raharris1973
Gone Fishin'
What would be the most plausible candidate country in Europe to have a "French Revolution" instead of France. The characteristics that I'm thinking of that made it unique were: atheism, regicide, republicanism, a claim for universal rights and a claim of universal validity in general.
In some dimensions you could argue the American Revolution was the first "French" Revolution, but Edmund Burke noted important differences - he saw the American grievances as more specific and grounded in local traditions, whereas the French Revolution seemed far more of a departure from the French past.
The regicide of Charles in England didn't seem as world changing at the time because it was tied in with a pre-enlightenment relgious dispute.
So, the American Revolution can happen or not happen, but I'm looking for a substitute for France in Europe.
In some dimensions you could argue the American Revolution was the first "French" Revolution, but Edmund Burke noted important differences - he saw the American grievances as more specific and grounded in local traditions, whereas the French Revolution seemed far more of a departure from the French past.
The regicide of Charles in England didn't seem as world changing at the time because it was tied in with a pre-enlightenment relgious dispute.
So, the American Revolution can happen or not happen, but I'm looking for a substitute for France in Europe.