Peace In Our Time: Collaborative Timeline

First Post
This is an idea I've had rolling around my head since I've joined AH.com, but I've never had the time to research for it, and now I don't even have the time to make it without research. So, I figured I'd present the idea as a collaborative timeline, and see what AH.com would think would happen. As I am very short on time, I might need someone else to help with this, mainly enforcing the few rules and also consolidating dates into one post every few pages. The TL will run from January 1st, 1920 to December 31st, 2010. Now, for the ground rules:

1. You cannot post any date past 1927 until the dates beforehand have been satisfactorily filled.
2. No assassinations or random killings of politicians unless you can get two other posters to support you, and even then it might get revoked if I see that every other post is just killing another politician.
3. Not much of a rule, more of a trend-setter: Most of the first few sets of dates will only be small changes in the USA, Germany, and Russia, and only until about the 30s will the butterflies have snowballed enough for us to start making huge political changes.

Now, without further ado, here are the four PODs that will kick off the Collaborative Timeline:

August 26th, 1921: Franklin D. Roosevelt dies after spending nearly a month with deteriorating health from catching some sort of illness during his trip to Canada.

December 10th, 1921: Shortly after receiving the Nobel Prize for Physics in recognition of his explanation of the photo-electric effect, Albert Einstein is killed in a chance car accident in Sweden, much to the dismay of many.

November 11th, 1922: Vladimir Lenin reads his testament aloud before the Soviet Party. It has been slightly altered, after a few visits from both Stalin and Trotsky, and the Testament now criticized Stalin greatly, suggested that he be replaced as General Secretary, and it even went so far as to suggest that Trotsky take his place. After the reading of the testament, Stalin leaves the building to think, and is assassinated once outside by an OGPU agent, who escapes.

November 9th, 1923:
The Beer Hall Putsch ends as the police show up. There is a misfire, resulting in the unfortunate death of one young Adolf Hitler.
 
Last edited:
August 2nd, 1923: Warren G. Harding suffers a heartattack. Despite the scare, docters are able to save his life, and he recovers quickly.

November 4th, 1924: President Harding is reelected in a landslide over Democratic candidate Al Smith of New York.

January 24th, 1925: Chicago's north side crime boss Hymie Weiss and Bugs Moran attempt to assassinate rival Johnny Torrio outside his home. Torrio is tiped off however, and is waiting for them. Weiss and Moran are both killed in a hail of gunfire, throwing the North Side into chaos.
 
January 21, 1924: Lenin dies; Kamenev takes over his post on the Council of Labour and Defense, but Trotsky's ally Preobrazhensky takes over Sovnarkom instead of Rykov (Lenin's deputy in Sovnarkom).

May 4, 1924: Igor Sikorsky crashes his S-29-A on its maiden flight; though he is uninjured, his company folds.

March 4, 1925: Trotsky resigns from the position of General Secretary, unable to cope with the workload; he cites a desire to refocus attention on reforming and modernizing the Red Army, and proposes that his protege Georgy Pyatakov, deputy chair of Gosplan, take over the post of General Secretary.
 
May 11th, 1925: The doctor informs Mr. Nixon that his son, Arthur, only has the cold and should recover within the week.

May 18th, 1925: Arthur Nixon is once again fully healthy.

August 19th, 1925: Arthur Nixon is still completely fine.

January 11th, 1926: Hannah Milhous Nixon discovers that she is once again pregnant with a child.
 
Last edited:
February 13, 1926, Trosky tells his former deputy, Pyadokov, that he wishes to remain as defence commissar, and suggests his new boss to propose to the Politburo a law granting the wish of any Politburo member to retire if their health or any other crisis arises where they might be neded.
 
The General Secretary isn't the boss; he's chief administrator, essentially in charge of the bureaucracy. He has no direct control over policy.

February 18, 1925: Bukharin's Right Opposition and Kamenev's Center Movement successfully oust Preobrazhensky from Sovnarkom; Zinoviev, Kamenev's most loyal ally, replaces him.

April 17, 1925: Sikorsky is hired by Grover Loening, director of the Loening Aeronautical Engineering corporation, joining Leroy Grumman.

April 28, 1927: Li Dazhao, co-founder of the Communist Party of China, escapes the KMT purge of Communists, surviving only with the support of Soviet agents.
 
Last edited:
June 1 1928: Following the disastrous election results, the new DNVP chairman Alfred Hugenberg takes a new radical volkish course in the DNVP special conference in Stettin.

July 19 1928
: In the Wiesbaden Conference Hugenbergs DVNP merges with General Ludendorffs Voelkisch-Nationale Block (NVP) and Josef Goebbles National Sozialistische Partei Deutschlands (NSPD).
They form the Nationale Volksblock (NVB)

November 20 1928
: Alfred Hugenberg is assasinated by an anarchist of jewish origin ...
 
A minor quip: I don't think the Nazis will stick together. The POD gets rid of Mein Kamph (sp?) and the leader who made them a formidable political force. My bet is on them fracturing and getting picked up by various other parties.
 
January 4, 1929: Paul Von Hindenberg considers running for the Presidency of Germany in the up-coming election, but is talked out of it due to his age, even though he gets backing from several high-ranking army figures.
 
A minor quip: I don't think the Nazis will stick together. The POD gets rid of Mein Kamph (sp?) and the leader who made them a formidable political force. My bet is on them fracturing and getting picked up by various other parties.

Goebbles was a good enough orator, I think that with him not abadoning his original socialis ideology he could make himself a nice niche party in Northern Germany.
 
Goebbles was a good enough orator, I think that with him not abandoning his original socialist ideology he could make himself a nice niche party in Northern Germany.
Oh, alright. Carry on, then. :)
Who do you think would run in the 1932 election?
 
January 17, 1928: Huey Long wins re-election as governor of Louisiana, winning 45% of the vote - well more than the 27% won by each of the anti-Long candidates.

June 28, 1928: Henry T. Rainey, former Speaker of the House (D-IL), and Senator Alben W. Barkley (D-TN), are nominated as presidential and vice-presidential candidates by the DNC; Al Smith, expecting that the GOP would win in '28 and not wanting to be beaten again, had not seriously campaigned, while Cordell Hull found himself outmaneuvered.

July 28, 1928: The Games of the IX Olympiad open in Los Angeles, California. The US, host of the Games, wins 61 medals in total, including 24 gold medals.

November 6, 1928: Republicans Herbert Hoover and William Borah defeat Rainey and Barkley, winning 55% of the popular vote and 367 electoral votes to the Rainey-Barkley ticket's 43% and 166 electoral votes.

December 5, 1929: Leroy Grumman, Igor Sikorsky, and four other former Loening employees, unwilling to move to Pennsylvania (home of the Keystone Aircraft Corporation that bought Loening in '28), found the Sikorsky-Grumman Aircraft Engineering Corporation on Long Island.
 
Last edited:
We still could - I've made no references to what happened to Harding or Coolidge during the '20s. All we know is that Harding was re-elected in a landslide over Al Smith in '24, and that it seemed likely that the GOP would win (as they did) in '28. There's no reason people can't post more events from the mid-'20s, is there? I'm not sure what to do with Harding, though.

I'd like to see more societal changes.

I also think that we should aim for the title to be accurate - i.e., that there be no big wars, especially in Europe, in the '30s and '40s.

How fast should a thread like this move, anyways?
 
Events are actually still restricted to 1920 - 1927. And I'm not sure what to do with Harding either. I would also like to see more societal changes, I think starting with Germany and Russia would be a good start, but I wonder what the effects of Science and America would also be as a result of the other two deaths.

As for the title, yes, that's why I put it. When I first conceived these PODs it was part of an overall idea for preventing WWII and the Cold War. As for how fast the thread should move, it depends on how many people are contributing. At this rate, we'll be moving into the 30s in December. But if more people start contributing, we could be jumping into the 30s by tomorrow, if there's enough of a boom.

And don't be afraid of killing people completely. If you want to kill a politician just post something like "Petition to kill X as a child. Signed, Y." And then if two other people add their names you can go ahead and kill the person.

Dates Open:
1920-1927
Tiers to be Opened Later:
1927-1933
1934-1939
1940-1945
etc
 
November 9, 1926-A car bomb goes off in Houston, Texas, killing over 100 people. William Hearst uses this as an opprotunity to create one of the first real 'Red Scares'{if we consider what happened in 1920 OTL as just a fluke or something}
 
Some thoughts on Soviet politics -
I personally think that Kamenev and Zinoviev will end up in the dominant position by the late '20s - they've got the tremendous advantage of starting out in the center, which lets them align with the Right or Left as needed. It worked for Stalin in OTL, after all... On the other hand, I think that both Trotsky's faction and Bukharin's faction will still have influence. Trotsky himself might be 'encouraged' to retire, though, especially if he ends up moving too aggressively.
Kirov will probably become a significant factor by the late-'30s, if not earlier.
***
Some events for the '20s:
January 22, 1923: The Toll of the Sea, the first all-color Hollywood film, is released, two months after the original print was damaged. It sees rave reviews, particularly for star Anna May Wong.

March 21, 1924: Anna May Wong Productions is founded by the popular film star and the investor Sid Grauman, just three days after Wong's second success, The Thief of Baghdad, was released. The company plans to raise money for films centered on Chinese myths and starring the popular actress.

December 9, 1925: Mulan, Maid of China, the first film by Anna May Wong Productions, is released, and proves wildly successful.

December 21, 1926: French ace René Fonck wins the Orteig Prize, flying a Keystone K-47A Pathfinder biplane from Roosevelt Airfield in New York to Paris Le Bourget, accompanied by navigator Charles Clavier.
***
Petition to kill José López Rega as a child. Signed: anon_user
 
Last edited:
Like I've said, GenSec doesn't equal control over policy; it equals control over appointments. It's an administrative post. Stalin used it to gain control of the bureaucracy, but Trotsky won't have the same power; not only do I think he wouldn't have been as dedicated to the task as Stalin, I think he would've run into problems with people regarding his personnel choices as portents of a coup. Stalin benefited greatly from being perceived as the 'grey blur;' Trotsky, even if he's recommended by Lenin, would be regarded with much more suspicion. Everyone knew the example of Napoleon taking over France with a coup; the perception of Trotsky as a potential 'Red Napoleon' was there.

One issue I have is that, before Stalin consolidated his power in the '30s, there was something of a tradition of never going against the Party - that is, members of the CPSU were never purged, only expelled from the Party if necessary. He didn't kill off the triumvirates in the '20s in OTL; I don't see anyone doing that here, either. Party membership made you safe in those days. On the other hand, that doesn't mean a rogue NKVD (or, to be more accurate for 1922, OGPU) agent couldn't have taken a shot at Stalin. Still, I'd be tempted to retcon it as a different death - maybe a train derailing, or a car crash, or a random assassin.

I think that collectivization and the Five Year Plans still occur under pretty much every part of the Soviet leadership. Bukharin might be an exception, but I suspect he'd just slow the pace of collectivization and planned industrialization, though he'd keep NEP running longer. The purges within the Party, though, are the product of the Stalinist system.

I think it might be useful to look at Brezhnev's era as a possible model for Soviet politics - and especially for Soviet society - without a Stalin or equivalent.

Link of tangential interest: Operation Trust, an impressive success for the OGPU
 
Last edited:
May 19 1923: Vladimir Lenin orders the arrest of one Joseph Stalin. Stalin is send to Siberia
June 27 1926: Heinrich Himmler is kill went he is hit with a car as he walks acroos the street.
 
Top