Search results for query: *

  • Users: Krix
  • Order by date

Forum search Google search

  1. Alternate Cold War scenario

    Is that the reason German Empire planned ethnic cleansing of Jews and Poles and Russian Empire revoked laws granted after 1905...? Obama doesn't come from a country invaded and occupied by USA which was on North American continent, that's really not a good comparison. I don't recall that...

  2. We lose World War I

    If not him then others would stand against the oppressive monarchies that treated badly so many nations. I was thinking more of a state. Was there one with more sinister goals then German Empire ?

  3. Alternate Cold War scenario

    If a the state was imposed on them against their will and they desire to end their oppression, that's not a stability, but the chains of prison state. Yeah, like those awful colonists who teared apart British Empire, or pesky Poles who dared to demand freedom from peace loving Russian and...

  4. We lose World War I

    Of course, their military just burned libraries, massacred civilian towns, and the German state used forced labour. And of course they only planned to ethnicly cleanse some(2 million) Jews and Poles after the war. If that's not a bad guy in WW1 then who is ?

  5. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    It should be remembered that the oil SU supplied to Germany was in great part provided from Polish oil fields in Drohobych and Boryslav.

  6. Alternate Cold War scenario

    I don't know about economy in fascism, but he argues for the eradication of cultures who oppose being part of an imperialistic state, which seems fascist enough for me.

  7. Alternate Cold War scenario

    Here he calls people who want to learn Slavic languages: irresistible nationalistic fascination for quaint peasant dialects https://www.alternatehistory.com/discussion/showthread.php?p=2607443#post2607443 Also almost every third of his topics deals on the issue how Germany effectively...

  8. Alternate Cold War scenario

    Sad world in which people like me know Poland had Lower Silesia before 1945 in its past ? I don't know exactly what you mean... Half of France was not assigned to Soviet Union, nor were the French considered untermenschen for extermination, nor was France partitioned by German states for over a...

  9. Alternate Cold War scenario

    Neither Croatia nor Serbia resigned from their sovereignty to the other side. Germany passed over all of its legal competences to Allies by unconditional surrender, thus changing the legal aspect of actions taken on its territory. In this case geostrategic needs went hand in hand with moral ones...

  10. Alternate Cold War scenario

    Seems like touched a nerve ? Your claims about "Polish poisonabsolutely do not change the fact that this not a historical map and just a imaginative creation not based on actual discussed changes. I have my doubts considering their lack of touch with reality. Those "patriots" were actually also...

  11. Alternate Cold War scenario

    You are incorrect, the agreement of former Allied powers plus 2 that allowed the reunification had several clauses. One of which included recognition of territorial changes by Germany that happened after 1945, and signing a separate border treaty with Poland. Austrian identity is different from...

  12. Alternate Cold War scenario

    The map is taken from Wikipedia and is original creation. It doesn't follow the actual changes proposed from Allies. That was never the goal of Valkyrie group. In fact it couldn't be since the term of Iron Curtain was invented much later after their attempt to keep German occupation of Central...

  13. Alternate Cold War scenario

    The Germans there didn't classify local population as untermenschen, and German minorities didn't assume the role of Nazi master race. The short answer is yes, since they are based on eastern border of Poland that was established in 1945 while the POD is in 1944. Also unlike Germany or Korea or...

  14. Alternate Cold War scenario

    The borders of divided Poland are completely implausible. Upper Silesia and Pomerania remaining in German hands is implausible. The Eastern Poland lacks both population or any resources to function as state. No removal of Germans from invaded countries is implausible. Poles lost more population...

  15. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    The Nazi aligned party called Sudeten German Party received 66% of German vote in 1935. The Jews of Bohemia and Moravia: facing the Holocaust Livia Rothkirchen, page 56. I would belive that by 1938 due to radicalism of German minorities in Europe the support can be taken for higher. By 1938...

  16. Second fascist wave in Europe?

    Post 1989 in Central and Eastern Europe could be a good place for that if the conditions are much worse then OTL. Post 1945 till 1989 Soviets wouldn't allow it. You could also have fascist states after a Cuban Missile War scenario TL's (I am basing this on the original one written on this very...

  17. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    In separation- perhaps, combined with invasion, not likely. Why ? Romania was aligned to Poland and afraid of SU, it would dare not risk such conflict.

  18. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    Because Tsarist authorities promised them autonomy and unification with the rest of Polish territories. But from 1916 onward the Poles were not reliable. Of course you can also use the example of Austro-Hungary whose ethnicly mixed troops performance was very poor and desertions very common...

  19. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    In case you missed it, this scenario assumes Poland in Anti-Comintern pact.

  20. Realistic take on war starting in 1938 ?

    I am aware of that, that was an example of the role Italy can play for Germany.
Top