Flag Challenge #50

Who has the best flag?

  • Entry 1

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Entry 2

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • Entry 3

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • Entry 4

    Votes: 6 37.5%
  • Entry 5

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • Entry 6

    Votes: 2 12.5%
  • Entry 7

    Votes: 3 18.8%
  • Entry 8

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • Entry 9

    Votes: 1 6.3%
  • Entry 10

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

My flag challenge is one that was suggested before by Trovador:

The Filibuster Republic: the XIX century was full of ambitious adventurers, personal armies and unstable non-civilized regions. The result of these things was some very short-lived and unusual nations, such as the Republic of Sonora, the Republic of Acre and the Kingdom of Sarawak. Create a flag for a (OTL or ATL) "Filibuster" state that manages to survive - it doesn't have to survive until present day, but must exist for over 30 years.



I want to say beforehand that I am really glad to see so much entries this time and all of them high quality ones. Good luck to everyone with the poll!
 
ENTRY 1

Oh, perfect!
Well, here is the Republic of Texas, formed when a group of American settlers in West Texas found themselves locked in mortal combat with Mexican authorities, and receiving no help from the American government.

Poll1.png
 
ENTRY 2

San Juan Republic

Shortly after completion of the Nicaragua Canal c1859 civil war again engulfed Nicaragua. With the UK reaffirming a protectorate over the Misikito Coast (and parts of Nicarugua itself) the US bowed to pressure from Cornelius Vanderbilt to protect the canal and trade he had built and sent troops support the freebooter/filibuster Charles W Walsh* who was in charge of the Canal Security.
Using these troops Walsh carved out an independent republic along the Rio San Juan as a US protectorate.

During the US Civil War the Republic fell under control of the UK and remained separate from the rest of Nicaragua until the 3rd Canal Treaty of 1895 unified San Juan with Nicaragua proper and Miskito, and reopened the San Juan Canal to international traffic.

The Flag displays a white acorn on fimbriated green roundel over a blue-white-red-white-red-white-blue striped field; and is said to originate from Security forces wearing their red & green Vanderbilt acorn logo over the Nicaraguan flag.

* an ATL personage resembling William Walker ;)

Poll2.png
 
ENTRY 3

Federation of the Guianas
During the Great War of 1815-1821 between the different European nations,
a small contingent was sent by the Dutch in 1815 to defend the small colony of Surinam with it's small number of gold mines against possible British, Germanic, French aggression. Although the Dutch were able to stay neutral for a year, in 1815 the country itself and most of it’s great colonial possessions (in the period 1815-1817) were soon run over by the Germanic-French alliance. Most of it’s small possessions were lost to different nations, allies or foes.

Except for Surinam, who wrote it’s own chapter in this turbulent era:
Although formally the Kingdom of the Netherlands surrendered in 1816 to the Germanic and French Empires, the local colonials( enforced by the commandant of the small contigent sent in 1815, Kolonel Willem Benjamin van Panhuis) declared independance from the Kingdom, establishing the Republic of Surinam. Within weeks the newly-formed republic was recognised by most independant South- and Middle- American republics.
After defeating a small French force at Jodensavanne in the spring of 1816, the former contingent was re-established as the “Regiment Republikeinse Gardisten*”. After being strengthened by the local “Regiment Surinaamse Jagers**” and the “Koninklijke Goejana Regiment***” the Korpsgeneraal Van Panhuis (by now the commander of the army) attacked the capital of French Guiana during the autumn of 1816 and captured it after a quick battle outside Cayenne.

Fearing French retribution Van Panhuis retreated to Surinam at the end of 1816, but not after establishing a Republic of Cayenne.
In 1817 however, war broke out between the former allies, the Germanic and French Empires, diverting the attention of the French to more important war theatres. The Republic of Cayenne by then was a place of disarray (from the view of the leaders of the Republic of Surinam) as former slaves had succesfully rebelled against the leading establishment. Fearing a similar rebellion in their newly-founded republic, Van Panhuis again marched on Cayenne. This time however a small regiment of the Para Free Republic joined them at quelling the rebellion. The territory was subsequently divided between the Republic of Suriname (85% of the territory) and the Para Free Republic (15% of the territory).

Late in 1817 the British Empire joined the side of the Germanic Reich and began to voice a claim on the former French territory of Guiana. In 1818 the U.S. however recognised the Republic of Surinam, making a military campaign by the British against the Surinamese hard, if not impossible, as the none of the European nations were interested in getting the U.S. involved in their “European” wars.

In Summer 1818 there was a small incident (later known as the Coconut-incident) at the borders between British Guiana and the Republic of Surinam which would have world-wide implications.
What exactly did happen and who fired the first shot, was never to be known, but a fact was that during the incident several soldiers were killed. One of them was in fact not a British nor Suriname subject, it was Ferdinand Johnson , the son of the American consul in Surinam.
The British reluctance to take responsibility for the incident together with the huge public outcry forced the then very popular president John C. Calhoun to come with his “Calhoun Doctrine” which at the bottomline was nothing more than a dictate:
All European nations should within 2 decades offer independance to all colonies on the Western Hemisphere.

The British, who were losing already heavly on their South Asian and European war theatres were the first to cave in, declaring in 1819 that all British territories were to be granted independance by 1824. The French,Germanics, Danish , Portuguese and Italians soon followed within a year with their own declarations with their colonies granted independance from per direct (like Italian Virgin Islands) to after 20 years (like Danish Eastern Kouba).

The British colony of British Guiana would not wait 5 years though: being secretly helped by the Republic of Surinam, the U.S. and several other South American nations the local colonials declared independance in late 1819, starting a small civil war within the territory. This prompted the, by then newly-elected President of the Republic of Surinam, Van Panhuis to invade British Guiana for the reason of restoring peace to it’s neughbour nation. Although the U.S. politically disapproved the invasion, it didn’t try to stop the Suriname either, even covertly helping them out militarily and financially.

By 1820 all of former British Guiana was pacified and the Republic of Demerara declared independance from the British, although being more a puppet-state under control of the Surinamese than a truly independant nation .

It didn’t took Van Panhuis long (in his second term as president) to realize a Federation of the Guianas in 1824 (a country made of the Republics of Demerara, Suriname and the re-established Cayenne Republics).
In 1829 the Federation (or “De Federatie” as it was locally called) joined Brazil in it’s war against the Para Free State and Gran Venezuela. After the war, which Brazil won, it gained several territories from the Para Free State and Gran Venezuela, combining all the Guianan territories under one flag and nation for the first time in history.

In the 2 decades there-after, during the 3rd term of President Van Panhuis and 1st and 2nd term of Van Panhuis Jr., the Federation had a relatively prosperous and peacefull existence.
It managed to stay united untill 1897, when the Red Revolution broke out across the continent.

* translation: Regiment Republican Guards
** translation: Regiment Surinamese Rifles (actually Jaegers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jäger_(military))
*** translation: Royal Guianese Regiment

Poll3.jpg
 
ENTRY 4

Rzeczpospolita Malagaska
Here is a flag of Commonwealth of Malagas located on Madagascar Island formed by Maurice Benyovszky, first King of Madagascar.

Maurice Benyovszky adventures are widely know in present day Poland, Slovakia and Hungary. His attempts to restore Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth had never come true in OTL.

Poll4.png
 
ENTRY 5

Central Republic of Cuba

From the 1850s to the 1890s was the era known as the 'Civil War Period' where the Island of Cuba was in a constant state of civil war between multiple Cuban factions, the Spanish, British, Mexican and American armed forces at one point or another. During the First War of Independence, Narciso García lead an expedition of mercenaries to capture Cuba as a colony of the US. This didn't pan out as planned although, as they only managed to secure the provinces of Santa Clara and half of Puerto Principe. The borders of the Republic shifted and changed almost constantly up until it was annexed into the Democratic Republic of Cuba, following the Mexican Invasion, effectively ending the Civil War Period.

Interestingly this flag would become the flag of the Democratic Republic of Cuba briefly during the 1940s after the Popular Revolution, before being toppled during a military coup, which restored the old flag.*

*This is a kind of parody of OTL, where the real flag of Cuba was designed by a filibuster and then was made the official flag after independence from the Spanish.

Poll5.png
 
ENTRY 6

Republicca di Berenice

The Republic of Berenice was a small rump state created by former participants of the Unification War in Italy, who after the peace of 1846, choose to take the city of Bingizi (OTL : Benghazi) from the Turks, then in war againt Russia.

Deciding to rename the city from its roman name, their power never expanded in the countryside and the ottomans maintened an actual presence in Cyrenaica.

However, thanks to the support of Russia and England (who wanted to have a possible sure harbour in central mediterranea after the loss of Malta), the Berenici kept the control of the city, using a oligarchic system veiled by a half-utopist, half-medieval inspired system of republic.

The last Capitano as the head of state was named, Alberto Lacca finally gave the control of western Cyrenaica to the french forces in 1904 after they took all Libya. Depsite their promises, Berenice was fully integrated in the region of Cyrenaica and the republic was officialy annexed in 1919 after it lost all real and symbolic power.

The flag of the republic symbolized the Mediterranea and the Desert and between them, the Cyrenaica represented by the "ottoman" green for prosperity removing the turks' crescent.

Poll6.png
 
ENTRY 7

[FONT=&quot]The Republic of Poyais


[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]MacGregor was born in Edinburgh, Scotland on Christmas Eve 1786. His parents were Captain Daniel MacGregor and Ann Austin. In 1803, he joined the Royal Navy. He later married Marie Bowater in 1805, who died soon after. He then served in the Spanish and Portuguese armies, after which he returned to Edinburgh. By this time, MacGregor heard about the independence movements in South America and in the Captaincy General of Venezuela in particular, where he arrived in 1811 with the rank of Colonel. In 1817, MacGregor led a group of 55 men to capture San Fernandina on Amelia Island, Florida from the Spanish. Surprising the Spanish, MacGregor's men overran the island on 29 June. MacGregor raised a flag with a green cross on it. He left a few months later to fight the Spanish.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]In 1820 Gregor MacGregor, while sailing from Latin America for London, England, was found to be the only survivor from the ship that carried him. An American merchant marine vessel rescued him and brought him to Charleston, SC where he pronounced that he had been created cacique (highest authority or prince) of the Principality of Poyais, an independent nation on the Lake of Maracaibo, in what was known as Gran Colombia$. Of course, all of this was a scam, but many people of Charleston and the surrounding area believed him. Soon many were buying stocking or signing up to move to the Principality. Eventually MacGregor would make it to London and continue the scam. He would conclude this finally in Paris.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]From the 1820 to 1826 numerous British, French, and American colonists would move to the region. Interestingly, MacGregor began to hear stories of how well the colonists were doing in the Principality. It has even been conjectured by scholars that he even started to believe it himself. So, by December 1826, MacGregor was sailing back to South America to claim his rightful place as Prince of Poyais. Unfortunately, on the trip over, he eventually died from some meat that he ate was infected with Clostridium botulinum.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]Emerald mines had been a going concern in the area ever since the Spanish first conquered the territory. When the Rutledge family moved to the area they quickly bought into an emerald mine near Muso with several locals. The family found the mines under run and not many stones were collected. Bartrum Rutledge changed this when he started to import slaves from the USA to work the mines. By 1832 all thirteen of the original families from Charleston owned emerald mines. With profits increasing they were able to expand the farms and moved into gold mining. The Bush family from England became the largest producers of rice in South America, with Bush Rice still the largest producer today. The [FONT=&quot]de la Fosse[/FONT] family was quick to buy into and improve the nickel mines of the area, and eventually they would discover several diamond mines.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]By 1832 the heads of the families came to realize that the Principality of Poyais was a sham. Stilling having trouble with the Gran Colombia Government, depending upon which one was in power or thought they were, the Families and more prosperous colonists moved to establish Poyais as a Republic with no good heir to be found. The fact that many of the Families came from the USA also did not lend itself to wanting a dictatorial monarch ruling them, so they convened a Congress of the more powerful men in nation to create a Constitution.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]The Republic of Poyais would be officially established on June 13, 1840 and the nation’s new flag would be raised atop the landing site of the first colonist home.

[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]Slavery lasted until 1875 after the people (Families and Businesses) came to realize that it would be bad for profits. It actuality slavery continued, but under the disguise of slave wagery. By 1895 the original native peoples and the descendants of the Spanish in Poyais became a movement to get representation in the government. In 1911 they would finally be recognized as citizens. It would not be until 1932 that the descendants of the formers slaves would gain full citizen’s rights and privileges when the Republic, after nearly twenty years of financial depression, asked for admittance into the British Commonwealth of Nations. While the biggest motivator was getting help from the British government to bring the nation out of debt, the Republic of Poyais was being threatened by the USA after Colombia# became a state in that nation.



[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]Flag: The original (fake) flag of Poyais was a green cross (St George) on a white field. As the American, British, and French colonists came to realize that Gregor MacGregor Principality was ficticous, they also came to realize that they help most of the wealth and power within the country. Never fully admitting that Poyais was based on a lie the leaders and rich of the nation convened a Congress to create a constitution and to set up a representative government. As part of this they had created a new flag. So, since many of the colonists worked, ran, or owned the emerald mines they set a trapiche* emerald in the center of the flag. Behind the emerald is a depiction of the common black hawk holding an olive branch in one talon and a bundle of arrows in the other. The arrows represent the thirteen original families to move to Poyais. The olive branch represents peace. The top and bottom stripes are, together, 5/6 of the flag. The top Blue represents the sea and the bounty that it brings to the nation. The dark green stripe is a holdover from the original flag (at least in color), but also represents the forests, jungle, and large plantations that stretch across Poyais. The white stripe symbolizes the strength of her people, but is also taken from the original flag and is only 1/6th the height of the flag. It is also interesting to note that white can also mean to hide or misrepresent unwanted truths (see whitewash)



[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]$ Simon Bolivar was mortally wounded in 1819 during the Battle of Boyacá, dying a week after the battle.
[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]# With the USA gaining control over Colombia in order to build the canal over the Panamanian Isthmus it was only a matter of time until Colombia effectively became a state within the USA.
[/FONT] [FONT=&quot]* The name trapiche comes from a grinding wheel used to process sugarcane in Colombia. According to the most readily available information, the only known mines are Muso [Muzo], White Crags [Peñas Blancas], and Coskuze [Coscuez] which are located within a span of about 30 km (20 miles) along the Rio Carare. Trapiche emeralds are green as all emeralds are, but black carbon rays radiate out in a six pointed radial spoke pattern from a center core and colorless beryl or black carbon often surrounds the green emerald areas. The center core may be in a hexagonal shape and contain emerald (green beryl) or colorless beryl or it may not form at all.[/FONT]

Poll7.png
 
ENTRY 8

Belize And The Islands

With the beginning of the caste war in the Yucatan many refugees fled across the boarder into Belize helping to raise tensions in an already repressed society. The end of slavery a generation before had hardly changed the social order in Belize as the plantation owners still held most of the power and kept the former slave population down.

The Clayton–Bulwer treaty, finalised in 1850, specified that Britain would not increase colonisation of Central America, nor have a direct hand in governance of any territory on the mainland. This was in exchange for primacy in the construction of any trans-oceanic canal in the future.

Despite the seeming loss of control over Belize the British extended diplomatic independence to the area granting colony status under the name British Honduras. The declaration was worded to emphasise the independence of the territory and its protective status under the colonial system only.

Following the intervention of William walker in the Honduran bay islands a small independent nation was established. However it failed to gain any following on the mainland and the Mosquito Coast remained under British control. The area was open to extreme wealth, however the British authorities viewed walker's state as a mere annoyance as long as the valuable logging and potential sites for a cross ocean canal were still under their control.

With political tension at an all time high within British Honduras and revolts beginning to flare; the local elite, who still craved a return to slavery, invaded walker to lead them, seeing him as a man who shared their interests.

Walker installed himself in a similar position as that which he had held in Nicaragua, a dictatorial president. This change of affairs was unacceptable to the British, who viewed the involvement of a US citizen in their affairs a breach of trust between the US and Britain. Frenzied diplomatic activity tried to give Britain casus belli while keeping US involvement away. This gave walker time to prepare; however with hostile forces on all borders his reforms were short lived.

While attempting to pave the way to revive slavery, Belize City was retaken by British naval forces and walker was swiftly captured in the city hall. After a short incarceration, walker was executed by firing squad behind the city jail.

Walker's legacy of intervention within southern America left his posthumous reputation in the south as a visionary and defender of southern interests in trying to create a total slave state. Yet this is perhaps on of the reasons for Britain staying uninvolved in the civil war, they had seen the potential for damage done by southerners expanding south.

i'm aware this probably isn't researched enough, but i had fun writing it :D

Poll8.jpg
 
ENTRY 9

United Columbia (1798 - 1859)
When Ira Allen returned from France, with the troops, material, and financial backing, he launched a successful war against the diminished British presence in Lower Canada (due to the governments decision to pull back troops to Britain, both as protection against the fledgling French republic, and to ensure domestic stability against any republican movement in the home islands). Through the years 1795-1798, Allen’s forces pushed back the diminished British garrisons along the St. Lawrence river, rallying support amongst the French Quebecois , until finally, after the siege of Quebec, Britain singed the armistice, recognizing most of Lower Canada as the new republic of United Columbia.

Following the wars end, Allen’s forces, the Green Mountain Boys (many who followed Allen to the north after Vermont’s admission into the United States), French Quebecois and those that fled tot eh banner against the British, began the task of establishing the new government, trade, and relations with the other nations. France and the US were given preferential treatment in trading with the UC, French Quebecois gained the rights they sort after in governing the territory, and together they formed one of the youngest constitutional republics in history, with Allen being elected as the first President (until his death due to lead poisoning on the 17 of August of 1801 from shrapnel remnants inside his body, leftovers from the siege of Three Rivers, the date being posthumously being honored by establish that date as the UC´s election day).

However, after Napoleons establishment of the French Empire, and his aggressive actions against its neighbors, the UC decided to begin distancing itself from France proper, resulting in the Pact of 1802, giving Britain rights to trade, giving access to the St. Lawrence river and great lake areas, moorage along Newfoundland. Eventually, during the Napoleonic wars, the UC severed all ties with France, and then, with the US (who sided with France against Britain, to diminish their presence along both the US and New France borders (the Louisiana purchase never taking place with full US entry to the war)). This angered many French nationals and Quebecois in the nation, and with the then president, Joseph Papineau advocated joining against Britain, a group of UC patriots (who also were pro-British acted by suspending the constitution (according to article 5, line 3, stating “..if foreign powers threaten the stability of the UC [and interests], both domestic and foreign, then it is the right of the governing military body to suspend the presidency, and rule in stead, until such crisis passes..”. The group suspended the Presidency, formed a wartime council, named the Committee of National Progress, and established a isolationist policy against the other powers (although they allowed British troops to pass through their borders, under the pretense of the 1802 trade act), until 1817 (this period being known today as the “New England Wars“ in North America), when the British, Austrian and allied powers defeated Napoleonic France and the US (its defeat ironically due to the UC being in exsitence, thanks to the British having sent in more troops prior to the war, originally designed to patrol the UC-British Quebec borders and trade routes: this lead to Britain reclaiming new England as far south as the Raritan River (renamed Wellington), the Michigan peninsulas, Wisconsin and all of northern New France down to the Kansas river (the entire territory being known as “New Wales”); Austria gained the southern half of New France (Spain and the Prussian Confederation being untitled to claim), eventually expending into the Texas regions; the US were forced south (the capital of Pennsylvania being leveled by British/Austrian Troops), and severely reprimanded by the winners, having to pay heavy fines, losing many of its trade ships, etc..).

Although many French nationals and republicans of the UC hated what the Committee did during its tenure, but did understand the intent: to keep the UC independent and to stop it being reabsorbed by Britain (they even managed to gain some small territory, namely in northern Vermont), and respected that it did follow the constitution and stepped down after the peace treaty of London was signed (1817). Papineau won the re-elections, and during his second term, repaired relations with many French nationals who fled to the country after the war.

During the postwar period, the UC managed to gain in power and economical might, but began to stagnate after Britain used its new Mississippi access to reroute much of their trade route to the new British Columbia colonies, although still retained the monopoly round the eastern edges. Eventually however, over the next few years, French nationalism once again arose against the pro-British governments during this period, especially with the restoration of the Second Napoleonic Empire, until, in 1950, Louis-Joseph Papineau won on a anti-British/Germanic platform. As soon as he came to power, he and his allies in the military seized control of the Senate, and forced through the Quebec reforms, allowing the President greater power over all branches of the government, arresting any who stood against him (even those who supported him, like the Quebec Republican Party). Eventually the UC, under Louis-Josephs government, entered the war on the side of France (and aided in part by the US, who were at the time, conducting their own war against Austria for control of Louisiana, and secretly, Russia, who wanted Russian Alaska back after the British took it in 1827), breaking much of the British defense in New England, and during the war, expanding the UC´s holdings over the entirety of British Quebec, Labrador, everything north and east of the Hudson rive line, and even laying siege to Ottawa and New London. Although the UC´s forces progressed rapidly in the beginning years of the war, by 1854 their offensive had become stagnated, especially with the loss of US troops and materials (after its defeat in the battle of Meridan), and greater British/Germanic troop reinforcements in the north. The British/Germanic alliance eventually pushed the UC forces back, and in 1856, after the loss of French forces with the end of the Second Napoleonic wars (with the execution of Napoleon III), and the death of Louis-Joseph and the majority of his cabinets death on the 23rd of February 1857 during the British offensive into the capital of New Columbia (Louis-Joseph refused to evacuate the city until the last moment, dieing with the vice-president, speaker of the house and high ranking officials and generals when the Senate house was shelled by mortars).

Two days later, Warwick Harrow (the then Secretary of Trade, who was one of the longest advocates of the anti-war movement a the time) was sworn in as the last President of the UC. In late April of 1858, he signed a armistice with the British/Germanic forces, ending the war in the north. 3 weeks later, in New York, he, along with other UC prominent members, signed the peace treaty of 1858, ending the UC as a independent state, and allowing it to be reabsorbed into British Canada, first as a transition Republic (with Harrow remaining as head of state , filling out the rest of Papineau´s term for that year), until January 1st, 1859, when the Act of Union with Canada came into effect, ending United Columbia as a nation.

However, the UC left a large impact over modern Canadian history, including the recognition of a Francophile state inside Canada, which was formalized during the Act of Confederation (20th of June 1870) which created the Dominion of Canada (with the Dominion of New England & Dakota Republic a few years later), and established the Province of Quebec-Columbia, even keeping the UC´s Flag as its own (although changing the top left and bottom right star to fleur de lis) and the use of many of its articles and amendments from its constitution influencing policies by foreign nations, during and after its disbandment as a nation, such as: the abolition of slavery (1804), its 3rd amendment (1807), protecting national parks and the enviroment (by severly regulating logging and land rights), complete male suffrage (from the age of 21) regardless of class (1798), the act of free religion and tradition (1800), allowing all religion and their traditions so long as they dont go against constitutional and state law (greatly protecting the native american way of life), for a few examples.

Poll9.png
 
ENTRY 10

Flag of the Kingdom of Jacobia (1849)

An independent Stuart monarchy ruling over the Hawaiian Islands.

Poll10.png
 
Top