New Sweden's Revenge

Part 1 - The storm dies

August 5, 1638
- The storm was like nothing he had ever seen. The wind was tearing the sails to peices. Deep green waves were breaking over the bow, and knocking men off their feet. Two poor souls had already been swept over board. It wasn't a big ship, maybe a 100 feet long with high narrow castle in the stern, and Peter Minuit was convinced it was going to be his coffin.[1]

Comming to the Caribbean had been a mistake. Better to have head directly back to Sweden with news of the colony. But the tobacco profits were too tempting to resist, now he was paying the price. The man who had bought Manhattan for the Dutch was going to drown somewhere off St. Kitts.

For two days the ship was battered by the hurricane. They lost the foremast and three more sailors, but somehow the ship refused to sink. By the evening of the second day the winds began to die, and by the next morning the sun rose over clear skies with some choppy seas the only evidence of the previous days' great storm. They had survived. Peter Minuit wasn't going to die today.

February 17, 1639 - The second fleet had arrived. Three ships full of trade goods, tools, news and most importantly colonists. Captain Mans Nilsson Kling was at the landing stage as his boss was rowed ashore at Fort Christina. Minuit jumped ashore relieved to see the colony survived, not only was it still there, it was propsering.

Kling brought Minuit up to speed on the news of New Sweden's first fall and winter. Then Governor Minuit's brought the news from Europe, and from the court in Stockholm. He had met with Chancellor Oxenstierna, who effectively ran the country on behalf of the 12-year old "Girl King." He told Oxenstierna about the success of New Sweden, but also of the dangers of continuing growth of the English and Dutch colonies nearby. A strong start to the colony would make all the difference for Sweden's chances in the new world. He persuaded Oxenstierna to get the government of Sweden more involved in the colony and to provide more ships and colonists. That is why we had returned with three ships, with about 200 more settlers. And another fleet would be coming in a few months. [2]

June 29, 1643 - It was time for Minuit to leave New Sweden. Christiana was more than just a fort now, with three or four hundred people living around the wooden pallisades. It controlled all trade on what people were now calling the Christina River - to Minuit, it was still the Zyudt River from his days as Governor of New Netherland. No ships could pass without and enter the rich fur trapping areas beyond without the permission of New Sweden.

One last time before he left he met with the new Governor sent out to replace him, Johan Björnsson Printz. "If I have one peice of advice for you Governor Printz it is to avoid conflict with the Dutch. I was once the governor of New Netherland, and I know them well. They see all of New Sweden as theirs, but if we avoid needlessly provoking them New Sweden can grow until it is strong enough to defend itself. The Dutch has issued deeds for all the lands to the east of the Christina River, so even though the shores are empty, claiming them will give them cause to hate us. The future of this colony lies to the west, not the east. We have good relations with the Indians and the English are far to the south. Do not compete with the Dutch over a few square miles of marsh when there is a whole continent ahead of us."

Printz agreed that it was the best policy. Minuit departed promissing to encourage the government to send more colonists.[3]

April 2, 1655 - To Olavi Termonen the new world looked quite a lot like the old one. Same trees, same burnt forests, same log cabins, same people. Termonen has just arrived from Sweden with 120 fellow Forest Fins. He spoke the Finnish of eastern Finland nearest Russia, but had never been there. He had grown up in northern Sweden, living the life like his ancestors. Building cabins, clearing the land by slashing and burning.

In Sweden the traditional life of the Forest Finns was now under assault. In 1647 a law had been passed that forbade the burning of forests, because the wood was now needed for charcoal for iron production. Of course some Forest Finns farther north kept slashing and burning, but had Termonen lived bit too close to royal authority. A cousin of his had left for New Sweden a year before, and with nothing else to lose he decided to give it a shot as well.

The voyage had been dreadful, and now he was in a new land, much like the old one. The Swedes were still in charge, and the Finns did all the hard work. All around the fort at Christina log cabins in the traditional Finnish style had been built, and many people were speaking Finnish as well. Of course it was not the only language. The Swedes were there too, but so were Germans, Walloons from the Low Countries and even some Dutch. The Dutch were natural traders and had already established some commercial relationships with their fellow countrymen on the eastern shore of the Christina River. Fort Nassau was across from Fort Nya Gothenborg, home of the Printzhof, built by Governor Printz and now owned by his son-in-law Johan Papegoja.

More and more settlers were moving north and south along the river. To the north was rolling country rich in trade with the Minquas, our native allies. To the south was good farmland and some small tobacco plantations were springing up. Some slaves from the Swedish Gold Coast had been brought to work the plantations. Termonen was going to head north and west and find some land near Nya Gothenborg to work.

August 9, 1655 - When word had arrived of renewed war in Europe most people got worried. War was bad for trade, and New Amsterdam was about nothing if not trade. But for Peter Stuyvesant war meant opportunity.

Sweden was distracted invading the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. Now could be an opportunity to get rid of those Swedish interlopers on the Zyudt River. He didn't have the men or resources for a long campaign and he didn't want to provoke a general war with Sweden. But if a quick coup de main could be pulled off...

It would have to be quick, since there had only been peace with the English for a year, and becoming too embroiled with New Sweden would give opportunities to the English settlers in Connecticut and Long Island.

Could it be done quickly? New Netherland had been growing fast - there was now around 3,500 Dutch settlers spread across 230 miles from Fort Orange down to south of Staaten Eylandt. No one was sure how many people lived in New Sweden, but it was at least 2,500 - in a much more concentrated area. And they had the Minquas as allies. Many Dutch farms and settlements to the west of the North River were exposed to Minquas raids. Stuyvesant was pretty sure he could win, but he wasn't sure he could win quickly. Every day he was at war with the Swedes would be another day of burnt farms and refugess streaming into New Amsterdam. He decided against it, the risk was too great. There would be other opportunities. In the meantime, better to prepare so when the time came New Netherland would be ready.

**********************
[1] In OTL Minuit died when his ship was lost in the hurricane. This is the POD.
[2] In OTL immigration was far slower, I am assuming a capable "man with a plan" like Minuit could have persuaded the government to be more aggressive.
[3] This is the other impact of Minuit living. In OTL Printz founded Fort Nya Elfsborg on the east side of the river. Thus when Peter Stuyvesant became Director-General of New Netherland in 1648 he took action as part of a sort of "arms race" on the Delaware. He built Fort Beversreede on the Swedish side in 1848 near what is now Philadelphia, and then in 1851 built Fort Casimir (now New Castle, Delaware) only a few miles downriver from Fort Christina (now Wilmington). In 1654 Swedish militia took Fort Casimir. The Dutch took it back in the fall of 1655, and captured the rest of New Sweden while they were at it. In our OTL this was the end of New Sweden. But in TTL...
 
Last edited:
Part 2 - Survival

July 24, 1664 - Four English ships sailed into the great harbour below New Amsterdam. Colonel Richard Nicolls, leading 600 soliders aboard demanded the surrender of the colony. Four ships would not be enough. Stuyvesant had been getting New Amsterdam ready for war for years. More cannons, more gunpowder, more food in reserve and most important more people. He had been encouraging settlement and free land for former Dutch soliders and sailors. Ten years ago there had only be 3,500 people in the entire colony, now there was nearly that in New Amsterdam alone. The intended target had been the Swedes, but the English would have to do.

The Dutch replied to the English demands with their cannons. The shots from the fort didn't too much damage and the fleet stood off out of range, waiting for the Dutch to reconsider. That night they sent their final answer.

After midnight half a dozen large canoes left the Broad Canal. Each one was paddled by two men. When they were within 400 yards of the English ships, fuses were lit on five of the canoes. Their crews jumped overboard and paddled to the other canoe. The first the English knew anything about these "fire canoes" packed full of gunpowder and resin was when one of them explored prematurely. The blast woke up half of New Amsterdam and the flames could be seen from everypoint on the shores of the harbour.

Ironically, this is what lead to the destruction of the fleet. Alerted by the blast the English sailors immediately cut the cables to their anchors. One canoe found its mark, setting an English ship aflame. Another explored harmlessly, and the fuses on the other two fizzled out. But the damage was done, all four ships were bourne south by the tide towards Staten Island. One managed to get its head around in time and avoid the shoals. The other three were not so well handled. They ran aground and one burned through the night. In the morning and high tide one floated off. The survivors from the other two ships straggled ashore wet, cold, hungry and weaponless.

Now Stuyvesant had a message for Nicolls. If the English agreed not to fight, they would help them refloating the unburt ship, and the survivors would be allowed to re-embark unmolested. Nicolls agreed and three weeks later they were back in Boston with their tails between their legs.

September 22, 1675 - Petter Termonen was running for his life. It wasn't supposed to be dangerous - or his father would never have let him go this far south.

The Minquas were at war with the Catholics. For years the Catholics of Maryland had been moving north, getting closer and closer to New Sweden and encroaching on their Minquas allies. No formal war had been declared, just backcountry raids for three or four years now. There had been a war about thirty years before, and the Catholics had lost that one too.[4] With a strengthening New Sweden, helping and arming the Minquas, Maryland a fractious collection of faiths and sects ruled by a Catholic divided by the English Civil War had become more unified. Lord Baltimore had brought over as many Catholics as he could find, espescially from Southern Germany, and even some from Bohemia, devestated by war. But it was the Bavarians that had Petter Termonen running.

He had crossed the broad Susquehanna River three days ago with three of his Minquas cousins. They were now almost at the head of the Bay. He had been bringing some guns, powder and musket balls to the Minquas war party that was attacking Bavarian farms. They hadn't found the war party so they had continued south confident that any Catholics in the area were either dead or running away. So it was a complete surprise to walk into farm, not only intact, but fortified and full of extremely angry Germans. The first volley had killed two of his group, and wounded three more. That left four of them running north.

They could hear the Bavarians behind, and the occasional shot rang through the forest. Then Petter heard the sound he'd been told to fear - the bark of hunting dogs. He now he could hear them as well, crashing through the underbrush. If a dog caught him, he'd waste too much time fighting it to outrun the Bavarians. By the sounds of it there were only two dogs coming, but two hungry pissed off german dogs were enough to ruin anyone's day.

He shouted to his cousins, and pointed to boulder ahead. They all scrambled up it's sides. Petter handed his pre-loaded musket to his eldest cousin, no longer a youth, really a warrior now, and the best shot of the bunch. The dogs were coming and he didn't have time to load another musket, but he started anyway. He could see the dogs coming through a clearing. He put the charge in barrell. His cousin's musket roared and the nearest dog fell dead. The blast took his youngest cousin by surprise and he slipped off the boulder.

The dog was five yards from him coming at full tilt. Petter slammed the ramrod into the barrel, raised the gun and fired. The rod hit the dog with nearly the force of bullet, impaling it. By the time his heart stopped beating he realised his cousins were off the rock and running again. He took off after them as fast as he could.

*****************************

[4] The Maryland/Susquehannock war of 1642-44. The English called the Minquas the Susquehannock. In OTL the Minquas had ultimately signed a treaty with Maryland in 1652 that gave up land on both sides of the bay exchange for arms. With a stronger New Sweden they had another source of arms, and did not give up the eastern side of the Bay.
 
Map of the Atlantic seaboard in 1675. The grey areas are unsettled by Europeans/controlled by the natives. I'm using a US county map which is the best I could find - does anyone know of any decent base maps for eastern North America?

1675 - Inset.png
 
Great start, this is the first New Sweden timeline I've seen that isn't ASB, keep up the good work.

It will be interesting to see how slavery develops in New Sweden, seeing as how it existed in English Pennsylvania and Delaware, but not on the scale of Maryland, Virginia, or New York (pre-Revolution).
 
Great start, this is the first New Sweden timeline I've seen that isn't ASB, keep up the good work.

Thanks, I spent a lot of time trying to keep New Sweden surviving realistic and then make sure the English don't take New Netherland. I've got some ideas, but keeping New Sweden going after Sweden loses the Great Northern War 1721 is going to take some doing.
 
Thanks, I spent a lot of time trying to keep New Sweden surviving realistic and then make sure the English don't take New Netherland. I've got some ideas, but keeping New Sweden going after Sweden loses the Great Northern War 1721 is going to take some doing.

By that point, you have butterflies enough to have Sweden not losing the equivalent war so badly. I don't say it would be a Swedish victory, you can just have it be more of a draw. The very existence of New Sweden would mean a different situation, where Sweden is somehow less focused on the Baltic and more on the North Sea. Which might cause a war where Sweden is more interested in imposing harsh terms on Denmark instead of wasting resources in turning herself into an existential threat for Poland and Russia. Of course, hostility with both would still be there and conflict ensues, but maybe the attempt to force Leszczinski on the Polish throne is not pursued to such lengths as OTL.
Revenue from America in this age might also help Sweden in the war overall.
I don't argue this implies integral Swedish Empire in the Baltic forever, but possibly a better deal for Sweden in the end.
 

ingemann

Banned
By that point, you have butterflies enough to have Sweden not losing the equivalent war so badly. I don't say it would be a Swedish victory, you can just have it be more of a draw. The very existence of New Sweden would mean a different situation, where Sweden is somehow less focused on the Baltic and more on the North Sea. Which might cause a war where Sweden is more interested in imposing harsh terms on Denmark instead of wasting resources in turning herself into an existential threat for Poland and Russia. Of course, hostility with both would still be there and conflict ensues, but maybe the attempt to force Leszczinski on the Polish throne is not pursued to such lengths as OTL.
Revenue from America in this age might also help Sweden in the war overall.
I don't argue this implies integral Swedish Empire in the Baltic forever, but possibly a better deal for Sweden in the end.

You can have a better peace quite easily in fact, you just need Charles XII to not be a idiot. Of course even if Sweden behave as stupid as historical, they may still keep New Sweden. The only two countries able to take it was either on the Swedish side (Netherlands) or changed side to Sweden at the end of the war (UK).
 
You can have a better peace quite easily in fact, you just need Charles XII to not be a idiot. Of course even if Sweden behave as stupid as historical, they may still keep New Sweden. The only two countries able to take it was either on the Swedish side (Netherlands) or changed side to Sweden at the end of the war (UK).

Actually Charles's strategy was pretty sound, except the bit where he managed to antagonize pretty much everybody in the neighborhood without realising Sweden had not the resources to defeat them all.
:rolleyes:
Jokes aside, it worked fairly well for a while. Knock-out Denmark and Saxony and put a pliant king over the mess known as Poland. At that point, he could reasonably hope to come to terms with an isolated Russia that, for what he knew, was just a large and useless backwater of limited importance. Of course, his error was a gross underestimation of an insolated enemy... that was somwhere five-ten times larger than the whole Swedish Empire just in population. :rolleyes:
Sorry, it's hard not to be sarcastic.
To be fair, however, it wasn't Sweden that started that war. And Poland was really quite of a mess.
 
Part 3
October 2, 1679
Nijmegen, United Provinces

It was a last minute addition to the treaty, but the Dutch plenipotentiary really did not care. The Franco-Dutch war was over, his country had lost and this was just about tying up loose ends. The last loose end was Sweden. Peace had been signed with France more than a year before, but Sweden remained. The terms had been agreed for at least a fortnight, but now the Swedes wanted to add something.

He'd heard about the skirmishes in America, and expected the same conditions as the French had demanded. It was the only part of the war that had gone well, a Dutch captain had capture the French colony of Acadia,[5] but it had been returned at the peace. To be honest he hadn't even known that the settlers of New Netherland had even managed to capture any of New Sweden until yesterday morning. Apparently, the Dutch had raided from Fort Nassau and burned the Printzhof and surrounding farms, near Nya Gothenborg, and heavens only knew where that was.

In retaliation, for this the Swedes were demanding part of New Netherland. A strip of land running down the east bank South River from the falls and out to the Atlantic. The strip of land was only to be three Parisian Leagues wide[6]. They said it would secure their colony from attack. He didn't care. If it would end the war he would sign. He hadn't checked with his superiors, but that was the point of being a plenipotentiary, it was up to you. He signed the treaty.

[5] This actually happened in 1674-75
[6] About 7.2 miles or 11.7 km
 
Last edited:
Part 4
September 29, 1685
Baie du Puants, Illinois County (Now Green Bay, WI)
Petter Termonen had been waiting to meet Nicolas Perrot for months. All through the long march through the mountains, through the narrow gap and down to the rivers. Then the canoeing, for months down the Great Charles River [7], and then up the River the French called the Mississippi. Now they were at Baie du Puants about to meet the legendary explorer and fur trapper.

Petter hadn't really wanted to come on this expedition, he would rather have been at his farm just north of Nya Gothenborg raising his sons. But he was half-Minquas, spoke the language, knew how to live in the bush, and the Knight of Alunda had promised him enough furs to buy a new farm. The Knight had not fared well on this trip west, he was a man more used to warfare in Pomerania and the courts of German princelings, than the bush of western America. But the King had asked for volunteers to explore the west and connect with the French, so the Knight was here.

They had set up two small trading posts along the way, better to stake Sweden's claim to the west and increase the trade in furs. Fort Charles had been the first at the confluence of the two rivers that created the Great Charles River[8]. Then several hundred miles later, Fort Ulrika named for the Kings's mother (or sister, Petter wasn't sure). Fort Ulrika was where another significant river, the Ulrika, flowed into the Great Charles [9]. It had been rich trapping country and he would do very well upon their return to New Sweden.

A few days before he'd asked the Knight why the French wanted them to come through such rich country. Surely, they would want it for themselves, he'd asked. They'd even explored it twenty years before. The Knight had explained that the French need an ally to serve as a bulwark between them and the English. Protestant Swedes in between Virginia and New France was a sure way to ensure the French had a free-hand in most of the Northwest. And after the Scanian War, the King of France felt he could trust the Swedes.

[7] Today's Ohio River.
[8] Pittsburgh
[9] The Great Miami River, west of Cincinnati
 
Last edited:

katchen

Banned
Interesting! A TL in which the Swedes aren't shunted to the far north but get the Ohio Valley! Which actually makes sense if they keep OTL Pennsylvania. (Svensylvania?:p I can't help it!
I wonder where William Penn will be granted his territory ITTL. St. Johns NB OTTL?
And where the Scots-Irish will settle from. Georgia?
 
Actually Charles's strategy was pretty sound, except the bit where he managed to antagonize pretty much everybody in the neighborhood without realising Sweden had not the resources to defeat them all.
:rolleyes:
Jokes aside, it worked fairly well for a while. Knock-out Denmark and Saxony and put a pliant king over the mess known as Poland. At that point, he could reasonably hope to come to terms with an isolated Russia that, for what he knew, was just a large and useless backwater of limited importance. Of course, his error was a gross underestimation of an insolated enemy... that was somwhere five-ten times larger than the whole Swedish Empire just in population. :rolleyes:
Sorry, it's hard not to be sarcastic.
To be fair, however, it wasn't Sweden that started that war. And Poland was really quite of a mess.

The best would be to have a less decisive victory at Narva that doesn´t convince Charles XII that he can always beat the Russians while outnumbered 10 to 1
 
Top