This is my second timeline for AH.com, it deals with a different reign of Richard II.
The POD is Richard executing Henry Bolingbroke (OTL Henry IV) in a fit of rage after ‘discovering’ a conspiracy against him
John of Gaunt raises an army to punish Richard and replace him with Gaunt’s Grandson
The style will be a bit different then my last timeline, with a basic timeline format to begin with, with ‘citations’ to sources from the ATL with more details, hoping it will be an interesting timeline and way of setting it out. As always please comment for style or pointing out complete ASBishness.
· The Lords Appellant take power from Richard II in the battle of Radcot Bridge, many of Richards allies and friends are exiled or killed - 1387-88 [1]
· Merciless Parliament under the control of the Lords Appellant.
· Richard begins to regain power early 1389 - John of Gaunt hailed saviour of the King [2]
· Starts distancing himself from Lords Appellant - peace negotiations with France, reducing Taxation...
· 1389 - 1397 Peaceful years
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
The POD is Richard executing Henry Bolingbroke (OTL Henry IV) in a fit of rage after ‘discovering’ a conspiracy against him
John of Gaunt raises an army to punish Richard and replace him with Gaunt’s Grandson
The style will be a bit different then my last timeline, with a basic timeline format to begin with, with ‘citations’ to sources from the ATL with more details, hoping it will be an interesting timeline and way of setting it out. As always please comment for style or pointing out complete ASBishness.
· The Lords Appellant take power from Richard II in the battle of Radcot Bridge, many of Richards allies and friends are exiled or killed - 1387-88 [1]
· Merciless Parliament under the control of the Lords Appellant.
· Richard begins to regain power early 1389 - John of Gaunt hailed saviour of the King [2]
· Starts distancing himself from Lords Appellant - peace negotiations with France, reducing Taxation...
· 1389 - 1397 Peaceful years
o Successful expedition to Ireland
o Begins to build own power base again in Cheshire
· 1397 - 1400 - Richards 'Tyranny' o Begins to build own power base again in Cheshire
o Execution of Gloucester (out of Sight) and Arundel
o 'Conspiracy' against Richard - fingers pointed at Lancaster dynasty, esp. Henry Bolingbroke
o Bolingbroke on trial, Gaunt pleads with King
o Tyrant Richard executes Bolingbroke September 1397 [3]
o Gaunt raises supporters
· Major Clashes between Gaunt and 'Duketti' (Richards Supporters) - 1398o 'Conspiracy' against Richard - fingers pointed at Lancaster dynasty, esp. Henry Bolingbroke
· Bolingbroke's son Henry moved to Ireland in care of Richard
o Thomas de Mobray, exiled and stripped of titles as Richard moves against opponents
o Bolingbroke on trial, Gaunt pleads with King
o Tyrant Richard executes Bolingbroke September 1397 [3]
o Gaunt raises supporters
o 1398 [4]
· French Support begins to arrive - in return for guarantee of the 28 year truce in treatise. [5]· March -Battle of Rutland - Gaunt takes on Edward of Norwich - decisive victory for Gaunt
· May -Battle of Marlow - Gaunt attempts to recover his grandson (Henry) from the Montacute's who had been entrusted with his care during the peaceful years.
· Gaunt takes Oxford which holds out for the campaigning season, forcing him to wait for the next year.
· May -Battle of Marlow - Gaunt attempts to recover his grandson (Henry) from the Montacute's who had been entrusted with his care during the peaceful years.
- Victory for Gaunt, but Henry moved before they could rescue the child
· July - Battle of Curbridge (Oxfordshire) - Thomas le Despenser, Earl of Gloucester and Gaunt battle - Gaunt Victory
· Gaunt takes Oxford which holds out for the campaigning season, forcing him to wait for the next year.
o 1399
· Gaunt dies of natural causes in June 1399 in the Tower· Feb - Battle of Woodstock (Oxfordshire) - King Richard v Gaunt - Gaunt began to move on London but after French support pushes tide of battle against Gaunt, Battle fought to draw but Gaunt loses on fact he does not get to take Richard and London
· May - Battle of Malkins Bank - Gaunt in retreat towards Lancaster to raise more forces is caught, his army was decisively beaten, Gaunt is captured
· May - Battle of Malkins Bank - Gaunt in retreat towards Lancaster to raise more forces is caught, his army was decisively beaten, Gaunt is captured
1.
Rule by Appellant Degree said:This was a troubled time for Richard, while the memories of the Peasants revolt were still in his mind, his opponents had begun to move against him. Gloucester and Arundel were the main perpetrators of this movements but they were able to outmanoeuvre the King. When the Kings supporters approached Radcot Bridge, they were routed and the kings supporters had to flee the country
Rule by Appellant Degree said:The Lords Appellant were able to take control of the king and through him manage most of the Country.
Gloucester and Arundel were joined by Henry Bolingbroke, Earl of Derby, and Thomas de Mowbray, Earl of Nottingham. They all managed to break up Richards support base, isolating him and force him to do their bidding.
But the lords were not universally popular, but Richard was defeated and for the moment Friendless.
2.
Rule by Appellant Degree said:Richard gradually re-established poor royal authority in the months after the Merciless Parliament, thanks to several factors. First, the Lords Appellant's aggressive foreign policy failed when their efforts to build a wide, anti-French coalition came to nothing, and the north of England fell victim to a Scottish incursion. Secondly, Richard was now over twenty-one years old, and could with confidence claim the right to govern in his own name. Lastly, in 1389 John of Gaunt returned to England, and once the differences with the king had been settled, the old statesman acted as a moderating influence on English politics. Richard assumed full control of government on 3 May 1389, claiming that the difficulties of the past years were due solely to bad councillors. He outlined a policy contrasting with that of the appellants, seeking peace and reconciliation with France, and promised this would significantly lessen the burden of taxation on the people. He ruled peacefully for the next eight years, having reconciled with his former adversaries.
Still, later events would show that he had not put behind him the indignities suffered during the preceding years. In particular the execution of his former teacher Sir Simon de Burley was an insult not easily forgotten.
For his new allies that managed to overturn the Lords Appellant there were rewards of titles and land for their support and many became very loyal to the tall and handsome king.
3.
The Tyranny and Rebellion said:Finally the accusations of conspiracy landed on Bolingbroke, immortalised in the play Richard II, he was not, as portrayed, a devious plotter working against the king, but as the cruel victim of political manoeuvrings by the king. Richard saw Bolingbroke as a threat, his involvements in the Lords Appellant were clear, but there is no current evidence of an actual conspiracy to the throne.
But Richard was not to be swayed and in the court he denounced Bolingbroke as a traitor and a conspirator, citing fictitious evidence of a plot to sink his royal ship on the kings planned trip to Ireland.
Richard by this point had 'done away' with Thomas of Woodstock, Duke of Gloucester, another former Appellant.
With de Mobray exiled, shown leniency for his 'part in the conspiracy' because of his accusations against Bolingbroke.
Richard thought he had finally subdued his opposition to the throne, ruling in his own right, he had his enemies right where he wanted them. But he did not count on one thing, John of Gaunt. Gaunt was Bolingbroke's father and viewed Richard with much distrust. Gaunt knew Richard could not let Bolingbroke go, so suggested exile to France. Richard refused, spoiling for blood (some modern Histio-Psychologists suggest this was a bout of some of his personality disorders) and declared Bolingbroke a traitor an sentenced him to execution.
Gaunt was enraged and threatened the King. His own nephew was about to execute his son and threatened not only his familial lines but his duchies hegemony in the nobility of the Plantagenet kingdom.
When the executioners sword fell in September 1397, Gaunt was already raising his army in Lancastrian lands.
4.
The Plantagenet Civil War said:Gaunt had raised his army in his Lancastrian homelands and fielded a formidable army. His son, the recently executed Henry Bolingbroke, had used many of his Lancastrian militia in his crusade with the Teutonic Knights in his attempts to eradicate the Pagans of Vilnius. This gave him an advantage to compare to the Kings army, who had not performed well under Gaunt in battle in France, and failed to find the enemy in a punitive mission to Scotland under the Lords Appellant.
Richard had not been complacent in his time as king and had built up Cheshire as a power base. As Richards main general John Holland mustered in Cheshire, Gaunt had already moved.
Bypassing Cheshire, Gaunt moved south, encountering Edward of Norwich on his march on London. The battle occurred mid March 1398, in an as yet undiscovered field in northern Rutland. The Battle of Rutland demonstrated that Gaunt's men were a considerable force, nearing 7,000, including many that had fought for the Appellants under Bolingbroke at the battle of Radcot Bridge. Current historical thinking puts the battle at either what is now the Cricket Fields of Oakham, or in the grounds of the Tolethorpe Hall.
The battle was short but bloody, with heavy losses on the Loyalist side, Norwich was forced to withdraw, and regroup. Gaunt moved further south. But this was not the end of the line for Norwich, after regrouping, he was faced with the task of intercepting the forces of the Percys. Henry Percy, first Earl of Northumberland and his son, Henry 'Hotspur' Percy, had fallen out of favour with the King, with his preferential treatment to the Nevilles, their bitter rivals. The Percys forces were of a much lower calibre then those of the Duke of Lancaster. Norwich had fresher men, and in a repeat of the ancient events of the Norman conquests, the long march from the north had tired out the troops when they met in the Battle of Whitwick, on the 29th September, this battle had the effect of stopping Percy influence in the war and removing much of the support Gaunt had outside of his own retinue.
The next major engagement fell to the 3rd Earl of Salisbury, John Montacute. The Montacute's had been entrusted with Bolingbroke's son Henry whilst his campaigning in Vilnius, but they were also staunch supporters of Richard and had been one of his most trusted advisors. When it was clear Gaunt would move against him, Richard had moved Henry back into their care from Ireland where Richard had taken Henry on an expedition. Gaunt wished to secure the young teenager as a potential heir, or replacement to Richard. Thus Gaunt moved on the Montacute's residence at Bisham manor where the boy was being kept. Montacute knowing that Gaunt with an heir would be more powerful and have more support compared to the currently heirless Richard.
Montacute made plans to remove Henry from Bisham, and move him to more secure locations in London or France. But he needed time to prepare and move him. Gaunt needed to be delayed.
Battle was joined in Marlow, Buckinghamshire on the 10th May, across the Thames from the Abbey. Popularised in the works of the Poet John Massey;
'for wonder of his hwe men hade, he ferde as freke were fade, and oueral darke horowe'
'Great wonder of the knight, full fierce was he to sight, and all over dark filth'
The famous passage from the epic of the Millers son, Massey portrayed the Duke as a knight, seen from the eyes of a mustered millers boy, formed to delay Gaunt on the 'dark filth' of the fields of Marlow .
The Battle itself was a harrowing affair, as Montacute dug in. Forcing Gaunt to come through him made the battle extra bloody as the wet field made manoeuvring difficult.
Gaunt eventually won the battle, but it was a difficult and drawn affair, and ultimately pointless. The Battle allowed Montacute to move Henry out of Gaunt's reach, and caused great anger to the duke. Seen in hindsight, even though it was a defeat for the Loyalists in terms of on the battle field, it denied Gaunt much support for his cause with the denial of a clear heir. Gaunt is reported to have said 'In the sweeping of victory in battle, I have lost the basis for my Victory in this great endeavour.'
Gaunt now swung west, wanting to defeat the Kings great ally Thomas le Despenser , before beginning his assault on London, Gaunt picked his spot carefully as the Earl of Gloucester had considerable forces, choosing a road just outside the village of Curbridge in Oxfordshire, on the path between his enemies, dividing them.
The forces met on the 8th of June, the battle was hard fought, but in the end Gaunt won, and the road was clear to London.[if you with to know more about the battle of Curbridge and the other battles of the Civil War, see Authors works including 'Curbridge or Marlow, which saved Richards hide?' And 'Battles of the Plantagenet Civil War', also see 'The Uncle and the King, the tale of 1398' by John Templeman, and 'The Tyranny and Rebellion, a study of Richard II Reign 1395-1400' by Ken Forester ]
5.
Turning the Tide said:John of Gaunt now had defeated most of Richards main allies in the south, but the campaign had exhausted the men. Rather then risk an assault on London, Gaunt wanted to strike a blow and establish a southern base of operations for the next year. Oxford became his next target, controlled by the aging Earl of Oxford, Aubrey de Vere, Gaunt laid siege.
Oxford though did not want to go without a fight, and managed to resist the invaders until September. Gaunt realised that his position could become unstuck if he moved at this stage of the season, so he awaited news of his Percy allies from the north and their progress moving south. This delay has been cited as one of the reasons for the defeat of the Lancastrian Army, but any attempt to attack London after the battle of Curbridge would have undoubtedly resulted in defeat.
When news reached Gaunt of the Defeat of his allies at the hands of the Earl of Norwich, Gaunt knew that he would need to move on Richard in London as soon as the campaign season started the next year, it would be a do or die attack.
Richard for his part wasn't idle in his capital whilst his generals men fought and died in his name in the country, feverishly working in France he managed to use his connections with the slightly less anti-English Burgundian faction in the French court. This faction wanted a written treatise on the 28 year truce that Richard managed to secure with his betrothal to the princess Isabelle de Valois a few years previous. Richard agreed to the terms, in return for men and arms to crush the Gaunt rebellion, England would sign a treaty to protect the tenuous peace between the nations.
In secret though, Richard agreed to support Burgundy in their feud with the Duke of Orleans faction within the French court of the 'Mad King'. This would have repercussions later in Richards reign.
As 1399 rolled around Richard had secured the support and was raising his main army in London, spurred on by the French reinforcements and a renewed sense of hope after the delay at Oxford.
Gaunt left Oxford with a token garrison in February, hoping to catch Richard unready for the early start in the unseasonably warm late Winter of 1399. Gaunt had received some extra men from Lancashire, and some of the remnants of the Percy force that had managed to get south over the Winter. Richard managed to ready his men though, and moved to meet him in the Oxfordshire countryside.
Gaunt had to move north to avoid the castle at Wallingford, and to try and circumvent some of Richards forces who were closing in, but it failed as Richard simply cut them off before they could manoeuvre around them.
The battle was joined near Woodstock, Oxfordshire, this was poignant as it was the birthplace of Edward, 'the Black Prince', father to Richard and brother to Gaunt. The battle was the largest to be fought in England for generations, as both sides clashed, both Richard and Gaunt personally led their sides to the battle.
The battle was fierce, and bloody, Gaunt's centre was decimated and crumbled, whilst his cavalry succumbed to the French Allies Richard had brought. Longbowmen featured less then many other battles as Gaunt had left many in Oxford to protect it, whilst Richard had a reduced force due to a fire at the Royal Armoury containing most of the Longbows stored for the coming campaign. So it was that crossbows played the biggest part in any battle that they had on English soil and the French Archers, and French trained Englishmen did reasonable damage to the Cavalry, being more of a quirk of history rather then a decider in the battle.
In the end the battle was almost a draw, with both sides with mounting casualties. By the end of the day, the feast of St Oswald (the 28th of February) both sides pulled back. Even though the battle wasn't a defeat for Gaunt, the opportunity to take Richard and London, and therefore the Crown, was gone.
The morning after Gaunt learnt that a force under a renewed Le Despenser managed to take Oxford from Gaunt's meagre garrison. Faced with destruction in all other directions, Gaunt was left with no choice but a long march back to Lancaster.
But even that was soon unavailable as John Holland, constable of Cheshire had raised a force and moved to block Gaunts route back to his home county, in the Battle of Malkins Bank, Gaunt's beleaguered and battered army was finally fully defeated in what was the end of the Plantagenet Civil War. Gaunt was captured and spent the rest of his time in the Tower, dying later that year in his sleep from natural causes.
With the death of Gaunt and the main threats to Richard gone, the Plantagenet Civil war was over, actual casualty numbers vary wildly, from a low 8,000 estimate, to 30,000, which is calculated including several outbreaks of dysentery on the passing armies of the time.
The Civil war is a tale of What if's: What if the Percy's hadn't been defeated by Norwich?, what if Oxford had been taken quicker?, what if Gaunt had 'rescued' Henry from the Montacutes?