Status
Not open for further replies.
Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.
-Galatians 6:7

Fiorello La Guardia at the 1932 Progressive Convention said:
Let us answer the question of 'What has moderation done for us?' I shall tell you what moderation has achieved. Moderation has achieved an unemployment rate of 32%. Moderation has achieved a stock market at its lowest levels in ten years. Moderation has achieved the worst Depression in the history of the United States. Moderation has achieved starvation.
It was once radical to believe that workers should form unions. It was once radical to believe women should vote. It was once radical to believe that slavery was wrong. It was once radical to call for 'Government By the People, For the People, of the People', and it was once radical to say 'All men are created equal'.
As I walked the streets of my city, the city that I love, I saw the suffering endured by million, men and women, white and colored, native and immigrant. And as I stared into the tearful eyes of a young boy, homeless and parentless, as he cried over the dead body of his twin brother, I knew what God intended. I knew that I could never face God on Judgement day, if I did not now call for all of my delegates to vote for the Radical Platform and the Radical Candidate!

Presenting the sequel to The Ruins of An American Party System, Part One: Implosion, winner of the 2015 Turtledove for Best New Early 20th Century Timeline:

The Ruins of An American Party System, Part Two:
Collision


~~~​

March 2, 1933

"Fiorello, at last!" exclaimed Floyd Olson as his Vice President Elect entered the room. "I called you here to inform you that I've chosen Huey Long to be my nominee for Attorney General." The Louisiana Senator was sitting in Olson's temporary office. He wore a plaid suit and a garish pink tie, his trademark obnoxious style. La Guardia knew that Long did so in part to anger the older, conservative Senators unused to someone blatantly disrespecting their office. "Have you met?" Olson asked the two.

"A couple times in passing," replied La Guardia. Long stood up and the two men shook hands.

"Well, as I live and breath, an Italian yankee!" exclaimed the so-called "Kingfish". "My ol' ma would never believe it if she saw me workin' with th' likes of you."

In stride, La Guardia responded, "Well, some of my fellow... yankees might be shocked, but I'll say that while I've heard plenty of rumors about the simplicity of 'yall's' bloodlines and lack of manners, I've never heard a man claim that a redneck is no good in a fight."

"Damn straight!" replied Long, as Olson stepped forward.

"And a fight is what we'll have," the President-elect declared. "We have a mandate and majority, but the capitalist powers will not accept it. They must be crushed. That is why I've chosen both of you; together, we can bring big business to its knees."

The three talked for a couple hours. La Guardia wondered at first whether Long was genuine, or an opportunist. As he listened to the man, he began to feel a kindred soul. He doubted that if their lives had been switched, if he had been born in the rural South and Long born in a big northern city, if they would not be nearly identical. He sensed the same rage he felt in the poor areas of the city in this country-born man.

The next night, Fiorello and his wife Marie ate dinner with Huey and Rose Long. Rose seemed quiet, though maybe that was just in comparison to her bombastic husband. There was a manic energy about the Kingfish, a sort of enthusiasm and drive, that made him both fascinating and fearful. As he they were driven back home, Marie asked her husband "Do you think he will be a good Attorney General?"

"I think so," said Fiorello. "He seems like a man with good goals. It will be interesting working with him."

~~~​

January 7, 1937

"I would give anything not to be standing here today. I wish that I were busy preparing for my second term as Vice President. But to my sorrow, it is not so. A year ago today, this country lost a great man. Floyd Bjørnstjerne Olson was taken from this country too soon. The youngest man to take the office of President became the youngest to leave it. This tragedy is felt by every good American.

I believe that Olson will go down in history as one of the greatest presidents of the United States. His monuments will stand next to those of Washington and Lincoln. He lead America from the Great Depression to the Great Recovery. To millions of Americans, he was more than just a good leader. He represented to these people that the government can be good, that the state can work for the populace and improve their lives. People who never got anything from the government before Olson now trust the institutions they once cursed.

For all of his achievements, Olson did not die content. He dreamed of so much which has not yet come to pass. I fought to make sure that the dream of healthcare for all Americans was achieved. And I swear, by the time my term is completed, I will make sure that Olson's ideal, a Fair Society, has been realized. We will not bow down! We will not give up!

I could speak for hours about Olson the President. But Floyd wasn't just a leader. He was my friend. Forgive me, but my heart is heavy remembering his loss. Thank you all for joining me in honoring the memory of this great man."

President LaGuardia left the podium. No one clapped for his speech. Applause was too joyful on this somber occasion. A year before, President Floyd Olson died in office. The young Minnesotan governor burst onto the political seen, reshaped America, and was gone as fast as he had appeared. Across America, candles would be lit in his memory.

La Guardia stared at the politicians and statesmen across the room. His eyes briefly locked with the Senator from Louisiana. Huey Long's face held nothing but antipathy for the President. The hatred was mutual. One day, LaGuardia would have to confront that man again. But it wouldn't be tonight. The President was tired, and thinking of Olson. He wouldn't deal with any of his sycophants or enemies right now. He had four years to deal with them. The inevitable could be delayed a day.

A day of rest, and then the battle begun by Floyd Olson would resume.
 
Last edited:
It's back!! And with an excellent set-up too; I've been looking forward to this for a goodly while now and I'm still so excited to see where it's all going to go.
 
A Conversation of Brothers

"You were right Charles."

"What?"

"Hoover was too conservative. Vandenberg would have been a total disaster. Borah would've cracked twenty percent, gaining entirely from the Republicans. We should've nominated Landon."

"Now Bob, I doubt that Landon could've won. The President nabbed 54% of the vote, and most of Landon's gains would've been at the expense of Borah."

"There's more to our democracy than merely winning the Presidency," replied Bob. "The radicals now have free reign to amend the Constitution, and there will be Hell to follow. If we could have only made some gains in Congress..."

"There's some fight left in our party," answered Charles. "And the moderate Progs won't let the radicals destroy the Constitution."

"I hope not." Bob was silent for a minute after that. "If they use their majorities to overturn the Court's authority... I can't bear the thought."

"Our father would roll in his grave."

"He would," said Bob. "We can't let our country fall into radicalism. But we can't let extremists like Bridges or Bricker alienate moderates. The Republican Party needs to win to stop LaGuardia and Long and their plots! We can't win without compromise."

"So what's the plan?" asked Charles.

"Convince the average Republican that we can't win without moderation. Use their desire to stop this so-called 'Fair Society' to get them to value winning. We can't roll back the Great Recovery, that's a fact that needs to be out there. But we can stop this nation from shifting further to the left, and God willing we will."

~~~

63 Days

A black car was driving down the street in Washington D.C. Within it were two of the most powerful men in America: Fiorello LaGuardia, the President of the United States, and Parley Christensen, the Speaker of the House. The driver was trusted, and this way they could be confident that no one was outside their office listening in.

"How long do we have?" asked Christensen.

"I've convinced Sinclair that the reduction in AEA funds this first quarter is just due to budgetary reasons, and they'll rebound come April. Until then, I think I can keep him from realizing his funding's being phased out."

"And come April, when the funds get reduced even further?"

LaGuardia sighed. "It means war in our caucus; the Socialists and God knows how many radicals in our own party will revolt."

"Fiorello... the radicals trust me. I am still one of them. I understand why you did this, but... I can't afford to alienate half of our caucus by defending you. Come April, you will have to explain why you are phasing out four-fifths of their funding. Please don't make me preside over the destruction of a party I worked so hard to build," pleaded Christensen.

"I won't," assured LaGuardia. "We have sixty-three days until April. Sixty-three days to remake America."

"Sixty-three days to build a Fair Society out of inequality and injustice. I assume our priorities are the same as the last time we met?"

"Yes. AEA road expansion, education expansion, disability protection.. the whole deal," responded the President.

"And the Constitution?"

"Labor Protection and the Poll Tax Abolishment. That's what the South will go for."

"You trust Long?" questioned the incredulous Speaker.

"I trust him not to sabotage initiatives he's fought for his whole career. God, I just hope he doesn't revolt until the Socialists do."

The car was pulling up next to Christensen's home. Before he got out, the Speaker queried, "So Civil Rights for all races..."

La Guardia sighed. "Any push will be delayed until the Socialists have already revolted. Let everything hit at once, give us sixty three days." Looking at Christensen's face, he continued, "Look, I know you're disappointed, but we can't win every battle all at once. Rome wasn't built in a day."

"But it was eventually built," replied Christensen as he exited the car.

parley.jpg

Parley Christensen​
 
Last edited:
"We have sixty-three days until April. Sixty-three days to remake America."

Cue Mission Impossible theme.


Christ, I wonder how things might of went had Olsen lived.
Might of kept up this house of cards for a tiny bit longer, but it does look like La Guardia has an impossible task.
 
Happy to see the sequel is finally on.

I just saw while reviewing the first part that the situation of East Asia is missing, mainly about the developments in China (KMT conquest of northern China, Japanese takeover of Mandchuria by radicals of the Kwantung Army, civil war between Nationalists and Communists ...).
I wait to see your version of these events.
 
Yay!!! The sequel's on! I can't wait to see how the 1937 Recession will further alter politics!

I don't think the 1937 recession will necessarily happen in TTL, as we know it. Hell, the Depression is gone, outright.


The game they're playing with the Socialists sounds interesting... they're gonna phase out the funding, but they're hoping to remake America so that the loss of funding won't matter as much... maybe?
 
And party revolts or not, I have trouble imagining that they'd intentionally undo their progressive accomplishments out of spite...


Or maybe they totally would.
 
Happy to see the sequel is finally on.

I just saw while reviewing the first part that the situation of East Asia is missing, mainly about the developments in China (KMT conquest of northern China, Japanese takeover of Mandchuria by radicals of the Kwantung Army, civil war between Nationalists and Communists ...).
I wait to see your version of these events.
Yeah...

If anyone here is knowledgable in China in this period, I have some ideas that I'd want to PM you to test their plausibility.
 
It lives!

I wasn't a huge reader until the revisions, but now you've got me totally hooked. Can't wait to see how the Socialists will react. Or, honestly, LaGuardia might refuse to go through with the reductions and keep his promise to Sinclair and have the moderates leave the party. Or rather, I hope.

In 63 days, nobody knows what will happen. And what will come of the Progressive Party? I wonder, will it dissolve? Will it become moderate again? Who knows?
 
Yeah...

If anyone here is knowledgable in China in this period, I have some ideas that I'd want to PM you to test their plausibility.

All I can say is that don't make the mistake of turning China axis without a old PoD like I did:p

Since I know zilch about interwar asia
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top