WI: Tom Selleck as Indiana Jones in Raiders of the Lost Ark?

[theReturner]

As some of you may know, Tom Selleck was once upon a time going to be the actor to play the now famous character of Indiana Jones in Raiders of the Lost Ark. However, he couldn't be in both Raiders and Magnum, P.I. so as we all know, the role of Indy eventually went to Harrison Ford. However, lets say that things are different, and that Selleck can be in both Raiders and Magnum, P.I.

Would Raiders still have been the hit it was, without Harrison Ford playing Indy? How would the character of Indiana Jones be different if Selleck had played him?How Selleck and Ford's careers be different? Assuming Raiders is a success, would future films have played out?

[The Vulture]

I like Selleck and think he's a good actor, I just don't think the character would be quite as appealing as it was with Ford. Ford gives off more of that everyman vibe, he made Jones a guy who made mistakes and got through things by the skin of his teeth. You could relate to that, which I feel was a lot of the appeal of the series.

Selleck. . . not so much, if Magnum PI is any indicator. Raiders would be remembered as a decent action movie that made back expenses at the box office, but it wouldn't be the iconic shared cultural experience. Hell, we probably wouldn't even have the "shooting the swordsman" scene.

[The Doctor]

Your very lucky my girlfriend is not a member of this wonderful board. She would dress up with the OFFICIAL hat and a leather jacket in high school. She would also give you all a very long reply, so much she would the whole page to herself.

[MrP]

Originally Posted by The Vulture

I like Selleck and think he's a good actor, I just don't think the character would be quite as appealing as it was with Ford. Ford gives off more of that everyman vibe, he made Jones a guy who made mistakes and got through things by the skin of his teeth. You could relate to that, which I feel was a lot of the appeal of the series.

Selleck. . . not so much, if Magnum PI is any indicator. Raiders would be remembered as a decent action movie that made back expenses at the box office, but it wouldn't be the iconic shared cultural experience. Hell, we probably wouldn't even have the "shooting the swordsman" scene.

IIRC, the shooting the swordsman scene was down to Ford coming down with a bad case of diarrhoea and not being up to the complicated choreography of a swordfight. So I agree that's certainly a butterflyable incident.

[Emperor Norton I]

Harrison Ford is more appealing: he's rugged, charming, but also has an everyman vibe to make him approachable and identifiable while likewise viewed as cool. Tom Selleck doesn't come off as rugged to me.

That said, it doesn't necessarily mean there won't be more films in the Indiana Jones franchise.

[thekingsguard]

On the upside, you can bet there would have been no Crystal Skull movie

[Geekhis Khan]

Much like the Ghostbusters movies I think the movie(s) would be remembered fondly, but probably not be considered true modern classics.

"Yea, Indiana Jones, the ones with that Magnum guy fighting the Nazis. I liked those. Whatever happened to him?"

[lounge60]

Originally Posted by theReturner

Would Raiders still have been the hit it was, without Harrison Ford playing Indy? How would the character of Indiana Jones be different if Selleck had played him?How Selleck and Ford's careers be different? Assuming Raiders is a success, would future films have played out?

Well,Tom Selleck was probably more right for the role of an 30s adventurer.
Selleck is more in line with the actors of the Hollywood golden age,like Clark Gable , Errol Flynn or Douglas Fairbanks Jr.
So i think that was a more classic Indiana Jones.
Harrison Ford is not truly in line with 30s.

Assuming a blockbuster like in OTL,i think that Selleck would become a very big name.

[David S Poepoe]

Originally Posted by lounge60

Well,Tom Selleck was probably more right for the role of an 30s adventurer.

Anybody remember Selleck in 'High Road to China' which is set in the 19202-30s? I barely do. I would wonder if Selleck as Jones would usher in a new age of the moustache - more so than Magnum.

[MrP]

Originally Posted by David S Poepoe

Anybody remember Selleck in 'High Road to China' which is set in the 19202-30s? I barely do. I would wonder if Selleck as Jones would usher in a new age of the moustache - more so than Magnum.

There is something unnaturally alluring about Selleck's moustache. Or perhaps I'm just possessed by the spirit of Monica Geller.

[trekchu]

Curses upon all of you! I now want to do an Indiana Jones Marathon!

[lounge60]

Originally Posted by David S Poepoe

Anybody remember Selleck in 'High Road to China' which is set in the 19202-30s? I barely do. I would wonder if Selleck as Jones would usher in a new age of the moustache - more so than Magnum.

1936.
Professor Henry Walton "Indiana" Jones Jr.

[lounge60]

[cumbria]

Originally Posted by MrP

IIRC, the shooting the swordsman scene was down to Ford coming down with a bad case of diarrhoea and not being up to the complicated choreography of a swordfight. So I agree that's certainly a butterflyable incident.

I saw when he said that.
Great stuff.
Best part of the film.

[cumbria]

To be honest an Englishman should have played the role.

[theReturner]

Originally Posted by cumbria

To be honest an Englishman should have played the role.

Why an Englishman? And which Englishman?

[Emperor Norton I]

Originally Posted by theReturner

Why an Englishman? And which Englishman?

Alec Guinness?

[cumbria]

Originally Posted by theReturner

Why an Englishman? And which Englishman?

An Englishman would fit with the Colonial adventurer role more than an American.
As for choices im not sure.
Oliver Reed may have been good as long as he sported the English playboy tash.

[theReturner]

Originally Posted by cumbria

An Englishman would fit with the Colonial adventurer role more than an American.

I don't know about that. What about Teddy Roosevelt?

[LordVetinari]

Originally Posted by cumbria

An Englishman would fit with the Colonial adventurer role more than an American.
As for choices im not sure.
Oliver Reed may have been good as long as he sported the English playboy tash.

I'm not sure. It is Indiana Jones, not Essex Jones, Manchester Jones, or Cockney Jones.