DBWI: Booth killed Lincoln?

Whitewings

Banned
On April 14, 1868, actor John Wilkes Booth attempted to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln, failing only due to Major Rathbone happening to get up to stretch at just the right moment to force Booth's gun off-target. Though wounded, the President did recover. But what if he hadn't, or if Booth had succeeded?
 
On April 14, 1868, actor John Wilkes Booth attempted to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln, failing only due to Major Rathbone happening to get up to stretch at just the right moment to force Booth's gun off-target. Though wounded, the President did recover. But what if he hadn't, or if Booth had succeeded?

IC: Wow, man. There are literally *endless* possibilities. But we'll start with this: how about a stronger Reconstruction? Lincoln was still quite popular up north before the incident(in fact, he won a third term); although he had to compromise on some things, he still won many people's respect. However, though, some felt he hadn't gone far enough, and Reconstruction ended in 1880, with the election of James Tilden(who campaigned on a reconciliationist platform). Perhaps if he had died, the radicals might have had even stronger levels of support than they did in our world, and it might have lasted longer, and have been more effective.

OOC: Are you sure this was 1868, and not 1865, btw? Or is this a slightly different scenario than in OTL? Not a problem either way, TBH, just thought I'd ask.
 

Sabot Cat

Banned
This has been brought up a lot before. Learn to use the search function.


Anyway, I'd also recommend The Fall of America series for a plausible exploration of this POD.
 
This has been brought up a lot before. Learn to use the search function.


Anyway, I'd also recommend The Fall of America series for a plausible exploration of this POD.

I remember that. Murray Turtledove did a great job on that.....although, sadly, the ending to the last book in the series was kind of a downer, though. By 1908, if I recall, the U.S. was besieged by rather severe political corruption & incompetence, the Klan basically ruled the Deep South(with only Louisiana and Florida excepted) from top to bottom, and the economy was on the verge of total collapse. Did I mention, too, that we'd tried to invade Mexico, only for us to narrowly lose and were forced to pack up and go home(and Mexico was weaker than the C.S.A., too)? By the end, you couldn't help but root for Eugene Debs and the rest of the Socialists, no matter how radical some of them may have been; the Republicans were mostly milquetoasts, the Northern Democrats were hopelessly inept, the Southern Democrats were thoroughly corrupt, and the Progressives had no ideas on how to fix the country's finances.

There was quite a bit of good fanfiction on the 'Net during the '90s, which explored several possible conclusions to it all; my favorite piece was "Red Dawn", in which the Socialists took over in in the Twenties, and rebuilt the U.S.(or at least, those areas that accepted Socialist rule, which most of the South and some of the western states didn't) in their image.....although with the Dixiecrats and other nasty reactionaries festering in the background; what they tried to pull just after the end of *WWII ITTL is utterly shocking, when you think about it; how about a foiled plot to detonate a radiological device in San Francisco, for starters? But after that, though, it took a much more pleasant turn.....

OOC: Thought I might expand on the book series, if you don't mind. Also included a shout-out to Jello_Biafra's work, as well. :)
 
Last edited:
On April 14, 1868, actor John Wilkes Booth attempted to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln, failing only due to Major Rathbone happening to get up to stretch at just the right moment to force Booth's gun off-target. Though wounded, the President did recover. But what if he hadn't, or if Booth had succeeded?

Maybe it is just me but I would have thought that if, actor John Wilkes Booth, a renowned confederate and anti-unionist was able to shot the President of the Union, which in my eyes is completely ASB, the Civil War would have began again with the North demanding blood for their fallen leader, while the South saw this as their time to rise up again with General Nathan Bedford Forrest as the new Confederate President, setting up a military dictatorship.
 
On April 14, 1868, actor John Wilkes Booth attempted to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln, failing only due to Major Rathbone happening to get up to stretch at just the right moment to force Booth's gun off-target. Though wounded, the President did recover. But what if he hadn't, or if Booth had succeeded?

He did succceed. You only got the wrong year. It was 1865.
 
He did succceed. You only got the wrong year. It was 1865.

OOC: This is a Double Blind What If; it means you answer the what if from the point of view of a person from the alternate history.

IC: I wonder what President Johnson would be like as President, because if I recall he was pretty popular amongst many of the Moderate Republicans (even though he liked the drink a bit too much). Perhaps (a bit out of left field I know) he could have drawn the Democrats and Republicans closer together, especially after one of the nation's most popular presidents got assassinated.
 
Maybe it is just me but I would have thought that if, actor John Wilkes Booth, a renowned confederate and anti-unionist was able to shot the President of the Union, which in my eyes is completely ASB, the Civil War would have began again with the North demanding blood for their fallen leader, while the South saw this as their time to rise up again with General Nathan Bedford Forrest as the new Confederate President, setting up a military dictatorship.


Esp as his VP was extremely vengeful toward the Rebs, demanding that they be "punished and - - impoverished". Andrew Johnson would quickly have formed an alliance with the Radical Republicans, with Lee and Davis being hanged and others having their property confiscated. The South would be looking at a far harsher Reconstruction.
 
Top