep, that is indeed what I said. If you want to see something from the previous list, you have to suggest it (which I have done), and it has to receive the most support out of any idea.