Ex Oriente Lux: An industrialized China

Srrpk7O.png



Our entire history is only the history of waking men.
Georg Christoph Lichtenberg


The night is no man's friend," attested a proverb during the middle ages. Many residents of urban and rural communities, when navigating the dark, learned to rely on local lore, magic, and their knowledge of the natural universe.
Time, place, and weather became critical concerns while treading abroad. The quality of moonlight (called by some the "parish-lantern") varied greatly, as did the nocturnal landscape, which children learned to negotiate early on "as a rabbit knows his burrow." Most people, robbed of their vision in a world of face-to-face relationships and hence their ability to discern gestures, dress, and facial expressions, depended heavily on hearing, smell, and touch (feet as well as hands). They also resorted to charms to ward off evil spirits.
And although the cost of candles—tallow as well as beeswax—remained prohibitively high for most households, early modern folk relied on a broad range of more primitive illuminants, including rushlights and candlewood, for small measures of light.

To forestall thieves, propertied households prepared for bed as if girding for an impending siege. "Barricaded,“ "bolted," and "barred,"were their homes on the "backside and foreside, top and bottom." Nighttime saw quarters made fast, with doors and shutters locked once dogs had been loosed outdoors.
So it doesn't come to much of a surprise that the first impression the Polo brother Niccolò and Maffeo had about China would also be the most lasting one. While many more wonders would await them in this distant, exotic Empire, the brightly shining skyline of Guangzhou illuminating the night would never be upstaged.

[FONT=Times New Roman, serif]Notes and Sources[/FONT]

[FONT=Times New Roman, serif]This will be a very short timeline which gives a small glimpse of the China the Polos visit and its back story. The timeline wil[/FONT]l mostly focus on the technology that is making the industrialization possible, so expect many dead butterflies when it touches any other aspects of history.
One key inventions here is the early discovery of coal gas and its utilization but there is more. This project is not meant to be in competition with any other similar timeline attempts, although it might be a little bit inspired by them ;-).

[FONT=Times New Roman, serif]A. Roger Ekrich: [/FONT]Sleep We Have Lost: Pre-industrial Slumber in the
British Isles.
 
Last edited:

RousseauX

Donor
Alright, this looks interesting, are you also going to expand on the economics side of industrialization?
 
Thanks for the intrest. There will be an update soon enough. On the topic of China's economy, I can't say if I will cover that. So far my plan is to outline the technological pathway for an industrialized China, anything else is optional at the moment. Personally I hope that the collaboration project on an industrialized Song China will cover other things in more depth.
 
Is there the Mongol empire? Because without them the Polos would never visit.

History went down quiet a bit different at this point. Without spoiling too much, the Mongols never were united in this timeline. As for the Polos, they use the Southern Silk road along the Indian coast. They mostly serve as a framing device thou, keeping some things familiar to OTL reader. They do however have some good alternate reasons to go on their journey here.
 
The Salt (and Gas) of Earth


A History of ...

Before there was an understanding of what natural gas was, it posed a mystery to man. Sometimes, lightning strikes would ignite natural gas that was escaping from under the earth’s crust. This would create a fire coming from the earth, burning the natural gas as it seeped out from underground. These fires puzzled most early civilizations, and were the root of myth and superstition. One of the most famous of these flames was found in ancient Greece, on Mount Parnassus around 1000 B.C. A goat herdsman came across what looked like a „burning spring“, a flame rising from a fissure in the rock. The Greeks, believing it to be of divine origin, built a temple on the flame. This temple housed a priestess who was known as the Oracle of Delphi, giving out prophecies she claimed were inspired by the flame.

These types of springs became prominent in the religions of India, Greece, and Persia. Unable to explain where these fires came from, they were often regarded as divine, or supernatural. It wasn’t until about 500 B.C. that the Chinese discovered the potential to use these fires to their advantage. The center of this development was China’s Sichuan Province. The Yangtze River flows along the southern edge of the basin, and numerous tributaries drain south through the rich agricultural lands and into the Yangtze. With its fertile, well-watered soil and mild climate, Sichuan is one of China’s most productive farming regions. Since ancient times, this region has held attractive conditions for human habitation and has been occupied by humans since the dawn of our existence. Many of China’s ancient technical accomplishments came from this region, including sophisticated irrigation techniques and their drilling technology and the Daifeng engine (1). At the base of all these technology lay the drill which allowed for the systematic exploitation of natural gas reservoirs.

... drilling...

Approximately 5,000 years ago Chinese coastal people were boiling sea water to produce salt. As high density human settlement penetrated further and further inland and increasingly relied on farming, salt, critical to human survival as a vital food supplement and preservative. became a valuable commodity.
The first recorded salt well in China was dug in Sichuan, around 2,250 years ago. This was the first time water well technology was applied successfully to the exploitation of salt and marked the beginning of Sichuan’s salt drilling industry. From that point on, wells in Sichuan have penetrated the earth to tap into brine aquifers, essentially ground water with a salinity of more than 50 g/l. The water is then evaporated using a heat source, leaving the salt behind.

About 2,000 years ago the technology began to evolve. The inhabitants began to dig wells with percussive drilling systems instead of digging them by hand with shovels. By the beginning of the third century AD, wells were being drilled up to 140 m deep. Some rural farmers still used this drilling technique for water wells only few decades ago. Thanks to them and the Imperial Sichuan Salt Industrial Museum the technology is well preserved The drill bit is made of iron, the pipe bamboo. The rig was constructed from bamboo; one or more men stood on a wooden plank lever, much like a seesaw. This lifted up the drill stem about 1 m or so. The pipe was allowed to drop, and the drill bit crashed down into the rock, pulverizing it. Inch by inch, drilling slowly progressed.

It has been speculated that percussive drilling was derived from the pounding of rice into rice flour. While it may seem that this was a fairly crude technology, the methods became quite sophisticated over time. Eventually, these ancient drillers had developed most of the tools and techniques one might see on a modern drilling rig, albeit on a smaller scale and without the benefits of modern machining methods.
At regular intervals in the drilling, the crushed rock and mud at the bottom of the hole needed to be removed. The drill stem would be pulled from the hole using a large wheel, somewhat similar in appearance to that on a modern flexible cable downhole tool truck. A length of hollow bamboo with a leather foot valve would then be lowered to the bottom of the hole. When the tube was lifted, the weight of the mud inside would keep the valve closed, and the contents could be brought to the surface. Drilling would then recommence.

The drilling method on its own is impressive, especially when considering that the rest of the world had nothing comparable in the earlier centuries. But even more impressive are all the techniques the Sichuan drillers developed to overcome common drilling problems such as cave ins, lost tools, deviated wells, and so on. A huge variety of tools and techniques evolved to handle well repair issues.
Many different drill bits were also developed, with different sizes, shapes and compositions, to deal with the different rock types encountered, and the many different drilling requirements. For example, opening the hole at the wellhead required a large heavy bit 3 m long weighing 331 to 551 lb called the “Fish Tail”; the “Silver Ingot” drilled the well bore rapidly, but roughly; the “Horseshoe” bit drilled slowly, but achieved round, smooth, high quality well bores. Hollow logs were used in the near surface as casing.

A major breakthrough, which allowed for deeper wells, was achieved around 1050 AD. Solid bamboo pipe was replaced by thin, light flexible bamboo “cable.” This dramatically lowered the weight of the “drill string,” which made it easier to lift from the surface. 1100 AD Sichuan wells were typically in the depth range of 300 to 400 m. The Sichuan salt producing industry was centered in the city of Zigong, and early photographs show hundreds of producing derricks, salt stove operations, and the Fuxi River jammed with salt trading boats. Brine and natural gas were transported through extensive networks of bamboo pipelines. Wood was initially the fuel used in the evaporation process, but sources of wood became scarce before long due to the scale of the salt production industry. Several energy saving techniques were used during evaporation, but natural gas eventually replaced wood in the brine evaporation process.

... and pumping.

Once established both brine and natural gas were piped through bamboo tubes; from small boreholes the gas could be piped directly to burners where the brine was emptied into cast iron evaporation pans for boiling and producing salt, but the pungent gas piped from depths of some 2,000 ft had to be first mixed with air lest an explosion occur. To remedy this, the gas was first piped into a large wooden, cone-shaped chamber placed 3 m below ground level where another pipe could convey air, thus turning the chamber into a large carburetor. To avoid fires from a sudden surplus of gas, an additional "sky thrusting pipe" was used as an exhaust system.

There is no record of when the use of natural gas exactly began, but clearly the Sichuan locals were drilling down hundreds of feet into the earth to get natural gas and brine already before the start of the Han Dynasty, so at least before 400 B.C. The initial discovery of natural gas may have come as a serendipitous byproduct of the search for brine and salt. Natural gas wells were called fire wells (火井). Once wells were drilled down to 700 to 800 m, during the Song's Golden Age they could produce both brine and gas from the Jialingjiang group Triassic formations. The salt industry was a huge economic driver, and many large cities in Sichuan were established and flourished,because of the lucrative salt trade.
A key technological advancement at was the introduction of the “Kang Pen” drum at the beginning of the Tang dynasty. This drum sat on top of the wellhead, and the pressure within the drum was controlled such that gas and brine could be produced simultaneously, and efficiently separated. One bamboo pipeline would take away the brine and others the gas.


Notes and Sources:

Generally this is all still OTL. Some stuff may happen a little earlier but the really big divergences will happen later. More is going to be revealed in the next post.

(1) Sterling Engine

Oliver Kuhn: Ancient Chinese Drilling.
Divestco Inc
Journal of the Canadian Society of Exploration Geophysicists

Author: Natural Gas as Fuel.
Kaleidoscope Cultural China

Author: First Oil Wells.
historylines.net

Author: History of Chinese Invention - The Discovery of Natural Gas.
http://www.computersmiths.com

Author: History of Natural Gas.
http://naturalgas.org
 
Last edited:
I'm really glad to see to that oil drilling, especially in Sichuan becomes the topic to cover in the 1st update :)

I cannot wait to see what the fully industrialized Song dynasty will be like.

It's not only about industrialization, isn't ? Song needs to be really militarily strong against powerful neighbors...
 
Has such industrialisation been overseen by a mandarinal class, by a merchant class or both? And how the traditional Confucean cursus, which emphasized farming, will cope?

Moreover, will the minority cultures be assimilated in the Han culture by the rural exodus created by a mechanised agriculture or there will be little "Silesias" such as Sichuan, mining districts containing minorities?
 
Has such industrialisation been overseen by a mandarinal class, by a merchant class or both? And how the traditional Confucean cursus, which emphasized farming, will cope?

Moreover, will the minority cultures be assimilated in the Han culture by the rural exodus created by a mechanised agriculture or there will be little "Silesias" such as Sichuan, mining districts containing minorities?

I haven't planned anything about those events. But once I get into the social ramifications of the technology I'll try to adress them.
 
Absolutely fascinating! And like Johannes Parisienes, I am interested to find out what social structure has lead to these innovations.

Also, what sort of weapons mechanized China will bring to bear against Mongol invaders?
 
Has such industrialisation been overseen by a mandarinal class, by a merchant class or both? And how the traditional Confucean cursus, which emphasized farming, will cope?

Moreover, will the minority cultures be assimilated in the Han culture by the rural exodus created by a mechanised agriculture or there will be little "Silesias" such as Sichuan, mining districts containing minorities?

The reformists represented by Wang Anshi must gain the upper hand in the court over the conservatives such as Sima Guang to have the reforms carried out continuously.

A big concern will be whether the current Song emperor is a competent one; many of the Song emperors are good in arts but they are incompetent in ruling the country.

The old mindset that discriminates against merchants and soldiers needs to be reformed. Song is one of the militarily weakest dynasty in Chinese history.
 
Blow Guns, Mechanical Servants and the Origins of China's Industrialization



Blow Guns


The origin of the blowgun, in terms of time and place, is lost in pre-history. Many scholars believe that, due to it's simplicity, this weapon was invented and re-invented in various locations. Most agree though that the blowgun dates back to the stone age and was known and used at that time on all the inhabited continents, with the exception of Africa.
The earliest written references to blowguns in China are from the Chin dynasty between 265 and 429 AD. In the same time frame we also get the first recordings of the fire piston. An fire making device derived from the blow gun manufacutring process. Like the blow gun itself it was independently discovered in the pacific islands without any contact to China's interior.


How does a fire piston work ?

Air gets very hot when it is compressed under high pressure. A classic example would be the heat that is created when one uses a bicycle pump. But when the air is compressed in a firepiston it is done so quickly and efficiently that it can reach a temperature in excess of 426 degrees Celsius. This is hot enough to ignite the tinder that is placed in the end of the piston which has been hollowed out to accept it.

Ancient examples of the tube itself are of hardwood, bamboo, or even horn. It is closed on one end, very smooth inside and accurately bored. Equal care is taken in the creation of the associated piston. A "gasket" of wound thread, fiber, or sometimes leather insures a proper seal for successfully creating the compression. This gasket is "greased" to help with the seal and to allow free travel of the piston.

"...the cylinder is held firmly in the fist of the left hand: a small piece of tinder...is placed in a cavity on the point of the piston, which is just entered into the mouth of the bore; with a sudden stroke of the right hand the piston is forced up the bore, from which it rebounds slightly back with the elasticity of the compressed air, and on being plucked out, which it must be instantly, the tinder is found to be lighted."

How the fire pistons were actually invented is unknown. One of the most cited theories claims that perhaps during the process of boring or gauging them, there may have been compression of air that ignited material in the bore or perhaps on the rod. In addition, it is speculated that perhaps when making blow guns of bamboo they would use a rod to pop out the nodes between the sections and that the discovery was accidentally made during this operation. Once metal making advanced the first brass fire pistons appeared, becoming more and more elaborately ornamented.

Ma Daifeng and his curious Machines

Records in an ancient book, Travel News, tell us that at the beginning of Emperor Tang Xuan Zhong's Kai Yuan rule, someone repaired the emperor's travel vehicle in the palace. Ma Daifeng was an accomplished craftsman of the Eastern Sea region. He rebuilt and repaired such items as the lead carriages, drums for recording the journeys' mileage, and birds for indicating wind directions. These items were made more delicately than those of even more ancient times.
Ma Daifeng also made a dresser for a queen, containing a mirror in the center and two shelves with doors beneath. When the queen needed to dress and apply her make up, the mirrored cabinet was opened and the doors beneath automatically opened. Then, a wooden robot woman emerged carrying washing paraphernalia. The queen removed all the towels and then the wooden woman went back into the cabinet. Items such as rouge and powder, eyebrow pencil and hair adornments all were handed to the queen by this wooden robot.

After she finished, the wooden robot went back and the doors closed automatically. As soon as the doors closed someone would remove the dresser. The top of the dresser was decorated with gold, silver, and colored paintings. The dress and ornaments of the wooden robot were very delicate as well.

Over several years, Ma Daifeng made a variety of instruments for the Emperor in the palace, but he did not give Ma an official position. Ma Daifeng thus felt ashamed.
The Emperor only ordered his people to deliver food and articles for use in daily life to him. Ma asked the Emperor to grant him permission to make useful mechanically enhanced articles, such as drinking vessels and a money-saving jar.

Emperor Xuanzhong granted his request. All the vessels were made from silver. The drinking vessel and money-saving jar were operated by machinery. The drinking vessel can be opened from four directions so wind passed into it. The blowing wind spun the machinery inside, thus, forming negative and positive opposites, allowing the wine to flow out like spring water and filling up all drinking cups and drinking jars. Moreover, mechanical servants controlled the pouring of the wine. These inventions were even finer and more ingenious than anything nature could have engineered.


The Daifeng Engine

Ma's greatest master piece however wasn’t initially recognized as such, the first version of the modern Daifeng engine.
He correctly theorized and tested the hypothesis that if heating the air inside a well sealed fire piston (by heating it from the outside) he could reverse its effect.
Instead of compressed air becoming hot, hot air should expand and press the piston. Thus he had all the components and the theory behind a very primitive air engine. He began tinkering with the idea until he was able to build a sophisticated miniaturized fanning device. These heat powered fans slowly spread from the court to the rest of the country, familiarizing people with the basic concept. Still metallurgy and the understanding of the underling theory didn't yet allow any greater leaps forward.

Notes and Sources

Ming Xin: Ancient Science and Technology: Tang Dynasty Master Craftsman Ma Daifeng.

W.R. Knapp: The Fire Piston: Ancient Fire Making Machine.

James Stuart Koch: A Brief History Of Primitive & Traditional Blowguns.

 
That was a great update :)

I cannot find any detailed info about Ma Daifeng in Wikipedia. This is the first time I've heard about him.
 
The long March of Progress

I recently read an interesting essay by the famous counter-factual history author Bānjiū (斑鳩) "The Aeopile Does Nothing! Musings on the industrialization of Rome".

Its great you can read it here. Briefly summarized, he argues that an (super) advanced invention doesn't spark any further developments on its own. It needs the right philosophical and political environment to really unfold its full potential. Aside form the title giving aeopile, he also goes into a in depth analysis of the the loss of Epicurean Empiricism and the shift into ethereal Platonism/Monotheism (1).

Anyway this inspired me to look into our own history and see if I might find such a moment. And I believe it did.

The Philosophy of Evolution and Adaption

The first theory of geomorphology was arguably devised by the polymath Chinese scientist and statesman Shen Kuo (1031-1095 AD). It was based on his observation of marine fossil shells in a geological stratum of a mountain hundreds of miles from the Pacific Ocean.

Noticing bivalve shells running in a horizontal span along the cut section of a cliffside, he theorized that the cliff was once the pre-historic location of a seashore that had shifted hundreds of miles over the centuries.
He inferred that the land was reshaped and formed by soil erosion of the mountains and by deposition of silt, after observing strange natural erosions of the Taihang Mountains and the Yandang Mountain near Wenzhou.

Furthermore, he promoted the theory of gradual climate change over centuries of time once ancient petrified bamboos were found to be preserved underground in the dry, northern climate zone of Yanzhou, which is now modern day Yan'an, Shaanxi province.Now this might have ended up as one of the many curiosities he wrote down in his book Yin Jong but fate would intervene in form of Yin Jong.
He was a scholar of the Lingbao School and very interested in this particular concept, he began regular expeditions into the Yin Jong mountains to obtain fossils there. His studies led him to elaborate on Shen Kuos thoughts.

Inspired by the taoist philosopher Zhuang Zhou,who explicitly denies the fixity of biological species and speculated that species had developed differing attributes in response to differing environments he began to formulate his basic theory. Taoism regards humans, nature and the heavens as existing in a state of "constant transformation" known as the Tao.
Yin Jong found indeed that many of the creatures he discovered were nowhere to be found in the present day world. This led him to formulate a prototypical theory of evolution. Animals had to change alongside their environment or they would die, perish to be forgotten.

This was not a new or typical Chinese idea there were others. The ancient Greeks proposed that one type of animal, even humans, could descend from other types of animals, are known to go back to the first pre-Socratic Greek philosophers. Anaximander of Miletus (c.610–546 BC) proposed that the first animals lived in water, during a wet phase of the Earth's past, and that the first land-dwelling ancestors of mankind must have been born in water, and only spent part of their life on land.

He also argued that the first human of the form known today must have been the child of a different type of animal, because man needs prolonged nursing to live. Empedocles (c. 490–430 BC), argued that what we call birth and death in animals are just the mingling and separations of elements which cause the countless "tribes of mortal things". Specifically, the first animals and plants were like disjointed parts of the ones we see today, some of which survived by joining in different combinations, and then intermixing, and wherever "everything turned out as it would have if it were on purpose, there the creatures survived, being accidentally compounded in a suitable way".

This line of thought was killed as mentioned in the introduction by Plato (c. 428–348 BC) was called "the great antihero of evolutionism", because he promoted belief in essentialism. A Theory of Forms that holds that each natural type of object in the observed world is an imperfect manifestation of the ideal, form or "species" which defines that type. This "plenitude principle"—the idea that all potential forms of life are essential to a perfect creation greatly influenced Christian thought.

The Technological Breakthrough

Now all of this could still have been contained to some scholarly circles, Yin Jong engaged in. But here we see the powerful combination of revolutionary thought and technology. The motherlode for his own expeditions was the Zhangxia Formation.

The fossils were impressed into lithographic limestone, which happened to have some very useful properties. Lithographic originally used an image drawn with oil, fat, or wax onto the surface of a smooth, level lithographic limestone plate.
The stone was treated with a mixture of acid and other stuff, etching the portions of the stone which were not protected by the grease-based image. When the stone was subsequently moistened, these etched areas retained water; an oil-based ink could then be applied and would be repelled by the water, sticking only to the original drawing. The ink would finally be transferred to a blank paper sheet, producing a printed page. Yin Jong discovered this while trying to "print" his fossils collection on paper to send them to other enthusiasts and vice versa.

The history of printing in China started as early as the Han dynasty ) using woodblock printing on cloth. during (206 BC–220 AD) Later came the invention of paper as a printing material in Imperial Court as early as the 1st century, or around 80 AD. But what distinguished this new method was the ease and the amount of material that could be printed. Obviously one of the first things he did spread were his own ideas and the teachings of his Taoist school.

The Political Side of the Story

These pamphlets and books were recognized and written all over China, and most importantly in the imperial court. Emperor Shenzong of Song was quiet open to the ideas of Taoism and found these new thoughts quiet enlighting seeing himseself following in the foootsepts of Emperor Xuanzong of the Tang Dynasty.

But in the long run it was Wang Anshi who (1021 – 1076 ) who seized the (political) opportunity this development offered. Anshi was a Chinese economist, statesman, chancellor and poet of the Song Dynasty who attempted controversial, major socioeconomic reforms. These reforms constituted the core concepts and motives of the Reformists, while their nemesis, Chancellor Sima Guang, led the Conservative faction against them.

In economics, his reforms expanded the use of money, broke up private monopolies and introduced some forms of government regulation and social welfare. In military affairs, he supported the use of local militias; and in education and government, he expanded the examination system and tried to suppress nepotism.

Under the Song Dynasty, the unprecedented development of large estates, whose owners managed to evade paying their share of taxes, resulted in an increasingly heavy burden of taxation on the peasantry. The drop in state revenues, a succession of budget deficits, and widespread inflation prompted the Emperor to seek advice from Wang. Though Wang was from the southern China, he came from a family of imperial scholars and was placed fourth in the imperial exam of 1042.
He spent the first twenty years of his career in the regional government of the lower Yangtze region. During this period, he gained practical experience in local governance. This experience guided his analysis in formulating solutions to revitalize the ailing Song society.

Wang Anshi's Reforms

Wang believed that the state has the responsibility to provide for its people the essentials for a decent living standard: "The state should take the entire management of commerce, industry, and agriculture into its own hands, with a view to succoring the working classes and preventing them from being ground into the dust by the rich."

Wang came to power as 2nd privy councilor in 1069.It was there that he introduced and promulgated his reform policy. There were three main components to this policy:

1) state finance and trade, 2) defense and social order, and 3) education and improving of governance. (......)

To improve education and government, he sought to break down the barrier between clerical and official careers as well as improving their supervision to prevent connections being used for personal gain. Tests in law, military affairs and medicine were added to the examination system, with mathematics added in 1104.
The National Academy was transformed into a real school rather than simply a holding place for officials waiting for appointments. He also promoted the mass implementation of litography. The new technology allowed to print teaching material in an previously unheard quantity and helped to drastically increase literacy and fueled the aspirations of the lower classes to take the imperial exams.

However, there was deep-seated resistance to the education reforms as it hurt bureaucrats coming in under the old system. Imperial scholar-officials such as Su Dongpo and Ouyang Xiu bitterly opposed these reforms on the grounds of tradition. Here again Yin Jong helped. Armed with the knowledge (and persuasive arguments supporting it) that all that resits change will fall, he was able to keep the Emperor as well as influential court officials such as Shen Kuo on his side even when things got difficult.

Notes and Sources

(1) A sentiment also voiced by Carl Sagan in Cosmos “The Backbone of the Night".

Lots of OTL stuff, but in my oppinion unfortunatly neccesary to understand the changes.

Marty, D et. al .: Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on Lithographic Limestone and Plattenkalk

daoinfo.org: Daoism during the Song and Yuan Dynasties.

Wikipedia
 
The use of lithography to mass produce printed materials is a brilliant idea :)

Glad to see that more attention is being given to learning law, military affairs, medicine, and mathematics.

Hope to see some form of Chinese scientific society soon.

In OTL, Wang Anshi neglected forming a strong reformist faction to fight against the conservationists.

While Jin Yong is really helpful, Wang Anshi needs to change his mindset; instead of working alone, he needs to work together with like-minded individuals so that the reformists becomes politically strong.
 
Top