us enters ww2 in 1939

[danishroll]

what would have happened

[mowque]

Why? The reason is important.

[danishroll]

let say fdr hears how jews are being mistreated in germany
declares war on hitler also because illegal invasion of poland

[The Red]

Originally Posted by danishroll

let say fdr hears how jews are being mistreated in germany
declares war on hitler also because illegal invasion of poland

That wouldn't be enough, German submarines were sinking American ships and the US stayed neutral.

[danishroll]

Originally Posted by The Red

That wouldn't be enough, German submarines were sinking American ships and the US stayed neutral.

i'ts called what if what if usa declared war on germany in 1939
what would have happened

[mowque]

Originally Posted by danishroll

i'ts called what if what if usa declared war on germany in 1939
what would have happened

But how and why is important in predicting how it plays out.

[danishroll]

Originally Posted by mowque

But how and why is important in predicting how it plays out.

just tell me what you think

[mowque]

Originally Posted by danishroll

just tell me what you think

What I think? What about Japan? When in 1939?

[The Red]

Originally Posted by danishroll

just tell me what you think

The war ends around 1942.

If there's no real reason though, this should probably be in ASB.

[Emperor Norton I]

Isolationism. It took the destruction of an American fleet to get America into war with Japan. And Hitler and Mussolini declaring war on America after to get us into war against them.

[Tallest Skil]

Three identical threads, all far too general for real discussion, and covering topics done ad infinitum.

Um.

[danishroll]

Originally Posted by mowque

What I think? What about Japan? When in 1939?

sept 1 1939

japan is fighting with soviet union

[The Red]

Originally Posted by danishroll

japan is fighting with soviet union

Okay, how did that come about?

[imperialaquila]

Originally Posted by The Red

Okay, how did that come about?

Well, there's the OTL Battle of Khalkhin Gol, which would have been going on in September of 1939; but that was an isolated incident, not a general Japanese attack on the Soviet Union.

[danishroll]

Originally Posted by mowque

What I think? What about Japan? When in 1939?

Originally Posted by The Red

Okay, how did that come about?

all here hows it pans out
us enters ww2 in sept1 1939
we fight the nazis italians & thier allies in all major campaigns

stalin fights japanese & wipes them out

hitler dies when audie murphey kills him

[Hamelus]

Originally Posted by mowque

Why? The reason is important.

On the morning of September the 1th 1939, an ASB blares this song across all of the USA.

A few hours later, all Americans collectively scream "AMERICA FUCK YEAH" and the Congress declares war on the Axis.

See? This thread is reasonable after all.

[The Red]

Originally Posted by imperialaquila

Well, there's the OTL Battle of Khalkhin Gol, which would have been going on in September of 1939; but that was an isolated incident, not a general Japanese attack on the Soviet Union.

Oh I know that, I have a TL on it in fact.

[imperialaquila]

Originally Posted by The Red

Oh I know that, I have a TL on it in fact.

Really? Could I have the link for that, if it's not too much trouble? Sounds intriguing.

[The Red]

Originally Posted by imperialaquila

Really? Could I have the link for that, if it's not too much trouble? Sounds intriguing.

http://www.alternatehistory.com/disc...d.php?t=146429

Unfortunately it's not finished as it wasn't happy with the timeline's flow, I might do a second version over Christmas.

[imperialaquila]

Originally Posted by The Red

http://www.alternatehistory.com/disc...d.php?t=146429

Unfortunately it's not finished as it wasn't happy with the timeline's flow, I might do a second version over Christmas.

I would read that. This looks pretty interesting.