1816, just the date makes any American with a knowledge of history cringe. Gordon Drummond makes most Americans shake their head in shame.
Gordon Drummond was the most talented officer in Canada at the time of the Reckoning War’s move into high gear. He was audacious and talented, frequently surprising those Americans that moved against him.
In 1816 The Army of Nations was preparing to move from central New York and into Upper Canada, Massachusetts was raising a militia to deal with the attacks on its northernmost reaches, the province of Maine, and Gordon Drummond ordered the last of the crack British troops out of Halifax and marched them west, not to meet the Army of the Northwest but to bring the war fully to American soil.
The Invasion of New York began in a three pronged attack that the Americans were not expecting. Drummond had the element of surprise and everyone was surprised indeed. A small force moved to capture Lockport first and set up a defensive line. The main British force, mixed with Canadian militia, would come in behind them from across Lake Ontario.
Mulcaster would come in handy on this invasion. His sailors were able to construct several pre-fabricated galleys to transport men and supplies all over the lake while a small force of war sloops moved down the Saint Lawrence and disrupted American fishing.
The truly masterful stroke however was upsetting the main force of Dearborn’s Corps by having Roger Sheaffe invade Vermont by deftly bypassing the Army of Old Kings Mountain, which was further north in Quebec proper trying to gain ground.
This one two punch laid the framework for one of the most disastrous battles in American history.
The Battle of Buffalo was not decisive because Buffalo was a particularly important city. It was decisive because it opened up southwestern New York to British conquest. The war in the Iberian Peninsula was winding down and Britain could free up more and more troops to go and fight a lesser prepared force.
The Army of Nations, under James Wilkinson, was just such a force. On the day of the battle most of the men garrisoned in Buffalo were either drunk, at leisure in a Den of Iniquity, or gambling.
Some multitaskers were doing all three. Either way they were almost totally unprepared and were soon crushed beneath the rolling tide of red clad Brits.
So they did the sensible thing and retreated to a larger encampment. They brought news of real British troops with real British guns and real British bayonets. The Army of Nations was demoralized and resigned to fight a losing battle almost before the battle began.
Wilkinson was unable to restore order amongst his men and many refused to fight, opting instead to retreat further afield, ultimately regrouping in Pennsylvania. As for the Army of Old Kings Mountain, their Vermont and New Hampshire regiments were quick to bail and return home to fight the wretched British there.
From there everything went to hell, the Americans would not regain their hold of southwest New York until the war’s end, Mulcaster and his men would terrorize the coast as well as every lake which Americans might try to make their living from and by 1818 there would be more British regulars in Canada than militia.
It was a dark time for America as they desperately tried to hold on to central New York and reports came in that Vermont and New Hampshire were just barely holding on. If it had not been for the large reinforcements from the Army of the Northwest and the fact that the Army of Old Kings Mountain was able to provide support to the Granite Militias [1] then the news could have been much, much worse.
The Massachusetts Militia was sent to war in 1816, but only in a mild support function on the border of their northern province. After 1818 however the state was firmly in the war and pushing to have Congress declare the Granite Militia, Massachusetts Militia, New York Volunteers, and the Army of Old Kings Mountain declared the Army of New England.
This was granted and soon the war took on a much more official tone. The Army of Old Kings Mountain was divided into two divisions of Kentucky Rifles and supported by a regiment of heavy guns raised in Boston, Massachusetts itself.
This early force was placed squarely on the shoulders of Solomon Van Rennselaer.
Early interactions liked this helped to cement the idea of the war not simply as a northern one or a southern one but as an American one. This would become increasingly important later on.
The Army of Nations was reorganized as the Army of the Tennessee River and would see one of the first big jumps of the war.
The Hamiltonian Plan, named because Hamilton had created such a plan during the Revolution, called for southern states to raise a number of slaves that would be fit for combat and the United States government would free them, while at the same time paying their former owners.
These slaves would be organized into a Negro Division and placed firmly inside the Army of the Tennessee River. The 4th Tennessee River Regiment ND* would come to great heights when in 1819 it would serve as a “temporary” occupying force after the Army of New England’s 1st Vermont Rifles and 3rd New York Horse would luck out as it were and manage to capture Halifax itself.
[1] A term which will come to describe the large combined militia which will eventually be fielded by both Vermont and New Hampshire, as a single force.
* Just in case you aren’t completely certain the ND means Negro Division, similar to the British army using NI, Native Infantry, for its Bengali sepoys. I will elaborate what happens to the 4th Tennessee River Regiment ND in future updates. As well as explain the capture of Halifax.
**************
Throughout the Reckoning War both sides would end up taking many prisoners, after all it is considered one of the last true “Gentleman’s Wars.”
Most American prisoners of war would be held in Quebec City where they would be under constant guard by a small contingent of Canadian militia. The Americans however were clever and would transport the prisoners down the Mississippi to New Orleans where they would be shipped over to the Territory of Florida.
That is of course if the captured prisoners were white. The Kentucky Rifles, formerly the Army of Old Kings Mountain, were infamous for massacres against the Canadian Indians. They fought mainly to avenge their beloved governor Isaac Shelby who was killed by Tecumseh. [1]
They were ruthless, merciless, and thorough. Women and children were captured and occasionally raped. Men would be beaten and then strung up in front of their loved ones. Those that survived the drunken anger of the Terrible Ones, one of the many Indian nicknames given to the Kentucky Rifles, would then take the long overland trek to Florida.
The United States could not spare boats for Indians. The few slaves found in Canada fared much better. They were allowed a position in the Negro Divisions and promised some land at the end of the war.
All of this activity would slowly increase the size of the population of the new territory. Through prisoners of war, captured Indians, and eventually mental patients and petty criminals along with prostitutes and the occasional moonshiner helped to make Florida the destination for the unwanted that could not fit into American society as a whole.
Though the real story of the year 1820 in the Reckoning War had to be the Pacific Squadron, after Isaac Hull had taken command and the USS Constitution was declared the flagship the fortunes of this three frigate squadron only increased.
They were incredibly lucky in raiding British shipping all over their Pacific holdings, most specifically the North Island of New Zealand, which served as a base for both British and American whaling interests and the USS Essex even conducted a small scale war against the British backed Kingdom of Hawaii.
Eventually though the Pacific Squadron would have to withdraw to resupply and restock. They found an incredibly good source on a place called the Falklands. The Falklands had been serving for the past few years, ever since the collapse of Spanish enforcement in South America, as a base for pirates and fishers alike.
So after a particularly heavy raiding session the Pacific Squadron withdrew to this tiny spigot of land and restocked its fresh water supplies. The first thing Isaac Hull did upon meeting so many disgruntled pirates who were fed up with the Royal Navy’s presence on the plunder rich Pacific coast of South America was issue emergency Letters of Marque and declared each of them honorary citizens of the United States and members of the Pacific Squadron.
He also gave them a prize that had been captured and towed back to the Falklands. It had been a small British brig named the HMS Beagle. [2] Isaac Hull liked the little brig and so decided to do it an honor when renaming it the USS Derby, after his own hometown in Connecticut.
So the beginnings of a pro-American feeling came into the pirates of Cape Horn who would later allow American ships to pass unharmed and would even help American squadrons in later engagements against other pirate bands.
For now though the Cape Horn pirates resumed their plundering ways under the command of an American onboard the USS Derby.
The christening of the Derby and later ships like it would be a minor footnote to the War in the Pacific. The most memorable event is of course, the Battle of Cape Horn. The “Honorable” British East India Company was roped into the conflict by 1819 when they lent over 700,000 pounds to the British government.
Their greatest effort though would be supplying their own sepoys and white soldiers to the war, as well as terminating the contracts of many actual British troops that were serving with John Company so that they could go and fight.
British and Company troop carriers were heading for Jamaica where they would reinforce the British garrison and free up troops for the attempted invasion of New Orleans. Though the troops had initially been massing for an attack on the Sultanate of Brunei’s formerly Spanish holdings they were intercepted by messengers who had been told by messengers who had been told by Cape Horn pirates who had been hired to inform the Indian troops.
Of course these Cape Horn pirates were more than eager to sell the secret to their American friends who were able to read the Greek letters used by the ever so clever British agent who had issued the order. [3]
So the Americans were waiting, the USS Constitution, USS Essex, and USS Congress were buffeted by a massive assortment of sloops and brigs like the USS Derby, USS Abuelo, USS San Martin, USS Jefferson, and the USS Bolivar. [4]
The most brilliant stroke though was the use of a tactic that been used to defeat the Spanish Armada so many years before. Nineteen small ships sat high in the water during the two day battle. They were filled with gunpowder barrels and when the large troop transports would approach these ships thinking them flotsam American sharpshooters would light them up.
The effects were devastating to the initial British waves and even if they won the engagement there would be far too many men and materials drowned in the cold waters of Cape Horn to make much of a difference in Jamaica.
It is of course notable that the Americans ignored the old rules of naval warfare and did very, very little to try and rescue these damned men. Commodore Hull even ordered a broadside on some British ships that were attempting to rescue the drowning.
Another feature of the battle was the first use in a long time of stinkpots, long a favorite of pirates in older days these vile little things erupted when they hit a ship and released odors so foul that men would jump overboard where the cold waters would shock them and force them to try and draw breath, drowning them even quicker.
After the first two attempts very few British sailors jumped overboard anymore. They were simply reduced to vomiting and crying as they fled from the horrible stench. Only to be fired upon by sharpshooters and carefully aimed broadsides that would render the deck of a ship devoid of all life.
The Battle of Cape Horn was an overwhelming American victory and sealed the fate of the naval war in the Pacific. For the rest of the Reckoning War the Pacific Squadron would continue to strike fear into the hearts of British whalers and try their hardest to build a permanent American outpost on the Falklands Islands, as well as garner alliances with more and more pirates.
[1] Just in case you didn’t remember the update in which that happened.
[2] Unlike OTL the British actually need the Beagle and so launch her to the colonies while bigger and better boats will be taking care of fighting the Americans. Also, take that Charles Darwin, take that.
[3] An actual British tactic used rather effectively in the Sepoy Mutiny of 1857. Of course some of the Americans have a classical education and are able to decipher it rather easily.
[4] These names of course reflect the origins of many of the new sailors/pirates.
************
When the Netherlands was forcibly assimilated into the French Empire the Dutch left behind more than a few colonial possessions, namely South Africa and the Dutch East Indies, however the unwanted bastard child of the Dutch Empire would prove to be the most important.
Suriname was annexed by the British in 1799 and was fully under British control until 1820 when the Reckoning War, specifically the American victory at the Battle of Cape Horn, forced British military planners to abandon the colony to its fate and use the freed British troops to move on New Orleans.
Of course the British did not really abandon Suriname. They simply turned over control of the country to the Dutch colonists and left them to their fate. The first move on the part of the Boeroes was to of course reinstate slavery and begin combating the Bosnegers. [1]
The Bosnegers of Suriname had been autonomous and living rather peacefully since the 1760s or so when they had signed treaties with the Dutch colonial government and continued living in traditional West African ways.
When the British had abolished slavery in the colony the Bosnegers had of course been pleased and were on good standing with the Brits. However the reinstatement and continuation of slavery and direct white rule by the Boeroes united the five Bosneger tribes against the new republic of Suriname and forced the Boeroes to try and find candidates for immigration. [2]
Well, they found them. All over Europe there were people who were tired of the constant cycle of war and conquest and war, they were a small minority to be certain but many early pacifists would eventually be joined by people who no longer wished to see their homes under constant threat of being ravaged. Most of these immigrants would find a home in the United States, only to realize that it was at war.
The better informed immigrants would find themselves in supposedly calmer climates like Suriname. Not only those seeking a respite from danger would come to Suriname, a large amount of Jews would immigrate to the new country, mainly because one third of the white population was already Jewish and they figured that they would be accepted more readily in the multicultural society.
However the greatest amount of immigration came from the former homeland itself, many Dutch citizens were fed up with French rule and found out the hard way that constant rebellion would be punished accordingly, so they fled all over Europe. Most of these ‘fugitive Dutch’ would end up in the German states, however more than a few would manage to flee into British hands and would be filtered into Suriname.
Of course wherever there were Dutch people who were unhappy of the way that things were going there would be the knowledge that Suriname was waiting. This knowledge would drive many Afrikaners to leave the then British ruled Cape Colony and find a home in Suriname. Even the Jersey Dutch began to move south in order to try and preserve their language and culture against the all pervasive onslaught of American English.
So Suriname came to be and its population almost immediately doubled, it was not hard of course because so few people had lived there to begin with. Rather quickly immigrants outnumbered natives and the Surinaams Dutch dialect was in danger of being absorbed by the heartier strains of Afrikaans and Vlaams.
Still, the language and culture of the new nation would come to reflect almost all of its new immigrants with laws and the eventual constitution being translated into Vlaams, Ladino, and English.
1822 was a critical year in the Reckoning War as British troops from across the Caribbean moved for the long planned assault on New Orleans. It came as a surprise to the Orleans Territory militia which had been put in charge of guarding the city as British cannon quickly reduced the harbor’s few defenses and the British used their naval advantage to quickly reinforce the troops that had been landed.
It was a short battle, one in which the American forces were completely routed and the British were quick to broadcast the news to everyone who would listen. This combined with the invasion of central New York made most Americans sit up and take notice as they realized that they may not be able to win the war.
The fact that the British now controlled the most vital port in the United States, and therefore the Mississippi River, meant that the Americans were going to have to strike back at the British and do it quickly.
So they chose Halifax. Halifax was and is a vital port in Canada and would complete its Quebec style defensive walls by 1820, just in time to use them against American forces that attacked the supposedly impenetrable city and took it in the summer of 1822.
Most British forces were either marching west to battle the Army of the Northwest which was still camped out in the large grain producing regions of Upper Canada or they had already been deployed into New York and Vermont and New Hampshire.
Halifax was protected by a small garrison of about 100 regulars and a similarly sized city militia, nobody was expecting an attack from the Americans and laughed when the small force of the 1st Vermont Rifles camped outside the city and began a barely noticed siege.
However the people of Halifax noticed when those same Vermont Rifles marched into the city on July 5th, 1822. The night before the Americans had celebrated their independence by setting off cannon and rockets while singing “Oh Columbia” as loudly and annoyingly as possible.
The people of Halifax had crowded the parapets to watch this spectacle and nobody noticed while American agents who had entered the city months ahead of time disguised as French fur trappers secured the Western Gate and waited until the American force marched to the other side of the city early in the morning and after a brief battle had officially taken Halifax by trickery. [3]
The Capture of Halifax was a result of sound military strategy and arrogance on the part of the British, it would be compared to the Biblical Siege of Jericho and the resulting occupation would become legend in the minds of many Americans.
After the capture and the turning out of most of the citizens of Halifax orders came in from the Army of New England that the Vermont Rifles and their companions in the 3rd New York Horse would be needed for an assault on British troops massing to try and take Long Island.
So the nearest somewhat experienced force was volunteered to hold the city. On July 23rd the 4th Tennessee River Regiment ND would be put in charge of Halifax. They were well supplied and well staffed, which would help them in 1823 when the British cut off reinforcements to the city and they would come under a four year siege.
[1] Boeroes is an actual Suriname term for Dutch pastoralists and their descendants, eerily similar to the Boers of South Africa. Bosnegers is an actual term that means Bush Negroes, also called Maroons in the English speaking world.
[2] So many African slaves were imported into the colony under Dutch rule and so many escaped that five large, distinct and culturally West African tribes developed in the interior of the country. They are the Quinti, the Saramaccan, the Paramaccan, the Djuka (or Aukan), and the Matawi.
[3] Agent will come to mean spy in this timeline, mainly because I like that word better.
******************
“John Armstrong, now there is a man for all times.”
-Anonymous
The last years of the Reckoning War were spent by both sides staring at each other and fighting one desperate battle after another. Little headway was made, though threw a slow and grinding campaign the last British troops were ejected from New York in 1825.
No, instead the last years of the Reckoning War would be spent much like the first years, in small scraps that ended up bloody and dangerous. Though the Fire of 1823 certainly altered the course of the war, in 1823 James Madison was a very weary man. He had been elected four times as the President of the United States and was more than willing to step down and was looking forward to trying his hardest to not run in the Election of 1824.
George Mulcaster would help alleviate Madison’s weariness, just not in the way he expected. November 9th, 1823 saw James Madison preparing for bed when a great fire began inside the Presidential Palace. Now George Mulcaster was an experienced raider who had had time to perfect his arson skills while inflicting damage in New York, some say even causing the Great Fire of Manhattan which nearly obliterated all of Long Island.
The President was caught in the blaze and died from smoke inhalation. The nation was stunned and without a leader and because Madison had not bothered to raise anyone up to the office of Vice President since it was left by Elbridge Gerry in 1814 there was no single man who seemed worthy or indeed capable of taking up the mantle and leading the nation in reclaiming not only New York and New Orleans but Charleston which had been invaded scant weeks before.
John Armstrong was the Secretary of War since almost the beginning of the conflict and had run the Reckoning War from his own office in Washington DC and from the frontlines, he had gained a good working knowledge of politics and of the Constitution, so it was with a heavy heart that he invoked Article I, Section 8, Clause 18 of the United States Constitution on November 18th of 1823.
John Armstrong declared nation wide martial law and elected himself and the leading generals of the day: Solomon Van Rennselaer of the Army of New England, James Wilkinson of the Army of the Tennessee River, and William Henry Harrison of the Army of the Northwest as the Executive Council of the United States. He promised to restore elections as soon as the threat from Great Britain had passed.
There was of course some internal strife but the good majority of the people were easily persuaded into sacrificing their votes in order to defeat the British menace. Firstly though Armstrong had to decide what a victory would entail, there were the obvious things like restoring Charleston and New Orleans to American control and the ceasing of all trade between the British and the Indians who were hostile to the United States.
Armstrong was a smart man though and liked the fact that as it stood, thanks Isaac Hull and the Battle of Cape Horn, that the fledgling American nation actually controlled the only known passage to Asia through the Atlantic Ocean route. The Executive Council also quickly realized that they would not have enough money to pay their soldiers for years to come and that if they held more territory they could use that as a bargaining chip at the Peace Table.
So James Wilkinson would do something daring, he would travel from the main front and open up the Caribbean to the full brunt of American wrath, with barely any competent troops and having to rely on conscripted pirates, black troops, and Indians who had previously been hostile to the United States he would take Jamaica. [1]
Most of the British troops that had been in Jamaica were currently trying to pacify the Orleans Territory and so it came as a shock when Wilkinson landed, burned Kingston to the ground, and declared all slaves that would rise up against the British as free citizens of the United States.
He brought guns to supply the Maroons who had been fighting a guerilla war in the mountains, he quickly and efficiently rounded up the leading plantation owners of the Jamaican colony and quietly deported them to Florida where they would reside until the final negotiations freed them and returned them to their possessions in 1828.
The United States government confiscated these large plantations and would use local Maroons as guards and former slaves as cheaply paid workers while the average American soldiers would run the day to day business on the plantation and send the sugar cane back to their beloved American homeland.
It was a remarkably similar strategy to the one adopted by the Army of the Northwest in the large grain producing regions of Upper Canada which ironically ended up feeding most of the American troops who would come to fight in Canada, the surplus was of course sold on the American market.
The British were stunned and appalled by the actions undertaken by the Americans and would carry out reprisals in the territory under their control, namely the Orleans Territory and central New York until 1825.
The Taking of Jamaica was the last big move of the Reckoning War and both sides would up end suing for peace in 1827. Final negotiations resulted in Charleston and New Orleans being returned to the United States, Halifax and Jamaica were returned to Great Britain, and prisoners on both sides were shuffled around until the last boatload carried those Brits that felt like leaving out of Florida.
The most interesting trade was the Americans giving up claims to Texas in exchange for Great Britain recognizing their right to the Falklands Islands and the surrounding areas near Cape Horn. The British were supposedly acting on behalf of the nation of Spain when they negotiated for Texas, which would have made more sense if Spain still existed. [2]
Tecumseh and his Confederation demanded that the British address the fact that so many Indians had been deported to Florida during the war, when the British refused Tecumseh took up arms and incited the tribes of the Ohio Valley to rebel against the United States.
Tecumseh’s Battle was squashed completely and utterly by the well trained and angry American forces who managed to slaughter the thousand or so strong Indian army. After this act of aggression Armstrong ordered all of the remaining natives in the states of Ohio, New York, Pennsylvania, and Delaware to be forcibly removed to Florida.
Those former slaves who had served in the Negro Divisions were also given land in Florida and encouraged to move there. As well as about 500 Jamaican partisans who had joined American forces.
Elections were restored in the United States in 1830 and John Armstrong was in a presidential mood, so was the general populace as they swept him to victory and named William Henry Harrison his Vice President.
The most pressing concern of the new government was finding some way to pay the former soldiers and help revitalize the American economy.
James Wilkinson would become the first governor of the Territory of Florida, formerly the Military District of Florida and would rule with an iron fist, thanks in part to the former Red Sticks and the blacks of the ND and the Jamaicans who would make up the largest sections of his police force which would be instrumental in keeping so many angry Indians in line.
1830 saw a rash of new territories being admitted as states, Orleans and West Florida were both admitted as states, Baton Rouge serving as the capital of Orleans and Mobile serving as the capital of West Florida.
The Mississippi Territory was divided into Alabama and Mississippi with Alabama’s new capital at Saint Stephens on the Tombigbee River, Mississippi’s new capital would be the relatively new town of Columbus. [3]
[1] All the above mentioned were easily found in Florida.
[2] Essentially Britain just said “Hey we’ll recognize your Falklands if you let us have Texas.
[3] No Jackson means no Jackson, Mississippi so I just went with my favorite city in Mississippi