Black Jack's 20s

HueyLong

Banned
1920: John J. Pershing is chosen as the Republican Presidential Candidate. He is viewed as too liberal by some, but is popular among many civilians and veterans. His politics were balanced out by the addition of Hiram W. Johnson, an Irreconcilable, as vice presidential nominee. His Democratic opponent, James M. Cox, is a dark-horse and uninteresting.

Pershing’s campaign was the most expensive campaign in the United States, costing nearly 9 million dollars. It included radio broadcasts (a campaign first), a nationwide tour and a large “mobilization” program designed to get veterans to the polls.

Pershing won the popular vote and electoral vote by a landslide. The women’s vote and veteran’s vote are viewed as key to his election.

1921: "...to care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his widow and his orphan..."- Abraham Lincoln

The Bureau of Veteran’s Affairs is founded. Its primary duty is to demilitarize the large number of army hospitals for their use by veterans and their families. It also listens to the demands of various veteran organizations and relays these to the President. It is decried as socialistic by some, but Black Jack’s anti-Red record cannot be denied.

Eugene V. Debs issues an appeal to be pardoned for wartime sedition. Pershing refused to pardon Debs and many other war protesters (primarily socialists like Debs.)

The Revenue Act of 1921 repealed a number of wartime taxes, such as the excess profits tax, which was hoped by some liberals to remain in effect. It was the first of many Republican attempts to lower taxes.

The Washington Naval Conferences end with recognition of Japanese possessions in Manchuria, Qingdao and Mongolia (primarily to oppose the Soviet presence there). Japan agreed to make no further claims and to respect the Open Door in its Chinese territories. An 8:3 ratio is accepted for Britain and America vis-à-vis the Japanese. Entente forces would be kept in Vladivostok until 1925, when a conference would be called to make a decision on the city. Pershing, however, was able to lower the amount of American troops stationed in the Russian city, much to the dislike of the British and Japanese.

Columbia’s overtures for an indemnity over the loss of Panama are rejected by President Pershing.

1922: The Fordney-McCumber Tariff Act is passed. It sets a scientific tariff, a rate designed to determine differences in production costs as part of the tariff. It also includes the American selling price, the price of a dutiable good in the American market.

Democratic representative Cordell Hall on the issue: "Our foreign markets depend both on the efficiency of our production and the tariffs of countries in which we would sell. Our own tariffs are an important factor in each. They injure the former and invite the latter."

Republican President John J. Pershing: “American markets need protection. We were drawn into the spiral of war by Europe, why should we be drawn into the spiral of panic?”

1922 also saw the suggestion of a national highway system for the United States. The Pershing Map, a map drafted originally by the Army Chief of Staff and edited by President Pershing himself, was a proposed system of civilian and military highways distributed to support the National Highway Act of 1922 (passed on September 23, 1922). The National Highway Authority, founded by the act, began hiring and contracting companies before the year was over. The military highways were given priority in construction and funding. The Authority also decided such policies as the shipping route monopolies and the inclusion of toll roads in the National Highway System. All of the roads are to be owned by the Federal Government, not by the states or private companies.

Historical Note: Republican Support for a National Highway?

Many are perturbed by the seemingly out-of-character Republican support for the National Highway Act. The Republican Party was against government interference, against government spending, and generally laissez-faire when it came to the development of the country. A variety of reasons changed this trend when it came to the National Highway.

First, there was the personal support of President Pershing, who had gained immense popular support and had, despite misgivings over his political leanings, had proved himself to be a stalwart Republican. He believed that a system of highways was essential to the growth and security of the United States.

Second, there was the support of the military in the plan. The Army needed a system for war transportation that was more efficient than the rails had been. The highway was seen as a solution. Some airplane advocates even suggested that military highways could be converted to landing strips. With many still in the war mentality of the Great War, such reasoning struck a chord.

Third, there was considerable support from industrialists, firm allies of the Republican Party. The railroads, de-nationalized after the war, had shot their rates sky-high. Manufacturers disliked relying on these unscrupulous shipping companies, and believed that a national highway would lower shipping costs considerably, and open up options beyond the primarily monopolistic railroads. Ford claimed that a national highway would make an automobile as common a sight as a cloud.

The Republicans reversed their small government trend for an industrial subsidy, for defense and for Black Jack. The National Highway Act authorized a huge government expenditure and large governmental interference with the economy, and was supported by the Party against all of that.


1923: The National Highway Authority is voted by Congress the funds it needs for the first tier of military highways.

1924: Black Jack is nominated as the Presidential candidate of the Republican Party for the 1924 Presidential election. His Vice Presidential Nominee is chosen as Charles G. Dawes.

His Democratic opponent, John W. Davis, lambasted the National Highway Act as a point of his campaign. He trumpeted states’ rights and fiscal conservatism, gaining a strong foothold in the Solid South and even in the West where the Highway Act was seen as a subsidy to the already-affluent East.

A Republican Senator by the name of Robert M. La Follette, Sr. ran on a Progressive Party ticket. His party was easily labeled as Socialist, as he used as a main campaign point the imprisonment of Socialist war protesters. He failed to win even his home state of Wisconsin, losing it to Black Jack.

Black Jack won the election, although he lost much of the South and Southwest to the Democratic Candidate.

The Immigration Act of 1924 was passed after intense lobbying on the part of supporters. It limited immigration to 3% of a specific ethnicity’s standing in the census of 1890. It primarily targeted non-whites, specifically Asians and Southern Europeans.

The Indian Citizenship Act gave citizenship to all Indians residing in the United States. It was regarded by many tribes as an attempt once again to assimilate them and destroy their identity.

In addition, the Revenue Act of 1924 finally levied taxes on Indians, and removed the need for the “Indians, not taxed” clause. The Revenue Act lowered taxes even further, and included an “earned income credit” designed to lower the taxes of the working poor.

The Republican Party still had a majority in Congress and the Senate, although NHA opposition was rising in the Democratic ranks.
 
Last edited:

HueyLong

Banned
He was a weak-willed Wilsonian, thats about it. He couldn't stick to his own opinions about anything, and was pretty much a dead-horse candidate. James M. Cox lost to Harding, a man without any popular base, and up against a popular candidate like Pershing, he would stand less of a chance.
 
A Republican Senator by the name of Robert M. La Follette, Sr. ran on a Progressive Party ticket. His party was easily labeled as Socialist, as he used as a main campaign point the imprisonment of Socialist war protesters. He failed to win even his home state of Wisconsin, losing it to Black Jack.

Very interesting time line and extremely well informed. However I'm going to have to dispute this, there is no way La Follete would have lost Wisconsin. During the 1924 election he carried the state by 20 points and Wisconsin had at this time been a traditionally republican bell water state. Furthermore the socialist label wouldn't have done too much harm there and in the upper Midwest where socialist parties were both decently strong and respected. I'm not disputing that he would have lost the national election but you have to realize how popular he was in Wisconsin. The La Follete name almost guaranteed an election victory until the postwar era, even still one of his descendants occupies a figure head position of Wisconsin's secretary of state.
 

HueyLong

Banned
1925: John J. Pershing issued an executive order for desegregation of the United States military. He had been a officer of the 10th Cavalry, and long held respect for black soldiers. He believed that segregation in the armed forces lowered the fighting spirit and the manpower pool of the United States. Many black WWI veterans had come back expecting to gain their rights for their service.

In addition, Pershing and many other conservatives had become worried about the pervasiveness of communism and socialism among blacks. He hoped that by allowing desegregation and some civil rights progress, communist efforts in the black populace could be halted. Pershing followed the order for desegregation with a large sweep of black labor leaders, throwing many into prison for trumped up charges of treason or inciting revolt.

Political opposition was muted from Republicans, who tried to give a show of solidarity against Democratic opposition. The issue almost threatened to raise the Ku Klux Klan once again. However, the D.C. Stephenson case and various cases of corruption halted Klan efforts to oppose the order. The Klan simply could not revive itself on segregation in the armed forces. Still, a large number of officers ignored the order almost completely, and only a few units would become truly integrated during the 20s.

1926: In the wake of the Ku Klux Klan collapse of 1925, Pershing took the opportunity to conduct a number of arrests on treason or embezzlement charges. A large number of men with ties to the Klan, many of them Democratic politicians, found themselves in bars their political careers ruined. The states of Alabama, Indiana and Oklahoma found a huge number of politicans and officials arrested on charges of associating with the Klan. The Second Klan died in a furious government assault after a period of scandal and a small chance of revival.

John J. Pershing made a statement in favor of removing prohibition, and then withdrew his statement on the suggestion of the Party elite. He submitted to Congress a bill that would allow federal officers more power to pursue and convict people who broke the prohibition laws and would give the officers a great amount of power in seizing the assets of suspected criminals. This legislation, the Enforcement Bill, would also extend to subversives such as Reds and Klansmen.

Al Capone died in an opposing gang's raid on September 20 at the Hawthorne Inn. Thousands of people came to attend his funeral, and he was almost sainted by many in the crowd.
 

HueyLong

Banned
As for LaFollette, I will consider retconning that little jibe. A little note though, Pershing is a bit more respected by many in the labor movement than the Republican presidents OTL- less corruption, less view as a business puppet, and socialism is a bit more discredited (America is still involved in Entente efforts in Vladivostok, [forgot to mention that 1925 Conference kept American forces in Vladivostok, oops.], and so there are a few well-published martyrs of the murderous Soviets. In addition, the Socialist movement has lost more than a few good men due to war charges)

WW2 going to be quite different if it exists at all. Japan hasn't been alienated from the West to the same degree as in OTL, and a Soviet-Japanese War in the early 30s is likely to predate any war in Europe.
 

HueyLong

Banned
Japan

Japan has since 1921 waged a war against Soviet and Chinese partisans in Manchuria, Inner Mongolia. Qingdao and the Shandong region, which was almost seized by a riot and an attempt at seizure by the KMT's political army in 1922, is being modernized for use as the administrative capital of Japan's Chinese possessions. Vladivostok is held by a White Russian and Entente force, with Japan's participation counted as 70,000 active troops in 1925 (America has 5,000, Britain has 15,000, White forces have no reliable records.)

The Tokyo Conference of 1925, called together to decide on the fate of Vladivostok, ended without a significant change in troop deployments. The British stated that they would be withdrawing 5,000 men from active duty in the city, America was blocked by the other delegates from ending its defense obligations for the city. Japan had invited White Russian delegates to talk of future government of the city (At the time, ruled by an ad-hoc system of patchwork White commands, autonomous communities and the more powerful Entente commands) However, the talks did not get to this, and a 1928 Conference was promised in which the Americans could withdraw and Britain could further scale back their deployments. The Soviet Union annexed the Far Eastern Republic during the conference as a show of power and "force of will."

Japan has tried to ratify Manchuria, Inner Mongolia and Shandong as League of Nation mandates but has failed consistently. Vladivostok has never been brought up as a proposed Mandate.
 
Excellent TL please continue.

How is Pershing's relationship with Central and South America? IIRC didn't the US send Marines to various states there during this time period?
 

Glen

Moderator
1920: John J. Pershing is chosen as the Republican Presidential Candidate. He is viewed as too liberal by some, but is popular among many civilians and veterans.


First, let me say I find the idea of a Pershing Presidency intriguing. Good work.

His politics were balanced out by the addition of Hiram W. Johnson, an Irreconcilable, as vice presidential nominee. His Democratic opponent, James M. Cox, is a dark-horse and uninteresting.

However, if Pershing is considered too liberal, how in the heck does Hiram Johnson, one of the founders of the Progressive party, balance him? If you want balance, you would need to find a more conservative Republican.

Actually, Cool Cal still wouldn't be a bad choice for VP.

As for Cox, I don't believe he was considered a dark-horse candidate at the time.

Pershing’s campaign was the most expensive campaign in the United States, costing nearly 9 million dollars. It included radio broadcasts (a campaign first), a nationwide tour and a large “mobilization” program designed to get veterans to the polls.

Pershing won the popular vote and electoral vote by a landslide. The women’s vote and veteran’s vote are viewed as key to his election.

A landslide seems unlikely, but a healthy margin is okay. The bigger problem I think is getting the nomination to begin with, though that is not insurmountable.

1921: "...to care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his widow and his orphan..."- Abraham Lincoln

The Bureau of Veteran’s Affairs is founded. Its primary duty is to demilitarize the large number of army hospitals for their use by veterans and their families. It also listens to the demands of various veteran organizations and relays these to the President. It is decried as socialistic by some,


but Black Jack’s anti-Red record cannot be denied.
Eugene V. Debs issues an appeal to be pardoned for wartime sedition. Pershing refused to pardon Debs and many other war protesters (primarily socialists like Debs.)

Okay, wonder what will come of this....

....
1922: The Fordney-McCumber Tariff Act is passed. It sets a scientific tariff, a rate designed to determine differences in production costs as part of the tariff. It also includes the American selling price, the price of a dutiable good in the American market.

I've thought of things like this before in the past. Where did this idea come from, is this a real Act that failed OTL?

More comments later.
 
and included an “earned income credit” designed to lower the taxes of the working poor.
Sorry the Earned income Credit is a holdover from the attempts in the 60's and 70's to get a negative Income Tax passed.
There is no way that this would be passed int the '20's, Whe are still in the Age of the Rugged Individual, in America.
 

HueyLong

Banned
Hmm.... I misread the rates for the Revenue Act of 1924. They are listed in EITC terms, they did not actually include an EITC clause. (I had assumed that it was basically a loosely defined tax credit to get rates lower than those proscribed in the bill, not today's EITC.) I apologize for that blurb, retcon it out. However, just from doing a quick search to rectify my mistake, there were similiar efforts to lower taxes on the poor among those in the Efficiency Movement (Hoover and many of the Republican laissez-faire crowd).

The Fordney-McNumber Act is OTL, simply mentioned to show that protectionism continues and still thrives in Black Jack's 20s.

Hmm.... I was choosing Johnson based on his anti-League merits and had not considered his very progressive lean, (book on the Jazz Age I was using only really mentions him when it comes to the League debate). Will have to retcon that......

Cox was a dark-horse candidate, but Harding was no popular hero either. When up against a popular hero, he is definitely a dark horse, and loses even more than in OTL.

The election of 1920 was the first presidential election where women could vote. 19th Amendment.
 
I'd like to believe that Pres Black Jack would've been an advocate of black soldiers, but given his poor treatment of the AEF's black contingents during WWI despite his own personal combat experience in the 10th Cav, could he have really stuck to his guns over his Buffalo Soldiers again, & how would the black community have reacted towards him ?
 

HueyLong

Banned
The effort is mainly symbolic. It does not give blacks an equal opportunity in the army beyond on paper. Most units remain de facto segregated, individual administrator's biases keep blacks out of many units. However, the removal of a legal status for these segregated units will eventually be a much broader base for reform.

The black community is mixed as to their opinion of him (and the Republican Party as a whole.) While some black leaders appreciate the effort, many more dislike the political imprisonment policies and they realize that in truth, the order has little influence on real practice at first.

The black community will, however, rally around the Republicans due to a different handling of the Mississippi Flood which will be covered sometime next week.
 

HueyLong

Banned
People of Historical Note: United States pre-Crash

Republicans

John J. Pershing "Black Jack"- President of the United States 1921-1929, noted for his support of US military involvement in Asia and his harsh anti-Red policies

Charles Evan Hughes- Vice-President of the United States from 1921-1924. Died while in office. [retcon]

Charles G. Dawes- Vice-President of the United States 1925-1929

Herbert Hoover- United States Secretary of Commerce 1921-1928, Republican Presidential Candidate 1928, known for his extensive broadening of the Department of Commerce, his support for the NHA and his handling of the flood of 1927.

Henry Cabot Lodge- Massachusetts Senator 1892-1924, Senate Majority Leader 1920-1924, died in 1924. Noted for his anti-League of Nations stance, an opposition to Black Jack's international commitments and as a major proponent of immigration restrictions

James Eli Watson- Indiana Senator 1916-1933, Senate Majority Leader 1924-1929, regarded as the political heir of Joe Cannon, James Eli Watson controlled the Senate during his time with an iron fist and a good throwing arm. He was known for his private parties and outspoken conservative views. He clashed repeatedly with Presidents Pershing and Davis.

Democrats

John. W. Davis- Democratic Presidential Candidate 1924 and 1928, President of the United States 1929-1933, noted for his opposition to the NHA and the VA, his support for states-rights and segregation and his classical-liberal ideals

Alfred Emmanuel Smith "Al"-Democratic Vice-Presidential Candidate 1928, Vice-President of the United States, noted for pushing Prohibition through Congress despite party and presidential dissapproval

Progressives

Hiram W. Johnson- Vice-Presidential Candidate 1924 and 1928 for the Progressive Party, returned as Senator after both bids

Robert M. LaFollette Sr. "Battling Bob"- Presidential Candidate 1924 and 1928 for the Progressive Party, took only his home state in both elections. He returned as Governor of Wisconsin after his failed bids. His son, Robert M. LaFollette became a US Senator in 1928, as a Progressive.

Eugene V. Debs- Still imprisoned for sedition and treason into 1929, Debs was a protest vote in the Election of 1928, drawing votes from the Republican Progressives and from liberal supporters of the Democrats

Military/International

Smedley Darlington Butler "The Fighting Quaker"- Commander of the Marine Expeditionary Force in Vladivostok (claimed as a Japanese mandate), supporter of immediate withdrawal from Vladivostok

Charles Lindbergh "Lucky Lindy"- [His flight goes exactly the same as OTL] President of the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics 1928-1933, appointed by conservative Republicans before election of 1928 was resolved

John L. Hines- Army Chief of Staff 1921-1929, known for leaving much of the management to Black Jack himself

Douglas MacArthur- Superintendent of West Point Military Academy 1919-1921, private retirement from 1921-1928, Commander of the Phillipines Department 1928-1930, Army Chief of Staff 1929-1933; clashed multiple times with Black Jack during his presidency, appointed as Army Chief of Staff by President Davis over the personal feud with Black Jack as well as his experience in Southeast Asia
 

HueyLong

Banned
The Soviet Union

[Soviet-Polish War went much as it did in OTL, there was not a significant drain of resources as the Eastern War was primarily a sitting war, and primarily partisan]

Lev Borischovich Kamenev became General Secretary of the All-Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) in 1924[In OTL, Stalin got this position]. Largely regarded as an unimportant position, Lev Kamenev used it to cement a burgeoning alliance with the Trotskyist left, using his control of the social network and party memberships to remove rightists and reactionaries.

Leon Trotsky, head of the Sovnarkom [Council of People's Commissars] since 1923, had taken control of much of the government during Lenin's slow decline in health and particularly after Lenin's Last Will and Testament. He allied with Kamenev for greater control over the Party itself.

It is not known when Nadezhda Konstantinova Krupskaya [Lenin's wife] was drawn into this alliance, although many believe that she is the author of Lenin's Will and Testament, which glorified Trotsky and demonized the Right. She served as a propaganda tool for Trotsky, and worked among many of the Old Guards to garner support for his purges of the Right.

Shortly after Lenin's death, Trotsky began removing individuals affiliated with the Right from the Government. One Politburo member, Josef Stalin, tried to organize a Right Opposition belatedly into the purges. Bukharin was expelled from the Soviet Union in 1927, as was Joseph Stalin. They went first to Scandinavia, where they would form the International Communist Opposition, although their alliance would be a shaky one.

Trotsky tightened the policies of the NEP, supporting consolidation into larger estates and putting more price controls into effect.

His first Labour Army, an attempt to regimentalize workers in the manner of earlier casual labor, was launched in 1928. It did not attract many workers, and was primarily composed of convicts.

Trotsky's troika opposed the return to normalcy that was proposed by the right and center. Trotsky did not fall back from his stand of World Revolution. He annexed the Far Eastern Republic in 1925 during the Washington Conferences. He actively used state funds to pay revolutionary forces throughout the world (especially in Germany, Italy and Turkey). He issued proclamations regarding revolution in Poland, the Baltic and in China. He stepped up the Soviet Union's military presence in the East, beginning with the Drive East of 1929.......
 
Cool TL. I look forward to seeing how TTL's analogue to the Civil Rights movement takes shape. :)

I'll speculate that TTL's USA might get drawn into a confrontation with the Soviets eventually...but regardless, I look forward to more.
 

HueyLong

Banned
The US is already in conflict with the Soviet Union- they still have about 5000 active duty soldiers on Russian soil (Vladivostok, recognized as Japanese territory by the US)

However, there is no one with the political will of Black Jack to keep men over there. Despite Japanese (and to a lesser extent, British) complaints, The US Expeditionary Force will return to the United States before the Soviets make a drive against Vladivostok.

The US won't recognize the Soviets until later than in OTL either.

A Japanese-Soviet War will happen before any US-Soviet involvement.

Thanks, David, for reading and responding. Got any suggestions or ideas, just PM me and I'll consider them.
 
Top