Soviet Beatles?

How could things come about so that a band similar to the Beatles could emerge in the USSR at about the same time and enjoy the similar huge popularity both there and overseas, becoming international icons? Are there any real Soviet musicians who could qualify for this? Discuss.
 
At the beginning, maybe, but if they grow too much the hair, or start singing too much about "love" they will see Lubyanka and/or Siberia too much for their health ...
 
IIRC there was a soviet elvis- though he was an American who just happened to get freakishly popular there and...moved there.
 
Well, If band like Czerwone Gitary could emerge and grow big in communist Poland during 60s, I can imagine similar possibility in Soviet Union - though SU was probably much more distrustful towards 'decadent western music'.
 
They can sing about the five year plans!

Well the Ukraine girls really knock me out
They leave the west behind
And Moscow girls make me sing and shout
They Georgia's always on my mind

Cheers,
Nigel.
 
Here's the track listing for the Soviet Beatles hit 1963 Album...

Please Please The Central Committee
I Saw Her Standing There (And Reported Her for Suspicious Behaviour)
Misery (Of Life Under The Iniquitous Capitalists of America)
Anna (Submit To The Supreme Authority Of Our Benevolent Leaders)
Chains (Of Capitalist Repression)
Comrades
Don’t Ask Anyone Why
Please Please The Central Committee
Love Me Do (Almost As Much As Our Great Leaders Love You)
P.S. I Love You (But Not As Much As I Love Our Workers Paradise)
Baby It’s You (I Want To Work With To Ensure The Continued Success Of Our Great Workers Paradise)
Do You Want To Know A Secret (There Are No Secrets In Our Socialist Republic)
There’s A Place (For Us Both On A Collective Farm)
Dance In An Orderly And Quiet Manner
 
Last edited:

Hendryk

Banned
There would have been no room in the Soviet conception of popular music for an act remotely like the Beatles. There was folk music on the one hand, and classical music on the other, but as late as the 1980s electric guitars were still considered suspect behind the iron curtain.
 

MacCaulay

Banned
There would have been no room in the Soviet conception of popular music for an act remotely like the Beatles. There was folk music on the one hand, and classical music on the other, but as late as the 1980s electric guitars were still considered suspect behind the iron curtain.

AW...come on. Billy Bragg seemed to be cool with them. I've got that EP on my shelf. :D
 
It's amusing listening to early Soviet pop/rock, what with their singers betraying obvious signs of classical training.

However, once it got going in the late 70s, it actually produced a bunch of rather good stuff.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Robeson
Here is one candidate. Still, what we need is a different attitude towards the Soviets after WWII. One plausible variant is Roosevelt staying alive and prompting a more peaceful post-war world with increased cultural exchange.
Another musician that could be popular worldwide in this scenario would be Yuri Antonov and his "Singing Guitars" - a band which enjoyed Beatles-scale popularity in OTL Soviet Union.
 
There would have been no room in the Soviet conception of popular music for an act remotely like the Beatles. There was folk music on the one hand, and classical music on the other, but as late as the 1980s electric guitars were still considered suspect behind the iron curtain.

Yes and no. The USSR would ever so often trot out Jazz or "Rock" combos to show Americans that Soviets were "just like us". These were officially sanctioned bands - probably actually paid by the State - that played and sang wholesome, folk-idiom rock music that could not possibly offend anyone. Think 3rd tier "Christian Rock" without the committment.
 
There would have been no room in the Soviet conception of popular music for an act remotely like the Beatles. There was folk music on the one hand, and classical music on the other, but as late as the 1980s electric guitars were still considered suspect behind the iron curtain.

Didn't stop people from gobbling it up anyway, especially in the satellite states.
 

Penelope

Banned
Here's the track listing for the Soviet Beatles hit 1963 Album...

Please Please The Central Committee
I Saw Her Standing There (And Reported Her for Suspicious Behaviour)
Misery (Of Life Under The Iniquitous Capitalists of America)
Anna (Submit To The Supreme Authority Of Our Benevolent Leaders)
Chains (Of Capitalist Repression)
Comrades
Don’t Ask Anyone Why
Please Please The Central Committee
Love Me Do Almost As Much As Our Great Leaders Love You
P.S. I Love You (But Not As Much As I Love Our Workers Paradise)
Baby It’s You (I Want To Work With To Ensure The Continued Success Of Our Great Workers Paradise)
Do You Want To Know A Secret (There Are No Secrets In Our Socialist Republic)
There’s A Place (For Us Both On A Collective Farm)
Dance In An Orderly And Quiet Manner

Commissar Pepper's Lonely Hearts Socialist Republic :D
 
Commissar Pepper's Lonely Hearts Socialist Republic :D

1. Commissar Pepper's Lonely Hearts Socialist Republic/With a Little Help From My Comrades
2. Lucy in the Sky With Red Stars
3. Getting Better (For the Workers)
4. Fixing a Hole (In a T-54)
5. She's Leaving Home (To Fight for the Motherland)
6. Being for the Benefit of the Glorious Worker's Republic
7. Within You Without You (For the Glorious Revolution)
8. When I'm Sixty Four (I Shall Still Fight on for Socialist Republic)
9. Lovely Rita (KGB)
10. Good Morning Good Morning (It is Time Beat the Capitalist Pigs)
11. Commissar Pepper's Lonely Hearts Socialist Republic (Reprise)
12. A Day in the Life (Of the Great Premier)
 
How could things come about so that a band similar to the Beatles could emerge in the USSR at about the same time and enjoy the similar huge popularity both there and overseas, becoming international icons? Are there any real Soviet musicians who could qualify for this? Discuss.
If I can nerd out for a moment Kennedy-wise, in the film "Timequest", there was a band called "The Moscow Five" who filled the hole left by an unsuccessful Beatles.

The problem with USSR Beatles is Soviet censorship, which played a heavy role in music. The music that was marketed was "wholesome" and state approved drivel. That led to a big underground, but getting a globally marked band with the Beatles kinda vibe from there is hard. And, the Soviets weren't necessarily good at exporting culture.
 
Top