Union and Liberty: An American TL

Status
Not open for further replies.
Part One: The First Term of Andrew Jackson (1828-1832)
Alright, I've been here for about a year, and I've built up a few timeline ideas in my head and on my computer through those days. So I figured I'd post a timeline here and see what you all think. It will be posted in a history book-ish style, as I'm not much of a person to go into very much detail about something. Anyway, here goes.

Union and Liberty: A History of America


Part One: The First Term of Andrew Jackson (1828-1832)

The Tariff of Abominations and the Southern Reaction:
In 1828, President John Quincy Adams passed a tariff increase to help American manufacturers compete with their European counterparts. This sealed Adams' fate in the Election of 1828 as Andrew Jackson and John C. Calhoun put reducing the tariff as part of their running platform.[1] Jackson beat out Adams in the election with 178 or 68% of the electoral votes. With the election won Jackson and Calhoun were sworn into the White House on March 4, 1829.


The Nullification Crisis:
After Jackson's ascension to the Presidency, South Carolina declared a right to nullify the Tariff of Abominations. Jackson opposed the nullification, but did not want to cause a confrontation with Calhoun as Calhoun had openly supported South Carolina's position on the tariff, and a fissure between the President and the Vice President would not help to strengthen the Union. Jackson also sympathized with the southern side of the debate to some degree. On April 13, 1830, at the Democratic Party celebration of Thomas Jefferson's birthday, a series of toasts would emphasize each member's position on the issue. When it came to Jackson, he raised his glass and said, "Our Federal Union: It must be preserved." Calhoun spoke next, and stated "Union and Liberty, our two most dear."[2] Calhoun's toast echoed the closing remarks by Daniel Webster during an earlier debate on the issue of Nullification. While the toasts showed the differing opinions between the President and the Vice President, it also showed their willingness to work together to preserve the United States.

In the summer of 1830, Jackson declared that he would reduce tariff levels to appease South Carolina and attempt an end to the Nullification Crisis, but he and Calhoun disagreed on how far to lower the tariffs. Calhoun wanted to lower tariffs immediately to below the levels before the Tariff of 1828 was passed, while Jackson wanted to gradually lower tariffs to somewhere in between the 1816 levels and the levels of the Tariff of Abominations. During talks in Congress, the two sides agreed to gradually reduce tariffs to the levels of the Tariff of 1824 over the next three years.


Arkansaw Statehood:
In 1831, the state of Arkansaw was admitted to the United States, becoming the 25th state.


The Election of 1832:
With their friendship restored, Jackson and Calhoun won the nominations for President and Vice President for the Democratic Party in 1832. Henry Clay was nominated as the Presidential candidate for the National Republican Party. The main issue during the election was the Second Bank of the United States, which Clay was in favor of and Jackson was against. Jackson had vetoed a renewal of the bank's charter during his first term as President, and convinced much of the populace during his campaign in 1832 that the bank was unnecessary and would lead to an elite. His appearance as the Common Man continued, and he won the election of 1832 with a landslide victory.

Under Jackson and Calhoun, the Democratic Party swept the south and the west, as well as much of the northeast. The Democratic Party achieved 190 electoral votes out of a possible 289, gaining 65% of the votes. Clay managed to win Maine, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Kentucky, and Maryland, earning the National Republicans 32% of the electoral vote. Vermont was won by the small Anti-Masonic Party led by William Wirt, but this minor party soon faded. Jackson and Calhoun were inaugurated and took office for a second term on January 21, 1833.

[1] In OTL, this was not part of Jackson's platform.
[2] Calhoun's toast in OTL was "The Union; next to our liberty, the most dear." This event showed the rift that had grown between Jackson and Calhoun that would lead to Jackson picking Van Buren as his VP for 1832.
 
Last edited:
The election map for the 1832 Presidential election.

Alternate Presidents 1832 election.png
 
Part Two: Jackson's Second Term
Now for the next part. And comments would be very welcome. :)

Part Two: Jackson's Second Term


New York v. New Jersey:
Even after the United States had been created, some states still had quarrels with each other that had carried over from the time as British colonies. The most important of these were territorial disputes that came about from inaccurate surveying or overlapping claims. One of these was the dispute between New York and New Jersey over their border as it approached New York City.

The border between New York and New Jersey after it reached the Hudson River according to New Jersey was a bisection of the Hudson, while in New York it was said to be the western shore of the Hudson. In the 1820s, New Jersey began to develop shipping industries on the western shore of the Hudson, and in turn New York attempted to tax the shipping for crossing the border into New York as the ships came in and out of New York Bay. Several New Jersey companies refused to pay the tolls on the shipping and the state brought the issue up in court. The dispute went all the way up to the Supreme Court as the Court is obligated in the Constitution to hear "controversies between the states".

During the hearing, not only were the trade issues brought up but also the underlying dispute over the two states' territorial boundaries. After four days, the Court headed by Chief Justice John Marshall eventually decided in favor of New Jersey in a 5-2 decision. Justices Marshall, Duvall, Story, Mclean, and Baldwin were of the majority opinion, while justices Johnson and Thompson forming the dissenting opinion. They determined that New Jersey did not have to pay New York for the tolls, but went further and stated that the eastern border of New York and New Jersey would bisect the Hudson River through the Narrows. This landmark ruling gave Staten Island to New Jersey and established the precedent of the Supreme Court having ultimate jurisdiction over boundary disputes between states.


Indian Removal:
Throughout his presidency, Andrew Jackson oversaw the policy of moving many of the Indian tribes west of the Mississippi River. Many of the Choctaw voluntarily moved off their lands after ceding the remaining territory to the United States government, and were moved west to areas in what is now the state of Arkansaw. While it was the intention of the federal government to move the Choctaw further west, the governor of Arkansaw allowed the Choctaw who desired to settle in Arkansaw and purchase land there. During Jackson's administration, ten thousand Choctaw moved into Arkansaw, while the same number remained in Mississippi where they were treated harshly by incoming settlers.

Many of the Chickasaw and Creek received monetary compensation for their remaining lands in Georgia and Alabama. Most of these tribes used the money to move west of the Mississippi and settle or south into Mexico. But a few decided to buy land in Alabama north of the Tennessee where they set up small communities in the sparsely populated frontier regions of the state. Their largest community was in Waterloo, Alabama, in the northwestern corner of the state. While the town had grown with the influx of Native Americans, the town has mostly died out during the 20th century as a result of emigration north to the Midwest.

The Seminoles were the toughest group to be removed, and the only group to remain in their ancestral lands until after the Jackson administration. The Seminole Wars is a term given to the many skirmishes the natives had with settlers and the militias gathered by the city of Saint Augustine. After offers of moving west had been accepted then rejected by a council of Seminole chiefs, the tribe stood its ground and fought for over ten years before they submitted and reached an agreement with the federal government. Owing to the poor climate of much of Florida and the resistance of the Seminoles, the federal government was slow to deal with the Seminoles and eventually let them remain on their land in the interior of Florida.

The Cherokee presented a complicated situation and in the end were the only of the Five Civilised Tribes to be forcefully removed from their land successfully. The Supreme Court decision of Worcester v. Georgia and Jackson's unwillingness to let the federal government handle the situation led the Georgia state militia to take action against the Cherokee. Many of the Cherokee were rounded up and forced to move west, on a journey where many of them died. Eventually, at Memphis in 1833, the Cherokee chiefs signed a treaty which formally ceded their land to Georgia and granted them new land south of the Platte River in what is today Pahsapa. While this conflicted with the locations of other Native American tribes, the Cherokee were moved to a reservation there and remain there to this day.


Assassination of Jackson:
The first attempt to assassinate Jackson came in 1833. On May 6, Jackson was on his way to lay the cornerstone of a monument to Mary Ball Washington in Fredericksburg. During a stopover in Alexandria in what was then Virginia but is now part of Winfield, a man by the name of Robert B. Randolph appeared and attempted to stab the President with a dagger. Jackson managed to dodge the blow and proceeded to chase after Randolph and beat him with his cane. Jackson had previously ordered the dismissal of Randolph from the navy for embezzlement, but in the end Jackson decided that the beating was punishment enough to Randolph and did not press charges. A short chronicle of the event was written by Washington Irving, who was present at the time and was serving as the minister to Spain under Jackson's administration.

The second attempt to assassinate a president was also toward Jackson, this time successful. In 1835, as Jackson exited the Capitol Building after the funeral of South Carolina senator Warren R. Davis Richard Lawrence stepped out toward Jackson and fired a pistol at the President. The bullet entered Jackson's chest and Lawrence was restrained by the crowd, including David Crockett, one of the first senators from the state of Tejas. Jackson died of blood loss four days later and was given a state funeral. He was succeeded by Vice President John C. Calhoun on February 3, 1835. Lawrence was deemed insane but his crime was viewed as so great that he was sentenced to death seven years after Jackson's death.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, very interesting.

One question about the original POD: why does Jackson make the change? OTL Jackson supported the 1828 tariff to gain support in Pennsylvania and thus the election; the move was Van Buren's idea. Does Jackson simply reject the idea and thus favor Calhoun over Van Buren?

Other thoughts:

1) What does Van Buren do after 1832?

2) Is Davy Crockett already a Senator from "Tejas" in February, 1835 or is he still a Congressman from Tennessee? If the latter, then it means he's more successful than OTL, which might complicate him getting to Texas in the fall of 1835, in time for the Alamo...which is probably how he survives to become a senator, I suppose.

3) I see the Civil War TTL will get pretty interesting: Winfield being a Thaddeus Stevens-like new state out of the old South, perhaps?

4) President John C. Calhoun! Eegads.
 
Interesting, very interesting.

One question about the original POD: why does Jackson make the change? OTL Jackson supported the 1828 tariff to gain support in Pennsylvania and thus the election; the move was Van Buren's idea. Does Jackson simply reject the idea and thus favor Calhoun over Van Buren?

Other thoughts:

1) What does Van Buren do after 1832?

2) Is Davy Crockett already a Senator from "Tejas" in February, 1835 or is he still a Congressman from Tennessee? If the latter, then it means he's more successful than OTL, which might complicate him getting to Texas in the fall of 1835, in time for the Alamo...which is probably how he survives to become a senator, I suppose.

3) I see the Civil War TTL will get pretty interesting: Winfield being a Thaddeus Stevens-like new state out of the old South, perhaps?

4) President John C. Calhoun! Eegads.
Well, I was thinking that Jackson, while wanting some tariffs to help reduce the national debt, would decide to oppose tariffs that were that high. Also, Jackson was a moderate supporter of states' rights and felt that he could gain more votes in the South than he could in Pennsylvania by supporting the tariff.

1) I haven't really thought about what happens to van Buren if he doesn't get the vice presidency, but I suppose he could get an ambassadorship somewhere or return to a position in New York.

2) In 1835, Davy Crockett is still a congressman from Tennessee. He will move out to Tejas later and become a senator once it becomes a state.

3) Perhaps. ;)

4) Eegads indeed. :D
 
Part Three: Calhoun's First Year
If we see a President Crockett, I will worship you as a god!
That gives me an idea...

Anyway, here's the next section.

Part Three: Calhoun's First Year

The Texas Rebellion:
Beginning in the summer of 1835, Mexico increasingly had problems with its frontier region of Texas as well as some other provinces as the conflict between centralisation and federalism increased. Along with Texas, the Mexican states of Tamaulipas, Nuevo Leon, Coahuila, Zacatecas, and Yucatan rose up in open revolt against Santa Anna. On October 2, the Battle of Gonzales was fought between Texas and Mexico, the first engagement of the Texas Rebellion. Two months later, on December 7, the Texans captured San Antonio and on December 19, signed their declaration of independence from Mexico at the city of Washington-on-the-Brazos, later to become Austin after the man considered as the Father of Texas.

President Calhoun's response to the start of the Texas Rebellion was that the United States should support the Texans in their struggle for independence from the 'corrupted democracy of Santa Anna's Mexico', as he stated in a speech in New Orleans. Calhoun also said that he would not directly intervene unless Mexico invaded the United States, in order to avoid angering the northern states by seeming like he overtly supported the expansion of slavery.


Expansion of Rail: During his travel to the speech in New Orleans, Calhoun became the first president to travel in a railroad car when he travelled on the Baltimore and Ohio rail connection between Washington, DC and Baltimore. Afterward, he was determined that rail expansion would serve to greatly help the country in its industrial growth.

During 1835 and early 1836, he helped pass legislation to finance a railroad between Columbia and Charleston in South Carolina, as well as approving a bill to create a congressional transport committee, primarily to assist with and oversee the connection of the nations interior industrial and population centers with its ports. This would facilitate economic growth as well as encourage passenger travel in greater parts of the United States.


Toledo War:
The Toledo War was a boundary dispute between the Territory of Michigan and the State of Ohio. The dispute had erupted when it was discovered that the southernmost point of Lake Michigan, the basis for the northern boundary of Ohio, was found to be more southerly than previously thought. Although there were few confrontations between the two, both the governments of Michigan Territory and Ohio refused to back down even with Calhoun and members of Congress.

The tensions between Michigan Territory and Ohio remained well into 1836. As William Henry Harrison, an Ohioan, seemed like the front runner for Calhoun's opposition in the election, Calhoun realized he didn't have anything to gain from siding with Ohio. With this, the President began supporting Michigan's position, and urged Congress and the Ohioans to side with his position. In June of 1836, Calhoun signed a bill that would accept Michigan as a state, as soon as the boundary with Ohio was settled. In August of 1836, the governors of Michigan and Ohio, with pressure from Congress and Calhoun to settle the dispute, allowed the border to be resurveyed.

To ensure impartiality, they chose a little known surveyor named John C Fremont, who was then an officer in the United States Navy. Fremont surveyed the line eastward from the southernmost point of Lake Michigan to Lake Erie, and found that the line did indeed pass south of Toledo. In compensation, Michigan allowed those who wanted to move to Ohio to do so, and compensated them for their land holdings on the Michigan side of the border.

While Michigan gained the Toledo Strip during the war, it also lost a large amount of land. This land went to the creation of the Pembina Territory in anticipation of the admission of Michigan as a state. The border between Pembina Terrtitory and Michigan Territory was formed by the Mississippi River up to the Chippewa River, then following that river to its source, then plotting a course north northeast to Lake Superior. Montevideo became the first capital of Pembina Territory.


Election of 1836:
Throughout 1836, the election was fought with a tough campaign. Calhoun ran as the incumbent for the Democratic Party, nominating George M. Dallas, former senator and attorney general of Pennsylvania, as his running mate. William Henry Harrison and Henry Clay ran in their newly created Whig Party, while Daniel Webster and Willie Magnum ran for the National Republicans. While Calhoun's decision in the Toledo War lost him Ohio, it has been determined by historians that he would have likely lost Ohio anyway as it was Harrison's home state. Harrison's and Webster's attempts to gather public opinion were futile and Calhoun was elected, showing the continuing disunion of the Anti-Jacksonian parties.

Calhoun/Dallas: 150
Harrison/Clay: 74
Webster/Magnum: 67
 
Last edited:
Interesting: the Texans declare Independence about 3 months sooner (OTL they did so on March 2, 1836). I presume the difference is down to Calhoun's support? Of course, they still have to win that independence from Mexico.

And it seems Austin will be some 150 miles closer to Houston...if of course, there is a Houston. (There should be, even if it's smaller, unless the Kirby brothers decide to go elsewhere or if Houston isn't President and so the brothers chose a different name to pull of their scheme/scam). Of course, it also seems like one or more of the Old NWestern states is going to be different in shape and or name, but what of it? ;)

The election of 1836 certainly was a squeaker--one state shy of going to the House.
 
Thank you for restoring Michigan's "lost townships" to her! So few timelines do. Also, with Calhoun as POTUS does this mean that slavery will expand into the American west and that the TC-RR will be built along the southern route?
 
And it seems Austin will be some 150 miles closer to Houston...if of course, there is a Houston. (There should be, even if it's smaller, unless the Kirby brothers decide to go elsewhere or if Houston isn't President and so the brothers chose a different name to pull of their scheme/scam). Of course, it also seems like one or more of the Old NWestern states is going to be different in shape and or name, but what of it? ;)
Hmmmm, I didn't know about the Kirby brothers until now. :D I will look into it and see what I can come up with. And yes, some of the Old NW will be different.

Lord Grattan said:
Thank you for restoring Michigan's "lost townships" to her! So few timelines do. Also, with Calhoun as POTUS does this mean that slavery will expand into the American west and that the TC-RR will be built along the southern route?
Well, while Calhoun is President, he will be somewhat balanced out by men such Clay and Webster in Congress. And you'll see what happens with the TCRR later. ;)

Meanwhile, here's a map of the 1836 election. I'll try to post text updates once a day.

Alternate Presidents 1836 election.png
 
Part Four: The Mexican Collapse
And now...

Part Four: The Mexican Collapse

Admission of Michigan:
On February 4, 1837, Michigan was admitted as a state in the Union. Before it was admitted, the land to the west of Lake Michigan was separated off to form the Marquette Territory. Detroit became the capital of the state of Michigan, which it remains to the present day. Stephen T. Mason, who was territorial governor during the Toledo War, was elected the state's first governor. John S. Homer, who opposed Mason in the 1836 territorial elections, became the first governor of Marquette Territory, moving to the new territorial capital of Green Bay.


Fall of the Mexican Republic:
As 1837 began, the Texans faced another attack by Mexico. As Santa Anna marched against Texan forces, other regions in Mexico began rebelling. The Yucatan, which had rebelled two years before, rose up once again to overthrow the policies of centralization of Santa Anna. In the north, citizens in Santa Fe and many of the Spanish missions along the California coast rose up as well. Santa Anna figured that if he himself crushed the Texans, then the rest of the country would fall back in line.

Santa Anna initially won a string of victories capturing San Antonio and Corpus Christi. Upon reaching Beaumont, he caught a group of the Texans retreating to the east. Santa Anna, taking a major gamble ordered his men to pursue the Texans all the way across the Sabine River, at which point they began putting up a fight. The Texans managed to push Santa Anna back across the river, but not before letting civilians know that the Mexican army had crossed into the United States. Santa Anna lost that gamble, and on April 12, 1837, Congress approved a declaration of war on Mexico. United States troops moved into Texas and soon were chasing Santa Anna back toward the Rio Bravo. Other forces were assisting with the revolts in California and Santa Fe. John C Fremont, now part of the United States Corps of Topographical Engineers, took part in the expedition to assist the rebels in Santa Fe. Later, he traveled west and led the rebels in California down from San Francisco to capture the missions in San Diego and all the way to Baja California.

Meanwhile, Zachary Taylor drove the Mexican army out of Texas and assisted the new rebellion in the provinces of Coahuila, Nuevo Leon, and Tamaulipas. In September of 1837, they declared their independence as the Republic of the Rio Bravo. Minor skirmishes continued throughout Mexico into 1838 as the independence forces and United States army contingents continued to battle the remnants of the Mexican army.

The rebels cooperated with the United States forces and Santa Anna was soon captured by the Texans and imprisoned. However, despite Fremont in the west, Zachary Taylor in the north, and the country growing more and more unstable, the government in Mexico City refused to give up. It was decided that an attack on Mexico City itself would have to be made. General Winfield Scott led an army to attack Veracruz and push forth to Mexico City. He followed the approximate route of Hernan Cortez, leading to one of his nicknames being the Second Cortez. After the occupation of Mexico City, the government surrendered, and Santa Anna was freed to negotiate with the various proclaimed governments that Mexico was now at war with. In a humiliating affair, Santa Anna signed the Treaties of Galveston on May 5, 1838. In the treaties, Santa Anna and the Mexican government recognized the independence of the newly proclaimed republics of California, Rio Bravo, and Yucatan. In addition, all land east of the Rio Bravo was ceded to Texas, Veracruz was opened to all United States navy vessels, and a sum was paid to the United States government. Soon after Santa Anna returned to Mexico City and the United States forces had evacuated, he was overthrown and replaced by Federalist Anastasio Bustamante. This would only lead to further troubles and civil strife in Mexico throughout the 19th century.
 
Last edited:
Interesting that the Treaties recognize the independence of the new republics...this suggests that US annexation is not a foregone conclusion. I imagine this results from the need to assuage anti-slavery politicians by President Calhoun?

Also interesting that the Rio Grande is known as the Rio Bravo in the US TTL (unlike OTL in which it's called the Rio Grande in the US and the Rio Bravo in Mexico).

Is the Specie Circular issued TTL?
 
In 1835, as Jackson exited the Capitol Building after the funeral of South Carolina senator Warren R. Davis Richard Lawrence stepped out toward Jackson and fired a pistol at the President. The bullet entered Jackson's chest and Lawrence was restrained by the crowd, including David Crockett, one of the first senators from the state of Tejas.
2) In 1835, Davy Crockett is still a congressman from Tennessee. He will move out to Tejas later and become a senator once it becomes a state.
Ahh buggers. I was hoping the 1834 Independence attempt had succeeded.
 
Part Five: The Remainder of Calhoun's Presidency
Part Five: The Remainder of Calhoun's Presidency

Martin Van Buren's Ambassadorships:
During Jackson's presidency, Calhoun had seen that Martin van Buren was becoming a prominent politician. Van Buren, a Dutch New Yorker, had been governor of New York as well as Jackson's Secretary of State for much of his Presidency. Calhoun, wishing to keep van Buren away from the United States to keep him out of politics, appointed van Buren to a number of ambassadorships during his presidency. Among his posts, van Buren attended the coronation of Queen Victoria in 1838 as ambassador to the United Kingdom. In 1839, van Buren was appointed ambassador to the Netherlands, where he played a small part in the negotiations leading to the independence of Belgium and helping the Netherlands retain all of Limburg and Luxembourg, as well as Liege to keep the country contiguous. In exchange, Belgium received the Dutch possessions on the island of Borneo, which at the time were losing money and that the Dutch consdiered a bad investment.


Speech on Republics:
In 1839, President Calhoun made a speech in Washington on the benefits of a republican system, and encouraged all the Latin American republican movements to flourish. This speech inspired many people, especially the men fighting for the independence of the Piratini Republic. The leaders, including Guiseppe Garibaldi, were encouraged by Calhoun's speech, and managed to hold off the Brazilian Empire for six more months. In 1840, Calhoun authorized the sending of hundreds of men to go assist the Piratini Republic in their fight. By August, the Piratini forces signed a ceasefire with Brazil, and became yet another independent republic in Latin America with the former Brazilian provinces of Rio Grande do Sul and Juliana.


State of Jackson:
With the intervention in Mexico, there wasn't much that Calhoun could do about the resistance of the Seminoles in the Florida Peninsula. While settlers were not moving to the lower portion of the peninsula, many were moving to the panhandle. As these settlers wanted to be part of a state, Congress passed a bill to divide the territory of Florida into two along the Aucilla River. The western portion soon was admitted on June 18, 1838, as the state of Jackson after the former President, while the rest remained a territory. The capital of Jackson was decided between Pensacola and Tallahassee, and Pensacola was decided on as many citizens of Jackson thought Tallahassee was too close to the Seminole lands and was vulnerable to raids. Also, the population of Pensacola experienced a massive increase as immigrants flocked to the city after the collapse of the Mexican state.


Election of 1840:
Unfortunately, the United States intervention in Mexico and Jackson's earlier policies which Calhoun for the most part continued pushed the country into a recession in the later 1830s. Combined with the consolidation of the Whigs and National Republicans into the Whig Party, Calhoun ran into trouble during the election of 1840. While he tried to appeal to much of the nation as the continuation of the Common Man espoused by Jackson, he did not achieve very much success. The country was in an economic downturn and had grown fed up with Jackson's policies. William Henry Harrison successfully ran with the platform of the Common Man and a war hero while making Calhoun look like a wealthy southerner. Where Calhoun tried to make Harrison seem out of touch and unfit to administer the nation, Harrison's campaigners not only twisted the attacks to Harrison's favor, but pointed out that they also had Daniel Webster, then a renowned senator and politician. These campaign tactics helped William Henry Harrison win the election handily, and he was sworn in on March 3, 1841.

Calhoun/Dallas: 93
Harrison/Webster: 205
 
Wow, look at all those butterflies...an expanded Netherlands, a successful Piratani Republic...powerful little buggers.

And I see the Whigs have gotten their act together and elected WH Harrison; let's hope he doesn't see the need for speechifying. Though if he does, at least we'll get President Daniel Webster!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top