Flag Challenge #47: Voting Thread

Which flag shall win?

  • Entry #1

    Votes: 3 8.3%
  • Entry #2

    Votes: 1 2.8%
  • Entry #3

    Votes: 3 8.3%
  • Entry #4

    Votes: 5 13.9%
  • Entry #5

    Votes: 5 13.9%
  • Entry #6

    Votes: 6 16.7%
  • Entry #6

    Votes: 13 36.1%

  • Total voters
    36
Entry #1:

attachment.php


Following Hitler's invasion of Switzerland, the Swiss retreated even more into neutrality, and by 1947, had completely closed it's borders, expelling all diplomats and refugees. Little was heard from the small nation until 1951, when a French border patrol heard gunfire across the border. Approaching quickly and cautiously, the French saw the opening battle of the Swiss Civil War.

The Swiss Civil War pitted canton against canton in bids for supremacy, land, and defensible borders. Soon, hundreds of Swiss citizens were popping across the borders in fear for their lives, as the battles began to tear families apart.

It finally ended in 1957 with the Treaty of the Three Cantons. Geneva, Jura and Zurich had formed the League of Three Cantons in 1954, and slowly had worn down the other cantons (save Basel-Stadt, which requested and received annexation by the French for safety). The Treaty dissolved all former cantons, which were swallowed up by the Three Cantons. The capital was declared to be Bern (made into a small capital region), and the nation changed it's name in 1958 to the Federal Republic of the Three Cantons. The flag was scrapped and replaced with one that took elements from the three, and the nation opened it's borders again.

Though the civil war ended, political and economic instability kept the nation teetering for nearly two decades. In 1975, the FRTC's elections saw the rise of the Peoples Democratic Party. Though with a name akin to that of the so-called "People's Democratic" rogue states of East Asia, the party had nothing to do with Communism, looking and acting more of a fascist party. Heinrich Pelli was declared Chancellor, and very quickly began exercising authoritarian powers over the press and government. Declaring that it was foreign influences that was keeping the Three Cantons from coming into it's own, he closed the borders once more. The FRTC's military remained on high alert for citizens attempting to leave the nation. Few escaped but those that did came with horror stories of starvation, political prisons, and widespread abuse of power by the armed forces, particularly rape and murder. However, with little more than hearsay, the UN and neighboring nations could do little.

On 10 November 1991, the day after the West Berliners had begun tearing down the Wall, a flood of refugees came out of the Three Cantons. While news had been failing to get out, radio from Europe had been getting in, and the Berlin Wall events had moved one Hans Moser to move on his boss, Pelli, and kill him. Pelli had concentrated all power within a very small circle of trusted advisers, who were quickly captured and executed by now disloyal troops. Relief from all over West Europe, Australia, America and Canada came pouring in. Swiss refugees began moving back home to rebuild, and Moser was elected Chancellor. He officially banned PDP, reformed and reduced the army, and began to pull the FRTC back onto the world stage.

It's 2011 now, 20 years having now passed since The Grand Opening. The FRTC is now a stable nation with a growing tourist industry, and joined the European Council and European Monetary Group in 2002. Government's power has been reduced, and the Cantonal Franc is now symbol of rebound recovery. Bern is now a large tech-industry city, with a population of nearly 300 thousand, and the Jura Grunauto company is the fifth largest automaker in the world.
Entry #2:

attachment.php


Flag of the Greater Swiss Confederation
Entry #3:

attachment.php


I made an alternate flag for the Swiss confederacy.

Instead of the flag of Schwyz, the confederacy later adopted a flag in red and white in the format of the Grey League.

Entry #4:


attachment.php


A sort of an ATL Swiss parallel since the invisible POD is before OTL Swiss Confederacy forms...

Federal Republic of Swabia (Bundesrepublik Schwaben)

The Federal Republic of Swabia [1] has its origins in the fragmentation of the Duchy of Swabia under the later Hohenstaufens. Under German Roman Emperor Frederick II, the Shires, or Gaus, of Schwyz and Uri were granted Reichsfrei status [2]....
...the addition of Swabia to the restored Kingdom of Arles (Burgundy) under GRE Henry VII Hohenstaufen [3] caused problems with the divisive Zahringer (Badener), Kyburger, and Habsburger nobles leading to many Gaus requesting Reichsfrei status...
...the succession of the Grand Dauphin Hugo of Burgundy-Savoy [4] to the Arelat Kingdom and his failure to obtain the Imperial Crown led to war in Swabia...
...the conclusion of the Swabian War and the extinction of the Kyburger and Habsburger lineages [5] saw 3 leagues in the former Duchy of Swabia – the Swabian City League, the Raetian League, and the Swiss League. With the accession of King Otto of Arles as German Roman Emperor, the 3 leagues were allowed to become separate from Arles in exchange for certain military duties...
...the Reformation War led to the 1st Union of the 3 Leagues – sometimes called the League of Three...
..with the abolition of the Alemannic Republic, much of the former United Leagues of Swabia called for a restoration...
...following WW1 the Swabian Protectorate was united into a Federal Republic...


The Flag

The flag maintains the colours of the original League of Three (red & white for the Swiss, white & red for the Swabian City, and black & white for the Raetian) but has abandoned the plain 5-stripe of the United League, which was appropriated for the Swabian Protectorate, in favour of the Saxon triangular hoist & stripes arrangement.

The flag has a black triangular hoist reaching the centre over 5 equal stripes – red white red white red.
On the hoist is a simple Swabian cross in white.


[1] so called as it roughly covers the lands of the former Duchy of Swabia
[2] as OTL
[3] a different marriage gives Frederick an additional son who gets the Kingdom of Arles when his brother briefly becomes Emperor
[4] better marriages for the Dauphin of Vienne gains the Franche-Comte and Savoy
[5] No Habsburg Austria. Take that Rudolf!
Entry #5:

attachment.php


Republique Helvetique
(2nd Republic)

The Republic of Helvetia or Helvetia is a landlocked state in Europe, which neighbours Alsace-Lorraine Confederation , France, Italy, Austria, Lichtenstein and Germany. Helvetia is most famous for its Helvetian Army Tin-Opening Device, a wildly popular line of gadget-laden pocket knives instantly recognisable the world around as a handy and quality tool. Helvetia is most infamous for its cuisine. It seems to consist largely of mushy pickled vegetables. It is said, somewhat tongue in cheek, that Helevtian food pairs well with Alsace-Lorraine wine.

The end of the eighteenth century saw an upsurge in Helvetian national feeling, coupled with resentment towards the Austrian opressor. In 1795 the citizens of the city of Fribourg rebelled, killed the Count of Sären whose seat was at Ciuzatz da Pfäich and declared the county to be a republic. They invited Napoleon to "liberate" the rest of Helvetia, and so in 1798 Napoleon marched in almost unopposed. On the 23rd of August 1798 the Helvetian Republic was declared, the first time there had been an fully independent Helvetian state in over five centuries. Austria reacted to this seizure of her western Territory with indifference, as they were distracted by Hungary dissidents and dynastic squabbles. There were some movements in the family to regain the old family seat, but they amounted to very little.

Unfortunately the First Republic was extremely short-lived, and in 1803 a coup by disaffected nobles regained control of the country, and Karl Josif, Duke of Stantz en Silb, leader of the aristocratic party claimed first the title of Grand Duke (1804) and then "King of Helvetia" (1808).

Karl Josif and his sucessor, Zächetz IV, ruled absolutely, with no popular representation at all. This caused unrest among the rising middle classes, especially among the urban elite in the south-west, whose nobility had largely fled before Napoleon. This agitation for some measure of democracy led to the Civil War of 1845-47, which ended with the king compromising and establishing the Republic in 1848.

Since that time Helvetic Republic (except short lived Helvetic Soviet Republic period) is know to be an oasis of pace among struggle by wars European nationalist states.
Entry #6:

X33VP.png


Despite its mixture of austerity and absurdity, and its ties to religion in an almost universally secular country, the Swiss flag is in no danger of being replaced. While the Kingdom of Switzerland formally removed the last vestiges of political power from the Reformed Swiss Hussite Church in 1983, the banner which bears its symbols of chalice and goose, and the cross representing the Heavenly Father, remains popular with over 85% of the population. The "Goose and Goblet" is strongly associated with Switzerland worldwide, and is seen in the nation's sports logos, advertisements, and airlines. Political controversy at home can't even harm the people's love for their flag - despite the overwhelming unpopularity of the Swiss occupation of Singapore, the G&G is as popular as it has ever been since its 1948 redesign.
Entry #7:

kingswissblue-1.png


Kingdom of the Swiss

(Italian: Regno dei Svizzero ; German: Königreich der Schweitzer ; French: Royaume de la Suisse)

First Monarchy: 1234-1301 (Union between the Zähringer and Kyburg Houses)
- Conrad II of Zähringer-Kyburg, King of the Swiss: 1234-1278
- Berthold VI of Zähringer-Kyburg, King of the Swiss: 1278-1301

First Regency Period - Beatrice of Savoy: 1301-1303

Second Monarchy: 1303-1375 (Union with the House of Savoy)
- Amadeus V of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, King of the Swiss: 1303-1321
- Humbert IV of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, King of the Swiss: 1321-1368
- Bianca I of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, Queen of the Swiss: 1368-1375

Third Monarchy or Imperial Era: 1375-1438 (Largest expansion of the Kingdom (see map app.))
- Edward of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, Duke of Genoa-Corsica, Prince of Monaco, Duke of Milan, King of the Swiss: 1375-1411
- Eleanor, “the Golden Queen”, of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, Duchess of Genoa-Corsica, Princess of Monaco, Contessa of Pisa, Duchess of Milan, Queen of the Swiss: 1411-1446

Fourth Monarchy or Warring/Decline Period: 1447-1491 (French annexation of Monaco; The 2nd Roman Nation’s invasion of Pisa and Genoa-Corsica; Habsburg control over the Holy Roman Empire & expulsion from H.R.E; Rebellion of Milan; Political instability in the Kingdom)
- Victor Amadeus of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, Duke of Genoa-Corsica, Prince of Monaco, Conte of Pisa, Duke of Milan, King of the Swiss: 1447-1471
- Berthold VII (Philip Emmanuel) of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, Prince of Monaco, King of the Swiss: 1471-1487

Second Regency Period - Thomas III, Count of Turin: 1487-1489
- Ulrich Hartmann, Duke of Aargau: 1489-1491

Fifth Monarchy or Final Monarchy: 1491-1509 (Absorption of Genoa-Corsica and Milan to the 2nd Roman Nation; Franco-Austrian invasion of the Kingdom & Repatriation into the H.R.E; Fall of the Monarchy; Partition of the Kingdom into nations: Duchy of Savoy, The Swissland Federation, State of Baden, Free City of Geneva)
- Hubert of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg, King of the Swiss: 1491-1509

The Four Year Kingdom: 1734-1738 (Realm created by Emperor Franz-Matthias II of Habsburg-Lorraine for his son as a personal fiefdom; ended in the Revolution of 1738 and deposing of the House of Habsburg-Lorraine and creation of the Swiss Confederacy)
- Karl-Josef II of Habsburg-Lorraine, King of Swissland: 1734-1738

The Second Kingdom or 27 Year Restoration: 1871-1898 (Re-establishment of the Kingdom under the French-Italian exiled Cadet Branch of Savoy-Bourbon uniting with the Neu Zähringer-Kyburg house; Union of the Genoan city state with Geneva into the Swiss Confederecy, forming the Second Kingdom; Final end of the Monarchy and formation of the Swiss Republic, ending the last Monarchy on continental Europe with the exception of the Empire of Sweden (the other monarchies left in Europe being the United Kingdom of Britannia, Princedom of Munster and Kingdom of Sicily-Tunisia))
- Conrad IV (Louis-Amadeus II) of Savoy-Bourbon & Neu Zähringer-Kyburg, Prince of Savoy, Duke of Genoa, Co-Prince of Geneva, King of the Swiss: 1871-1898



  • Royal Flag of 1871: The Royal Flag of the Second Kingdom bears the French-Italian tri-colour of the House of Savoy-Bourbon (light blue representing its French line, red the Italian), emblossed with the ancient coat of arms of the House of Savoy & Zähringer-Kyburg (the top two quadrants showing the crests of the ancient houses, with the bottom pair showing the union between the 3 main cities of Bern, Zurich and Geneva, enlaid with a central shield of a greek cross over a red field, the standard of the House of Savoy and a Swiss National symbol), the old coat placed inside a coiled rope shield, representing the former maritime power of the Older Kingdom and the new Duchy of Genoa, over the central field of the tri-colour (white):
 
Last edited:
on follows he has to say which flag is for the comp..mu.ltiple ones arent allowed anymore...plus ya need to make this a poll
 
on follows he has to say which flag is for the comp..mu.ltiple ones arent allowed anymore...plus ya need to make this a poll

THe poll has now arrived!

And I will change the image of entry #5 to the one posted on the flag thread.

EDIT: ****! Forgot to add the end date...
 
Okay, I think this poll has ended (sorry for the inconveniences with this poll). jkarr is officially the winner with 8 votes (9 - 1 because of Benkarnell's misvote)!

I will post the official decleration in the corresponding thread.
 
Top